Latest News

a, Sports

Sports 2013 Wishlist

As a huge basketball fan, it would be pretty great to see a non-superteam win the NBA Finals and hoist the Larry O’Brien trophy at the end of the season. It would validate the fact that the NBA world isn’t dominated by a couple of superstars, and that true team-basketball is still the best kind of basketball.

Remi Lu

I wish that the NBA will bring back basketball to Vancouver. Otherwise, I hope that the Brooklyn Nets continue to ascend into the ranks of the elite—beating the New York Knicks in the process—and that someone from an NCAA conference other than the SEC wins the BCS Championship Game.

Mayaz Alam

­

My wish is for the return of the Quebec Nordiques. There is an obvious thirst for more hockey in La Belle Province. Numerous NHL franchises are currently struggling. Moving one of these teams to Quebec City would eliminate an economic bottom feeder—the kind that  is bleeding money and begging for help during the lockout. Having more hockey teams in Canada is better for the league. Period.

—Trevor Drummond

I would love to see Peyton Manning and the Denver Broncos take home Superbowl XLVII, shutting down the New England Patriots in the process. As a Broncos fan, I’ve watched Peyton pick apart my team in many playoff games when he was a member of the Indianapolis Colts. A Superbowl win would more than make up for all those devastating losses.

Justin Simon

I’m blindly cheering for a drug-free Tour de France, with the ‘Manx Missile,’ Mark Cavendish, again showing that he’s the fastest thing on two wheels. Knowing I won’t make any friends with this, I’m hoping for a continued NHL lockout since it has greatly increased the coverage of sports I hold dearer and those that have improved my quality of life.

Jeff Downey

I, for one, want the NHL lockout to end soon. Not only will life be better with NHL hockey, but cancelling an entire season could prematurely end some great careers. Above all, my wish is that Daniel Alfredsson—a good person, a great leader, and a borderline Hall-of-Famer—gets to play at least one more game in the city he has adopted as his home, a city which bows at his feet.

Adam Sadinsky

Why do Raptors fans—myself included—go through this self-punishment every year? Do we watch to see Ben Uzoh record the Raptors’ only triple-double of the year; or do we watch to see the team finish in 8th place before being obliterated by Chris Bosh and the Miami Heat? Our well-dressed general manager’s time is up. This mess is his fault. In 2013, I want Bryan Colangelo expelled from the Toronto Raptors—and for good reason.

Filippo Furlano

I was born the year the Blue Jays won their first World Series. Since then, the Toronto sports scene has been fairly bleak, filled with the nasty combination of false hope and embarassment. However, with one major offseason trade, a Toronto team has finally become relevant again. My wish in 2013 is for the Blue Jays to make the MLB postseason, and remove the disappointment at the collective Toronto sports fans’ core. I don’t know if we can survive another year of mediocrity and heartbreak.

Steven Lampert

Darche is engaged in the NHL lockout negotiations. (Luke Orlando / McGill Tribune)
a, Sports

McGill NHLer weighs in on the lockout

The Tribune had the opportunity to sit down with Mathieu Darche, a McGill graduate (B.Com. ‘00) who played in the NHL last season with the Montreal Canadiens. He weighed in on his time at McGill, this year’s Redmen roster, and the current NHL lockout. 

McGill Tribune: What do you remember about your days as a McGill Redmen? 

Mathieu Darche: I went to McGill to get an education. It was the only [Canadian] school that gave me an offer. I remember all those years at McGill, those Christmas trips that we [took to] Europe and Vancouver. I think we went to Slovakia one year. I try and keep in touch with quite a few of the ex-Redmen, like my linemates from those years: Dave Gourde and Dave Grenier. [Tampa Bay Lightning assistant coach] Martin Raymond I actually still talk to today.”

MT: How closely do you follow the current McGill Redmen?

MD: To be honest, I only saw one game this year. But I’ve heard good things about that [Marc-Olivier] Vachon, and a few other kids like [Ryan] McKiernan, who was there last year [and] seems like a good character kid. I know it’s a bit of a transition year for them because they graduated a lot of players [from] last year’s [championship team]. That’s the thing with [collegiate] sports; you can’t keep your players forever.

