Latest News

News

AUS attacks its debts

In the face of numerous unanticipated financial difficulties that have come to light this semester, the Arts Undergraduate Society’s Executive unveiled their Financial Recovery Plan to the AUS Council last Wednesday.

“Like the real Marshall Plan, this isn’t just us throwing foreign aid at something,” he said. “It’s a plan to allow all parties to recover themselves.”

In addition to the deficit of approximately $30,000 incurred by Frosh, the AUS owes $18,000 to both the federal and provincial governments in back taxes, as well as $83,000 to the Faculty of Arts due to the organization’s failure to pay their share of the Arts Student Employment Fund.

The Marshall Plan, which is based around the four tenets of accountability, automation, solvency, and growth and partnership, is designed to address the AUS’s current financial challenges and to ensure that similar issues do not occur in the future. The first step in this process, Marshall said, was re-evaluating the organization’s business partnerships both within and outside of McGill. The assessment resulted in the dismissal of the AUS’s former accountant and the hiring of RSM Richter, a professional accounting firm, to manage the society’s books.

“One of the main advantages that attracted us to RSM Richter was the fact that they were able to provide us not only with an audit service, but with an entire team, a team that includes a tax attorney, legal advisors, and an accounting service,” said Majd al-Khaldi, AUS VP finance.

Thanks in part to RSM Richter’s negotiations, the AUS’s federal tax debt is now settled. While Marshall is still in negotiations with the provincial government, he said he is hopeful that situation will soon be remedied as well.  

“We’re now reaching out and trying to get help, because we’ve realized that the traditional perspective of … some student leaders … to kind of take on challenges and … refuse to ask questions, has been damaging for the AUS,” Marshall said.

In addition to revisiting the AUS’s accounting structure, al-Khaldi and Marshall have been working with the group’s banking institution, the Royal Bank of Canada, to revisit the AUS’s investments. According to al-Khaldi, this is long overdue.

“The AUS has had investments in the past, and since the financial crisis I would hazard to guess that they weren’t revised properly,” he said. “In that sense, we haven’t been using our money to its fullest potential.”

Marshall also emphasized the assistance the AUS has received from the Faculty of Arts administration, particularly with regards to the debt they owe on the Arts Student Employment Fund.  

“With regards to ASEF, we do have the dean’s support for a payment plan, so that’s going to be paid over the next few years,” Marshall said.

“The Faculty has had discussions with the AUS about the Arts Student Employment Fund, and we are working together on a plan that ensures that students continue to benefit from the Fund and allows AUS to meet its obligations without putting further stress on its cash flow situation,” said Dean Christopher Manfredi of the Faculty of Arts in email to the Tribune. “Student associations are independently incorporated entities whose relationship to the university is governed by memoranda of agreement. For the most part, the relationship should be governed by the provisions of these agreements, but everyone obviously has an interest in collaborating to ensure that funds are properly administered.”

Despite the difficulties they have faced this year, both Marshall and al-Khaldi emphasized that all student organizations can learn from the AUS’s experience. To help ensure that a similar situation doesn’t affect another campus group, the Executive is working on a document that will outline standard financial, legal, and tax procedures for student-run corporations in Quebec.  

“For legal purposes, we all have to be companies, but we aren’t great at running them, clearly,” Marshall added. “I’m hoping to share this with all student associations because there’s a huge benefit to sharing this sort of thing. I don’t want anyone else to ever have to go through the experience we went through with all of this. But it’s a great year. Student services haven’t been affected except in the positive.” 

Student Life

Back to blog basics

Cooking is a science, and a fun and delicious one at that. And like any science, experimentation is key.  Julia Child meticulously tested her recipes, which is why they’re still the heart and soul of so many kitchens. Unfortunately, Child is partly to blame for the plethora of food blogs on the Internet. Julia and Julia gave hope to food bloggers everywhere that they too might make a mess of their kitchen (and their marriage) and turn it into a feature film. These blogs present a challenge for competent cooks, who may follow a blog’s recipe to the teaspoon, but end up with polenta that’s as hard as concrete.  

Good food bloggers find a recipe, decide to change something and then see if it works. If not, they repeat the process until it does, and then the post their results. Just like a lab report, they outline their cooking methods in detail so that other cooks can predict potential problems.  

Bad food bloggers find a recipe, incorrectly or incompletely copy it onto their blog, and make changes that aren’t scientific or practical. Worst of all, when their soufflé collapses mid-making, they post a stolen photo of a perfect soufflé and write that while their effort didn’t turn out perfectly, it was delicious.  