MT: Has your McGill Management degree benefited you throughout the NHL lockout negotiations? 

MD: Well, a degree is just a piece of paper. I mean, maybe I was able to get a grasp on the financial things quicker because I did take some finance classes. [However], whatever you learn in school is nothing compared to practical work and experience. I’m getting towards the end of my playing career, and being in the business side of hockey is something that I’ve always been interested in.

MT: Do you see the NHL lockout ending anytime soon?

MD: I’ve been optimistic from the start that there [will] be hockey; and I think the players have come a long way. We sacrificed over a billion dollars in salary, and it just seems right now, like the owners want to hit a home run by getting us on the player’s share and contracting rights. Then again, I think we’re way too close to not get a deal done.

MT: Have NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman and Deputy Commissioner Bill Daly been unfair during the negotiations? 

MD: I don’t have anything personal against those two; they’re incredibly smart people, and they’re doing what the owners want them to do. They’re just the voice behind the whole [position]. Obviously, I’ll preach from [the players’] choir. I feel that we’ve made the most concessions.

MT: Were your ex-teammate Roman Hamrlik’s comments against NHLPA Executive Director Donald Fehr out of line? 

MD: I don’t want to say [out of line], [because] I understand where he’s coming from. He’s 38 years old and I’m in the same boat. Maybe I’ll never play again, who knows? And I have no problem with his opinion except for one [thing]: I’m just disappointed that he hasn’t been to any meetings. When he was in Montreal, skating with us, I tried to explain stuff to him and he wouldn’t listen. He would just say, ‘That’s stupid, that’s stupid.’ The only thing that I [can] say is that I’m a little bit disappointed that he made those comments without being informed.

MT: Is decertification for the NHLPA a realistic possibility? 

MD: It could happen. I mean, you saw the NFL and the NBA did it and they got a deal not long after. Will we do it? I don’t know yet. Has it been discussed? Of course it has. Every [possibility] has been discussed. I don’t know if we will, [but] I’d like to hope that we’ll get an agreement before doing something like that. It’s tough to predict right now if we’ll get to that or not.

MT: Does the fact that you don’t currently have an NHL contract change your perspective in these negotiations? 

MD: Well, some people told me on Twitter—because you get Twitter haters who think they’re ‘Twitter tough’—[that] ‘of course it’s easy for me to be a hardliner.’ They told me that I have nothing to lose because I don’t have a contract, but I think it’s the opposite. I have everything to lose because especially at my age [36] the longer it goes, the lower my chances are of playing again.”

 

a, Behind the Bench, Sports

Fantasy is my reality

After unloading my backpack stuffed full of books and unzipping my puffy jacket, I settle into my McLennan carrel with a Tim Hortons’ double-double for a long study session. I open up my computer, click on Safari, and type “Yahoo fantasy basketball” into the Google search bar. The results appear, and the normally blue hyperlink at the top is purple from countless clicks. An hour later, I still haven’t started my work, preferring instead to pour through Rotoworld’s fantasy updates, research hot players, or just stare at the beauty of a lineup that includes Russell Westbrook and David West.

I have always been a basketball fan. Growing up in Boston, it’s hard not to get swept up in the mania of one of the greatest sports cities in the world, especially given the past decade of success. However, I will admit that I never really paid much attention to teams other than Boston in the NBA. Barely able to divide my attention between the Celtics, Patriots, and Bruins during the winter months, there was no way, I figured, I could ever pay attention to a whole league.

Nevertheless, I live with roommates whom I would consider to be basketball fanatics, and I was approached this fall with the prospect of being in an NBA fantasy league. I eagerly accepted, thinking that it would be a fun way to pay a bit more attention to basketball—a good topic of conversation among friends.

I can honestly say now—as we’re ending the fifth week of our league—that nothing has ever consumed my waking psyche like fantasy basketball. In the mornings, the first thought that pops into my head is how my fantasy team performed the night before. It’s always the first website I go on when I open up my laptop.

Yahoo! Fantasy StatTracker—the league’s live scoring system—is probably the most distracting feature of all. In the evenings, I’ll find myself at the library, staring at the application, and waiting for a player’s name to light up and the statistics to update. Even when I’m in the comfort of my own home and done with studying for the night, I’d rather watch StatTracker than a real game on TV.

Being involved in the league has made me think about basketball in another way. Before, I was always attracted to the unorthodox combination of grace and physicality that exists in basketball: the swish of a long range three through the net, the effortless and quick motioned dribbling, and the aggressive drives to the paint. Teamwork was always a thing of beauty. But now, I curse teamwork and pray that my fantasy players selfishly jack up three balls and miss shots to grab their own offensive rebounds.

Sadly though, my allegiance to the Celtics has waned in these past few months, most evidently when a member of my fantasy team is playing them. For instance, when Boston played Oklahoma City just a few weeks ago, I was delighted that Russell Westbrook was tearing it up from behind the arc and making well-placed assists. Even in the final minutes of the game, when OKC was threatening to overtake Boston, I hoped Westbrook would tally up some late game points.

Before this fall, I could probably only name the star players on each NBA team. Now through my team, I can rattle off the two players time-sharing at centre for the Denver Nuggets, and the backup point guard for the Golden State Warriors. I eagerly await Portland Trailblazers’ games, even though they are last in their division.

Yes, final papers are weighing heavily on my shoulders, and I should spend my evenings pouring through source material, but every night around 8:00 p.m. StatTracker goes up and the rest of the night is written off as I stare at my computer, living the fantasy life.

Sharples celebrates with the Baggataway Cup. (Jishan Sharples)
a, Sports

For the boys: Sharples leaves on top

“My plan was to go to Western University to play lacrosse since grade 12,” Jishan Sharples, McGill’s graduating, and recently crowned national champion said. “I didn’t even think of going to McGill, hadn’t even visited the campus. I was sure I didn’t want to go there. But then [Head Coach Tim Murdoch] contacted me and with one 30 minute phone call, I switched right away.”

Amazingly, this one discussion with Murdoch transformed Sharples’ life. Using the captain’s desire for a premium education and a promise of a national championship in the coming years at McGill, Murdoch lured the young star recruit to Montreal. Despite Sharples’ early uncertainty, the move to McGill has undoubtedly paid off, as he scored the game winning overtime goal in the Baggataway Cup final to beat the team he was once destined to join—the Western Mustangs.

“I saw immediately that Jishan was a versatile athlete—strong, fast, and athletic,” Murdoch said. “[Yet], it is truly ironic that Jishan scored the most historic goal in our history against Western in the championships. I’m so glad he was wearing red that day instead of purple.”

Growing up in Vancouver, Sharples began playing lacrosse at just five years old, after his father got him interested in the sport. Long travel sessions to practices and games marked Sharples’ high school playing days, then a member of the Burnaby Mountain Selects, the premier travelling lacrosse program in British Columbia. The club cycles through tournaments in the United States to provide exposure for gifted lacrosse players to Divison I NCAA schools.

“There isn’t a lot of exposure in Canada, specifically for field lacrosse, which is what is played in university,” Sharples said. “In order to take it to the next level, you really need to join a travelling team. The switch really came for me in grade nine, when I joined Burnaby.” Sharples said.

The Vancouver native was recruited by 18 American institutions, in addition to his few Canadian opportunities. However, McGill’s strong lacrosse program, as well as its academic reputation, won the Sharples over.

“The best decision I ever made was becoming a Redmen,” he said.

According to Sharples, the team’s success can be attributed to the roster’s diversity and the team’s devotion to the motto “for the boys.” The team features players from all across Canada and the United States. This multi-faceted dynamic—faithfully helmed by Princeton alumnus Murdoch—presents an environment where players can mature and constantly improve. This differs dramatically from other elite Canadian programs, like Western, which recruit heavily from the local talent base.

Even this year’s national championship—where Sharples scored five goals between the semis and finals, including the game-winner in the Baggataway Cup—was a total team effort.

“The entire tournament everybody played his role­—as corny as that sounds, from offence to defence—and even though my name will be on that last goal, I’m adamant that it stands as a team one,” Sharples said. “But, it is a pretty amazing feeling … it’s the only way I wanted to end my career at McGill.”