Like most university students, I don’t have the money to purchase Jacques Pepin’s cookbook series, but I would like to know how make a French omelet or perfect dinner rolls. Scouring the web for a recipe usually results in hits from several dozen food blogs, but here are some of the ones you should trust:  

Smitten Kitchen: With hundreds of tried-and-true recipes from Deb Perelman’s five years of blogging and cooking available on the website, you’re sure to find what you need fast. Perelman is honest about her mistakes, and always tries to find ways to improve her work. Her wry sense of humor and tiny New York City kitchen are easy to relate to for just about any cook.  

Living the Sweet Life in Paris: David Lebovitz, former pastry chef of Chez Panisse, shares his expertise in pastries and savory cooking on his website. Having trained in Paris and worked in the U.S., Lebovitz can help you bring the best of the culinary world to your student apartment kitchen.  

Real Baking with Rose: Rose Levy-Beranbaum, the legend behind The Cake Bible, has all of her recipes available on her website, and blogs about her latest experimentations. An expert on all things baking, she prizes scales over volume measurement, and it pays off. Best of all, she answers readers’ questions daily. For perfect cookie, cake, pastry, and bread recipes, go to realbakingwithrose.com

The Best Dishes: Former Tribune writer Francesca Ferenzi can sympathize with university students who have small kitchens and budgets, but big culinary dreams. After studying abroad in Italy, Ferenczi knows what good food is, and how to make it on a dime. Ferenzi finds amazing restaurant food and then recreates it herself. Follow her food adventures at frenchietbd.com.

The Front Burner: For all you vegetarians out there, Emily Malone’s blog offers healthy, simple, and delicious recipes. Since Malone is a recent graduate of a prestigious American culinary school, you can be certain the recipes you find here won’t be disappointing. Malone also includes an occasional gratuitous photo of her two adorable dogs.

Ceci n’est pas un food blog: Although not limited to the traditional recipe only format of other food blogs, as the title so clearly insists, former Tribune editor Vincci Tsui provides the occasional recipe along with the blog’s other food and nutrition related posts. A Registered Dietician currently living in Calgary, Tsui often includes information on the nutritional content of the recipes she posts, but doesn’t limit herself to salads and granola. Her recipe for Margarita Cupcakes is especially amazing.

Science & Technology, Student Life

Suprising space savers

During exams, your apartment is probably going to end up looking like the site of a pipe bomb explosion. It also means you won’t have the time or money to make another trip to Ikea for assorted Scandinavian organizing junk. Instead, some ordinary household objects can be used to tidy up and manage the ever growing mess that is your desk while making your cheap lifestyle a little easier.

Binder clips -> cord holder

Binder clips are great for just about anything, including keeping those pesky power cords tied up. The more appliances you have, the more tangled the mess around the surge protector becomes. By fastening a binder clip to the edge of a table and running the head of the cord through the clip’s handle, the cord becomes retractable and stays put. String eight or ten of these together for a nice, tidy power station.

Book -> eBook case

The biggest complaint about eBook readers is that “I don’t get the same feeling I do when I read a book.” Problem solved: glue the pages of an old book together, carve out a nook using a kitchen knife, and conceal the eBook reader inside. If you choose War and Peace, the new, stylish case for your reader both protects it from damage and makes you look a lot smarter while reading Twilight. Who knows, it might even rekindle your interest in reading.

Wire -> cable fastener

I’ve got more electronics in my apartment than a Best Buy. This creates a spaghetti style traffic jam when I try to manage which cables belong where. Using old bits of electrical wire to manage the scrambled mess makes this task a lot easier. By rolling up a cord and winding some wire around both ends, you can prevent it from getting tangled up when it’s stored, or you can shorten the cord so that the excess doesn’t get in the way. You can also do this to bind several cables together when running them from A to B.

Old beer cans -> pencil cups

Don’t toss those old PBR beer cans just yet—you can reuse them to hold pens, pencils, and anything else you like. By carving off the top of the can, lining it with electrical tape to protect from sharp edges, and weighing the whole assembly down with a counter-weight rock, you can create a quick and cheap pencil cup for your desk.

Old CDs -> coaster

If you’re too cheap to buy coasters, you can steal them from bars, or you can just use old CDs. By putting a bit of tape across the centre hole, the CD should catch all of the condensation that forms on the drink, preventing it from damaging your nice Ikea table. The best candidates for the job are old Windows install CDs and Justin Bieber albums.