Looking towards the future, Sharples already has opportunities. With the National Lacrosse League planning to expand the current professional scene in Canada—including a team in this city to follow the now-defunct Montreal Express—Sharples was chosen to participate in a tryout for Quebec lacrosse athletes for a chance to play in a Toronto Rock professional game in December. Although he was unsuccessful in his first bid, the tryout served as a learning experience for future endeavours should he wish to pursue them. However, the future may be far more similar to the present.

“The good thing about our league, is that there is no [eligibility] limit—so I’ve already told coach I’ll be back in some form,” Sharples said. “As long as you’re a full-time student at McGill [you’re eligible]. I’m hoping to do a dual MBA/JD program, with another four years of lacrosse.”

Looking back, Murdoch had glowing reviews of Sharples and the legacy he leaves with the program.

“I am always happy to witness young men like Jishan mature over four years on campus. He took full advantage of McGill’s academic offerings—four-year honor roll status, while enjoying himself socially in Montreal. He has always been self-motivated to achieve great things, on and off of the lacrosse field, [and] he made his own success through hard work and determination,” Murdoch said.

“Jishan is destined for continued success in whatever career path he chooses beyond McGill,” Murdoch continued. “As head coach, I have formed especially close friendships with our captains over the years, and I can say from the bottom of my heart that I will miss Jishan enormously.”

It’s safe to say Sharples made the right playing decision.

“[It’s been] the best four years of my life,” Sharples said. “An absolute roller coaster, with definitely more highs than lows, but it started the right way and ended the right way.”

McGill will compete as a co-ed team at the National Championship in August 2013. (Courtesy of McGill Tennis club)
a, Sports

McGill earns first ever nationals appearance

Three weeks ago, the McGill tennis team qualified for its first national championship. The tournament will take place in Toronto in August 2013. McGill will compete as a co-ed team, picking up the second of the two qualifying tickets from the Eastern division, along with top-seeded Western University. The teams will face off against two other universities from the Western Division,  rounding out the tournament competitors.

The co-ed format was introduced to nationals to allow teams from the Western Division, typically with smaller rosters, to enter the competition.

During the qualifying rounds, the men and women competed separately, in order to qualify for a mixed team of ten players. The University of Montreal lost its qualifying bid to McGill, even though the Carabins were heavily favoured, and have won every national title since the championships’ inception in 2009.

Alexandra Beran. (Simon Poitrimolt / McGill Tribune)
Alexandra Beran. (Simon Poitrimolt / McGill Tribune)

In the semis, the Martlets fell 4-3, but the Redmen prevailed 5-2. McGill therefore finished with a two-point cumulative advantage over the Carabins. Western University dominated the competiton, winning both the men’s and women’s draws.

The amateur tournament will be played alongside the annual professional women’s Rogers Cup at the Rexall Centre.

“As far as I know, it is unique to have a tournament that brings together the best players in the world, at the same time as university players,’’ Head Coach Adrien Dupont explained.

The upcoming nine months before nationals will require unique preparation for McGill. “[Our] next challenge is to maintain the same level of play that we have managed to rise to this semester,” Dupont said.

After losing its varsity status in 2010, the team rebuilt itself around the leadership of Dupont and a core of new players. Dupont became the head coach five years ago, while he was still playing at McGill. The team at that time was still student-run. Two years later, he reintroduced the women’s program, following its dissolution in 2008. In this Fall’s regular season, the women’s squad went undefeated for the first time.

Haytem Laaribi. (Simon Poitrimolt / McGill Tribune)
Haytem Laaribi. (Simon Poitrimolt / McGill Tribune)

“It is still a very young team, and certainly one of my greatest prides,” Dupont said.

Despite its status as a competitive club, both tennis teams were allowed to play in the same league as the seven other varsity teams from Quebec and Ontario. Now, the club’s development depends on the evolution of the sport in the province—motivation that wasn’t there just a few years ago.

To introduce an independent RSEQ conference, a minimum of four teams is required. However, Dupont hopes to see such a division created by next year. This is particularly important because being part of a provincial-only league is a requirement for a competitive club to be instated as a varsity team at McGill. McGill has scheduled winter exhibition games against Laval, Sherbrooke, and Montreal, with the intention of promoting an independent conference. It would also give McGill an opportunity to prepare for nationals in August.