Opinion

Hipsters aren’t hipsters

Nowadays, it seems that when a subculture springs up it’s given a name before a proper definition. Remember the word “emo?” All of a sudden there was an umbrella term for a group made up of wildly different characteristics: Dashboard Confessional fans lumped in with The Cure fans, people who wear scarves indoors on top of their Penguin polos coupled with guys wearing black nail polish and mascara.

But emo took an ugly turn and became a derogative term, meaning a person whose state of mind involves any combination of being sensitive, sad, whiny, and self-centred. And that’s only my interpretation—everyone’s is different.

Thankfully, emo has fallen out of common use. But the past couple years have seen the explosive popularity of an equally problematic term: hipster. What originally was synonymous with “trendy” has largely become a derisive term for a smug and inauthentic person who’s into liking things because they’re current, ironic, and are, or appear, inexpensive (drinking Pabst Blue Ribbon is about half the battle).

But for the most part, what people find off-putting about this imagined hipster persona is the same thing that people scorn in any style or subculture: an all-for show mentality. Droves of guys wearing deep v-necks with sparkly patterns on them and $300 jeans, and people who own a rainbow of Chuck Taylors and paid money for anything with an anarchy symbol on it all send the same message, and nobody likes a poser.

But what about the real hipsters? You know, the ones who have been wearing the same wool Christmas sweater since junior high (when their grandma knitted it for them) and started listening to Broken Social Scene back when “Lady Marmalade” was your favourite song? The term hipster leaves out real hipsters, because in order to be a called a hipster you have to not really be a hipster, capish? The term completely misses the mark, and it’s time to put it to rest in the annoying phrase graveyard next to “uber” and “raise the roof!”

Letters to the Editor, Opinion

Letter to the Editor

First of all, thank you for the support you’ve shown the Architecture Cafe. It is greatly appreciated, as information is what really empowers students on campus.

However, I am writing concerning last week’s article: “Architecture Café shut down by McGill.” I am sure that the subject had been researched prior to publishing, but there are certain errors which need immediate correction. Katherine Messina is not the current president of the ASA, and her opinions do not necessarily reflect those of the association. Study space is obviously a valuable resource within the campus that is often taken for granted. But the Architecture Cafe represented much more than a mere study space. Although many students balanced coffee cups on stacks of textbooks, it also provided an opportunity to socialize, relax, and grab a decent meal.

Student-run initiatives offer many benefits not covered by the basic curriculum, and give students a chance to bring about positive change within the McGill community. I look forward your continued support in this matter.

—Kyle Burrows, ASA President

McGill, News

McGill Opens New Centralized Service Point for Administrative Needs

McGill opened a new integrated service point in the recently renovated basement of the McLennan Library, designed to centralize administrative services for students.

After nearly five years of planning and development, the $4.9 million renovation has created a new space offering assistance with registration and Minerva, the issuing of McGill ID cards, and various transcript services.

“This project really is more than just about the renovation,” said Kathleen Massey, McGill’s registrar and executive director of enrolment services. “Students have complained about red tape and have complained about run-around, and despite the fact that most people have put their hearts and souls into trying to create very good services, it wasn’t addressing the run-around.”

The service center has brought together several services that were previously spread across campus, including offices in the James Administration Building and the Brown Student Services Building.

The Principal’s Task Force on Student Life and Learning endeavoured to end this run-around and create a centralized office with a team of staff members that could provide almost every service from one desk counter.

“The whole point behind this service point was really to rethink how we delivered services. Not just where we delivered services, but how we did that,” Massey said.

“Really, this project is not just about the bricks and mortar,” Massey added. “It’s really about rethinking how we provide services and trying to make those services much more convenient for students.”

The new service point is located at 3415 McTavish St. across from the McGill Bookstore and is open Monday to Friday from 9:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.

Student Life

Overheard @ SSMU

In anticipation of the new school year, the Tribune sat down with SSMU’s executives to see what they accomplished over the summer and what big items are on their plate for the coming year. Our photographers, meanwhile, asked them to physically demonstrate their eagerness to spend long hours at their desks in the Shatner Building. The results were spectacular.

 

Zach Newburgh – President

What are your long-term goals for the year?

Essentially, to build a community together, to improve accessibility to the SSMU and to give green and sustainable initiatives a chance on campus. So, really thinking big, and that’s the acronym I gave during the campaign. The campaign may have won, but we’re going to need everyone as partners in this initiative.

In your campaign, you talked about GA reform. Is that something you will be working on this year?

That’s something that I’m definitely interested in. First of all, we need to set up a committee to review the General Assembly. See if it’s something that’s worthwhile, review its purpose and see if we’ve been fulfilling that aim. But certainly, the GA is a first-come, first-serve democracy. We like to flaunt it as direct democracy, but the reality is, it isn’t. We want to make it accessible to every single student on this campus, not just to the first 600 to show up to a room full of angry antagonistic individuals. I’d like to see the creation of town halls prior to a GA so we can address the issues at hand, hear debate and post that online.

Is there anything that your predecessor did last year that you are looking to change or to continue doing?

Ivan Neilson did a tremendous job in restructuring our organization. He led this initiative to revamp our committee terms of reference. He established various sets of committees and he also removed some that were obsolete. Generally, Ivan set a positive atmosphere in the office. I’d like to bring that atmosphere outside the office, making sure that the SSMU executive and the SSMU organization is known to students and is loved by students all across this campus.

McGill has never really had much school spirit or pride, but this seems to be something you want to change. Do you think that students are not open to creating pride, or that it has just never been done?

I would say that the student experience at McGill University is mediocre at best. There are few things that the administration and the students do together, but the administration doesn’t show support for us although they have the intention. Our intention is to create school spirit.

 

Anushay Khan – VP Clubs & Services

What did you accomplish over the summer?

I finished up a lot of projects that Sarah Olle had been working on. We finished the student lounge, which hopefully looks good. We’re still working on that. We finished the new meeting room next to the Lev Bukhman Room.

I worked on the SSMU Handbook and a lot of other publication materials. I revamped all the brochures and informational material. I also made it a point to start working on the website. It’s taken a lot longer than expected.

What are your top priorities this year?

For clubs, I think that in the past clubs have felt a little alienated from SSMU—that the bureaucracy was a little difficult to work through. I’m putting more forms online this year. That’s always beneficial. With services, it’s the McGill name and issues of liability [brought up by the McGill administration].

I’ve also been working with Zach Newburgh and Josh Abaki about getting meal card readers in the [SSMU} building, so that students in their first year can actually use their meal card plan in the building. That hasn’t been done in the past, and I think it could be really beneficial.

Did your experience working as interest group coordinator last year help you hit the ground running?

I think there’s a lot to learn in this job, because the portfolio is split between three very different areas. You run the building, you have publications and you have clubs and services. For me, clubs was very easy, because I had been doing that. I knew every club like the back of my hand.

 

Nick Drew – VP Finance & Operations

What are your long-term goals for this year?

One of my long-term goals was to kind of help create the new Gerts, which is undergoing some renovations. I want to phase the renovations out over three years because there’s a lot of money that needs to be invested in it to make it look the way the people that created the new designs intended. We basically need to amortize these costs so that we can do a really good job, because there’s nothing worse than trying to do something very half-assed and going too fast. We’re yet to get the new actual floor plan in the works because [the designers] sent us a few designs and they look too modern. It didn’t look like a bar that would appeal to the average student. So that was a bit of a discouragement.

Is there anything from previous years that you plan to continue doing?

Something I want to continue, which my predecessor did a very good job of, is tying the faculties together, getting them into SSMU and being more friendly [to one another] and giving a face to Gerts. Gerts did really well because the faculties were really into coming in and doing their events there. That’s something I definitely want to continue.

Do you foresee any obstacles in the upcoming year?

One of the obstacles we’ve [already] had to overcome was getting a lease on the SSMU Building from McGill and that was kind of worrisome when we first got into office. But [negotiations have gone well], and that’s good for us because now we know we can start investing in projects that will help the building and increase efficiency, especially concerning our energy audit, from which our score was not that high. But there is still a lot of room for improvement to make this building a lot more green.

 

Tom Fabian – VP Internal

What are your long-term goals for the year?

To make sure we have some big events at SSMU, I created two new events that have never been done before. To promote them throughout the year, I have a campaign called the “Get Ready” campaign. I’ve created a website that is sort of a forum for these six big events that I have for the year. I wanted to create hype on the website throughout the year for each event. I also want to foster a diversity of different, smaller events that are easier to put together through Gert’s or through whatever other means that I have.

In your election platform, you mentioned that you wanted to get students more involved. Is that something you are doing just through these events or do have other plans to get students more involved as well?

I want to get students involved in the event planning as well. In my committee, anyone who wants to can join in, and we’ll make a committee structure and make sure there’s lots of people involved in the planning process so that we have a lot of student input on how things should run. I’m also contacting a lot of different faculty and departmental student associations to see what kind of events they want to put on and get them involved in planning events, and I can help out since SSMU has the resources to do that.