“Our hope is that the exhibition season will be a success; and if so, we will be in a position to re-engage the discussion with the university [regarding the varsity status for tennis] and the three other programs to try to move forward,” Dupont said.

Michel Berthelemot. (Simon Poitrimolt / McGill Tribune)
Michel Berthelemot. (Simon Poitrimolt / McGill Tribune)

Currently, the club faces challenges of reduced publicity and university-provided financing. However, these difficulties have not undermined the team’s ability to compete for its first national title.

“Now that we are qualified, our objective is to go get our first title,” Dupont said. “It is definitely a format that gives us the opportunity to have our best men and women represent us.”

a, Opinion

Crowdsourced canards: Social media and the spread of falsehood

Over the past decade, the entire concept of social media has gone beyond the province of futurists and patent offices, to become a real and tangible part of our lives. Just as quickly, it has grown to be a trusted source of information for many. A recent study by the Pew Research Center found that more than half of Americans now get at least some of their news from social networking sites.

Some of this news is misleading, but the spread of bad information on social media is not limited to outright falsehood. More common is the sort that incites the viewer to action without context: the ‘ill-considered activism campaign.’ Quite a few of these have gained steam on social media over the years, but the most visible of all was the Kony 2012 campaign. Produced by the charity Invisible Children, the video called for the “stopping” of Ugandan warlord, Joseph Kony, and reached 100 million YouTube views in a record-breaking six days last March. It was swiftly criticized by those who had actually been following the situation in Central Africa—not just because of its lack of nuance, but also because it ignored basic facts about Kony and his Lord’s Resistance Army—such as stating they were in Uganda, when they were not.

Why the video grabbed people’s attention better than less slickly produced treatments of central African civil wars is not hard to understand. The type of person who will respond and be provoked to action by an emotionally-wrenching web video is probably not the same sort of person who will respond to an Economist piece on the issue. However, being emotionally affected to the point of wanting to share the video over social media is another story. The hybrid public-private nature of social media allows users to craft an idealized version of themselves for the consumption of their ‘friends.’ Posting and tweeting about an activist campaign can be an attempt to look both caring and ‘socially conscious’ in front of peers. Because the interest in the underlying issue to the person is fleeting and ephemeral, finding where the reality differs from the call to activism is almost irrelevant.

[pullquote]The nature of social media makes the flow of information almost frictionless after a certain threshold of attention, regardless of the veracity of the information.[/pullquote]

Another, more serious instance of the ‘crowdsourced canard’ was the spread of fake photos and news during Superstorm Sandy back in late October. Some of these included shots showing the hurricane violently bearing down on the Statue of Liberty. Even mainstream media got in on the act, reporting all manner of falsehoods: from trapped utility workers, to three feet of water on the trading floor of New York Stock Exchange. As with the photos, all of these reports spawned from social media. The problem, in this case, was twofold. When it came to the pictures being shared online, it seemed that whether the photo was true or not did not matter as much as long as it was an attention-grabbing image.

The fake reports are particularly troubling. The original claim of flooding at the NYSE originated from a facetious, or ‘troll,’ twitter handle. Once the news of flooding reached low-level journalists, however, it was stripped of that context—to the point that CNN, one of the media outlets that reported it as fact, could only trace it back to a National Weather Service messageboard. The ‘report’ came to take a life apart from its ‘reporter,’ until the most prominent media outlets that ran with the unverified information were left holding the bag.

Is there anything that can be done to stem this flow of falsehood? Probably not. The nature of social media makes the flow of information almost frictionless after a certain threshold of attention, regardless of the veracity of the information.  Perhaps the only comfort we can take from this new media reality is this frictionless flow of information; the fact-checks of both Kony 2012 and the falsehoods of Superstorm Sandy were also incited by social media. Instead of pining for a time past when the media landscape had more gatekeepers, we should look both to ourselves—the users of social media—and to the legacy media, to exercise better judgment when passing along information on these platforms.

a, Opinion

Tribune Holiday Wishlist

Heather Munroe-Blum wants to bring back “the warmth. The happiness.”

The Tribune wants the Protocol on Demonstrations, Protests, and Occupations removed immediately.

The Tribune also wants a $500,000 loan at one per cent interest. (You don’t need to know what it’s for.)

The AUS wants more students to attend its next General Assembly.

McGill Students want to know what the wooden structure outside FDA is for.

Arts Students want an Indigenous Studies Minor.

Rob Ford wants his job back.

Mitt Romney wants more binders.

Joe Biden wants a “bunch of stuff.”

Stephen Harper wants a pair of overalls just like the Biebs’.

We all want more acronyms on campus (WAWMAOC)

Josh Redel wants more ‘mood watchers’ at his next General Assembly.

The Bull and Bear doesn’t want to have to remove another article or photo.

The Daily wants to exist. (We want them to exist, too.)

McGill Football wants Bishop’s to continue using illegal players.

Joe Schwartz wants you to buy his new book.

John White and David Goltzman want you to take your vitamin D.

The Tribune wants a crossword constructor.

Arts&Entertainment wants Les Mis to be released.

Daniel Day-Lewis wants the Academy to stop wasting time and give him his Oscar already.

a, News

Senate Membership and Contacts

2012-2013 Senate Membership

(Terms start September 1)

Ex Officio
The Chancellor Arnold Steinberg
The Chair of the Board Stuart Cobbett
The Principal Heather Munroe-Blum
The Provost Anthony C. Masi
The Deputy Provost Morton Mendelson (Student Life and Learning)
Vice-Principal Michael Di Grappa (Administration and Finance)
Vice-Principal Marc Weinstein (Development and Alumni Relations)
Vice-Principal Rose Goldstein (Research and International Relations)
Vice -Principal Olivier Marcil (External Relations)
Deans of Faculties
Agricultural and Environmental Sciences Chandra Madramootoo (email)
Arts Christopher Manfredi (email)
Dentistry Paul Allison (email)
Education Hélène Perrault (email)
Engineering Andrew Kirk (interim) (email)
Law Daniel Jutras
Desautels Faculty of Management Peter Todd (email)
Medicine David Eidelman (email)
Schulich School of Music Sean Ferguson
Religious Studies Ellen Aitken (email)
Science Martin Grant (email)
Dean of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies
Martin Kreiswirth (email)
Dean of Students
Linda Jacobs Starkey (interim)
Trenholme Dean of Libraries
C. Colleen Cook
Dean of Continuing Studies
Judith Potter 
Members of the Board of Governors
Alex Kalil
Cynthia Price
Amir Raz 
Elected Members
Faculty of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences Ashraf Ismail (email)
Mark Lefsrud (email)
Michael Ngadi (email)
Martina Stromvik (email)
Faculty of Arts Brian Cowan (email)
Wilbur Jonsson (email)
John Galaty
Brendan Gillon
Allan Hepburn
Gillian Lane-Mercier
Catherine Lu
Derek Nystrom
Lydia White
Faculty of Dentistry Ji Zhang
Faculty of Education Jamshid Beheshti
Nancy Heath
Caroline Riches
Ada Sinacore
Faculty of Engineering David Covo
Frank Ferrie
David Lowther
Arun Misra
Faculty of Law David Lametti
Helge Dedek
Desautels Faculty of Management Leslie Breitner
Morty Yalovsky
Faculty of Medicine Daniel Bernard
Serge Carrier
Renzo Cecere
Claudio Cuello
Elaine Doucette
Kalle Gehring
Terence Hebert
Gary Pekeles
Melvin Schloss
Laurie Snider
Elin Thordardottir
Christina Wolfson
Edith Zorychta
Schulich School of Music Stefano Algieri
Christopher Harman
Faculty of Religious Studies Torrance Kirby
Faculty of Science Graham Bell
Gregory Dudek
Charles Gale
Peter Grütter
David Harpp
Jacques Hurtubise
Andrew Hynes
Bruce Lennox
Nigel Roulet
University Libraries  Daniel Boyer
A. Maya Kucij
Marc Richard 
Administrative and Support Staff
Group 1 Ruth Kuzaitis
Mark Michaud
Group 2 Antonia Di Paola
Kathryn Peterson
Group 3  Mary Jo McCullogh
Honora Shaughnessy 
Elected Student Members
Students’ Society of McGill University (SSMU):
(for emails, see http://ssmu.mcgill.ca/about-us/our-team/senators/)
George Azmy Engineering
Stephanie Bachelet Law
Laurence Belanger Medicine
Andrew Boudreau Music
Nikhil Srinidhi Engineering
Haley Dinel SSMU VP University Affairs
Rodrigo Espinosa Arts
Jimmy Gutman Arts
Shannon Herrick Science
Moe Nasr Science
Josh Redel SSMU President
Avi Rush Management
Max Zidel  Arts 
McGill Association of Continuing Education Students (MACES):
Isabel Vivas
Eric Laverdiere 
Macdonald Campus Students’ Association (MCSS):
Evan Henry 
Post-Graduate Students’ Society (PGSS):
Adam Bouchard
Jonathan Mooney
Boran Xu 
Medical Resident Group or Postdoctoral Scholar
Ziad El-Khatib 

http://www.mcgill.ca/senate/senate-2012-2013/senate-membership

Students demonstrate in solidarity with student movements around the world. (Sam Reynolds / McGill Tribune)
a, News

Students at Nov. 22 demonstration call for free education

On Nov. 22, students gathered in Montreal to protest in favour of free tuition and show their solidarity for student causes across the world. The protest was part of a global education strike week organized by the International Student Movement, a coordination platform for student mobilization worldwide. As part of the movement, 60,000 students across Quebec voted for strikes that varied in length from one day to the entire week, lasting from Nov. 14 to Nov. 22.

The protest was organized by  the Association pour une solidarité syndicale étudiante (ASSÉ), one of the largest student groups in Quebec. ASSÉ helped to coordinate last year’s student strikes against the former provincial Liberal government’s proposed tuition increases.

ASSÉ spokesperson Jérémie Bédard-Wien emphasized the importance of connecting Quebec students with other student movements around the world, especially now that the Parti Québécois (PQ) has repealed the tuition increases.

Sam Reynolds / McGill Tribune
Sam Reynolds / McGill Tribune

“Many movements have used us as an example of a successful struggle against tuition increases,” he said. “These movements showed us tremendous solidarity last spring, as we were facing police brutality, exclusion, and political repression. It is a chance for us today to say thank you to these movements, and demonstrate our solidarity with theirs.”

According to the International Student Movement’s website, the movement was endorsed by over 100 groups in 36 countries.

“We’re nearing a point where we’re able to effectively share tactics, [and] share methods of organization in order to make all of our movements better and more effective,” Bédard-Wien said.

Students’ Society of McGill University Vice-President External  Robin Reid-Fraser attended the protest with a small group of McGill students.

“It’s so important to remember that this kind of struggle is happening all over the world, and to show that we have these ways of creating connections and showing that solidarity, especially since the police response in many other places can be even more severe than here in Quebec,” she said.

Starting at Victoria Square, the protest wound through downtown Montreal, before ending at Parc Émilie Gamelin. Although the Service de police de la Ville de Montréal (SPVM) declared the protest illegal because the organizers did not disclose their planned route, SPVM announced that they would allow the protest to continue as long as no criminal acts were committed. No arrests were made.

Bédard-Wien emphasized that free education will continue to be the theme of ASSÉ’s campaign as the organization looks towards the provincial education summit that the PQ is planning for February.

Sam Reynolds / McGill Tribune
Sam Reynolds / McGill Tribune

“We want the summit to be a place [where] the university community as a whole [can meet], and not [just] economic elites,” he said. “We also want the summit to be a place where we can talk about the fundamental orientations of our education system.”

On Nov. 8, ASSÉ submitted several requests to the provincial government about the way the summit will be run. These included the concern that the chosen themes of discussion do not allow for a conversation about the mission of educational institutions.

Last Sunday, ASSÉ announced that they will participate in the summit, despite not having received a response from the government regarding these requests. The organization will also hold a protest during the summit, however, and will leave the discussions they feel decisions have been made in advance.

At the Nov. 22 protest, many students expressed concerns over the effectiveness of the upcoming education summit. Thomas Sallá, a student at Le cégep du Vieux Montréal, said he hopes the education summit can be an effective way of addressing student issues. However, he emphasized that continued student mobilization is necessary to keep pressure on the government.

“I hope we’ll keep this level of mobilization, because we can accomplish great things by staying ready to go back in the streets,” Sallá said. “I hope we’ll keep this fighting spirit.”

a, News

Poor advertising suggested as cause of low AUS GA turnout

On Monday night, the Arts Undergraduate Society (AUS) failed to meet quorum at its Fall General Assembly (GA). The GA passed several motions as a consultative forum, including motions mandating AUS support for accessible education and for  the AUS to help promote departmental GAs.

The AUS began holding GAs in Fall 2011. Last semester, over 1,000 students attended its spring GA as a contentious general strike motion was on the agenda as part of a larger student movement opposing provincial tuition fee increases. Multiple rooms were required to accommodate all participants.

Because this week’s GA did not meet quorum, successful motions will serve as recommendations to the AUS Council. In order for the GA to pass binding resolutions, 150 arts students must be present. Approximately 30 to 35 people were present for Monday’s GA, which ran for about two hours.

Some attendees suggested that Monday’s low turnout may have resulted from a lack of advertising. Arts Representative to the Students’ Society of McGill University (SSMU) Claire Stewart-Kanigan said the use of flyers and more classroom announcements could have helped raise awareness. She also pointed to the fact that the motions were only made available to AUS members a few hours before the GA began.

“[Classroom announcements] provide the opportunity for more discussion between the AUS and our constituents about what’s going to be brought up at the GA and these motions for us,” Stewart-Kanigan said.  “I do wish that the motions would have been made available to AUS members ahead of time. … A General Assembly might not spark [students’] interest, but one of the motions might.”

Alexandra Allaire / McGill Tribune
Alexandra Allaire / McGill Tribune

However, AUS Vice-President Communications Yasmeen Gholmieh said the AUS used multiple methods of promotion, including posters, emails, and social media tools, and could not have done much more in the way of advertising.

“I think the GA was well-advertised, and it’s a shame that we had such a low turnout,” she said. “We advertised to the point where some people actually contacted us, saying we should stop sending out emails about the GA.”

Gholmieh expressed concern about the criticisms the AUS executive team faced from students at the GA, both during and after the event.

“Both SSMU and AUS General Assemblies have faced issues with low student turnout in the past, and I think it is unfair to blame the low turnout only on the VP Communications,” she said. “I, along with the Chief Returning Officer and the President, did our best to advertise the GA. In the future, we will start advertising it sooner.”

The consultative forum passed five motions, which dealt with facilitating increased departmental democracy by encouraging departmental GAs, lobbying McGill to free the university from financial ties to fossil fuels, opposing Plan Nord, and opposing Canadian aggression towards Iran. Many of these motions were originally discussed at the SSMU GA earlier this year.

The forum also discussed a motion mandating support for accessible education. The motion passed following an amendment by SSMU Vice-President External Robin Reid-Fraser, which included a clause mandating that “the AUS lobby McGill University to refund the tuition still pending to out-of-province and international students.”

A motion regarding the creation of a “Students Helping Students” fund was tabled indefinitely. The motion sought to re-allocate pre-existing funds from AUS student fees. If passed, $0.75 per student, each semester, would be assigned to the creation of a fund that could help students financially affected by a student strike.

Students at the consultative forum expressed concern over the specifics of how and to whom the funds would be delegated, as well as what would happen to the funds if a strike were not called in a specific year. Nicole Georges, arts representative to SSMU, called for amendments to address these concerns.

“I have a concern with the ability [of present and future] AUS executives … to be giving away money like this,” she said. “Is there going to be somebody surveying the AUS executive to make sure that the money goes toward people who are deserving?”

Lily Schwarzbaum, U3 arts, said she found the discussion and proposed amendments to the motion problematic.

“I think amendments are not the place to lay out step-by-step execution plans,” Schwarzbaum said. “[Motions] are mandates that are for representatives who are elected in order to sit through longer meetings.”

Since the motions only passed as recommendations, they will be brought to the next AUS Council on Nov. 28, when councillors will vote to either reject or adopt them.

Read the latest issue

Read the latest issue