Is there anything that your predecessor did last year that you might want to do differently?

On the events side, I delegate a lot, so I get a lot of people involved and I just make sure it runs smoothly. In the end, it’s a student-run event, so what’s the worst that could happen? It’s not like we’re professional party planners
who are contracted out. So, I don’t have a lot of stress in general because I get a lot of people to do a lot of different things and it all comes together. I’m really working on getting in contact with a lot of students, as many as I can, because that’s basically what the VP Internal’s for – talking to students, making sure students know who I am so they can come to me with anything.

 

Myriam Zaidi – VP External Affairs

What did you work on over the summer?

I have been working with the Post-Graduate Students’ Society a lot to see what kind of strategies we can adopt this year regarding tuition increases and the ideas that our principal is pushing for regarding tuition increases. I have also been working a lot with TaCEQ, we have created a plan of action for the year which is really great because this is the first time this is done. Finally, I did a lot of studying about what is going on and how to counter what is going on, so I learned a lot.

What will be your strategy to prevent tuition increases?

Informing students, especially since [the tuition freeze was lifted] in 2007. For about three years there was not much being done, there was no “threat” from the government or anyone else so we lost a lot of the people since then. Back in 2007, there were a lot of students who were informed and mobilized regarding the de-freeze, so now we have to start back from almost scratch and inform students about the consequences of tuition increases as well as other alternatives. So it’s going to be a very informative year.

How will you incorporate TaCEQ with the external portfolio and SSMU?

Since each VP external of the four member’s associations are the Board members of TaCEQ I can’t incorporate it to SSMU, we are already incorporated. But SSMU is working on the TaCEQ’s website, we are going to make an English version, since the previous website/blog was not up-to-date and with no English page. We are also going to promote the English acronym which is QSR (Quebec Student Roundtable). It’s going to be less complicated for students to hear and that’s what it means. Also I’m inviting a lot of members of SSMU, making them aware of the meetings that we have each month. I’m also perfectly bilingual, so I love interpreting or translating for students who do not understand.

 

Joshua Abaki – VP University Affairs

What did you work on over the summer?

Some of the things I established as my priorities for the year, for example keeping the libraries open longer […] Now McLennan will be open 24 hours a day from the third week of the term until the end of the year.

I have also been working on work-study. Normally we have quite a few students apply and not enough positions, so I launched a summer research project to see where we can increase student employment, and we have already started to increase the number of students employed.

Another thing is the off-campus support program for off-campus students. The idea is for students who live off-campus to have fellows depending on where they live to provide support and keep students connected. That program is now up and running.

How are you planning to get more people sitting on SSMU’s committees?

I made a call out to students to apply to sit on committees and I received over 60 applications and they are already filled. That is also one of my priorities: to get a good base of students who represent the McGill body. I’m excited, since a lot of them seem very enthusiastic and they bring great ideas into committees. It’s a great way to get involved.

What strategies are you planning on using to get the administration not to increase tuition?

We launched a summer research project on the self-funded tuition model to help us at least counter the administration’s arguments for self-funded models.

The other thing is getting students to raise their voices about the tuition increase, as well as show that it is contrary to McGill’s commitment to improve the university within the student body. So mobilizing senators and students as well as meeting with the administration.

News

J-Board dismisses petition against Newburgh

In a June 24 decision, the Students’ Society Judicial Board dismissed the petition put forward by the McGill chapter of Solidarity for Palestinian Human Rights against Zach Newburgh, the former speaker of SSMU Council.

In the factum submitted last March, SPHR claimed that as chair of last winter’s General Assembly, Newburgh, who is now the SSMU president, placed himself in a conflict of interest. The factum alleged that this conflict of interest stemmed from the fact that at the time of the GA, Newburgh simultaneously held the position of speaker and president of Hillel Montreal. Because of this, SPHR claimed that Newburgh did not act impartially, particularly during debate over the motion re: The Defence of Human Rights, Social Justice and Environmental Protection.

More specifically, SPHR took issue with the allowance of amendments to preamble clauses, which broke precedent from previous GAs. Newburgh contended, however, that Robert’s Rules of Order, which the SSMU Constitution binds GAs to follow, permit such amendments.

During the case, the J-Board sought to determine first and foremost whether or not Newburgh fulfilled his constitutional duty as speaker. They asserted that only if it was found that Newburgh had violated Roberts’ Rules would they investigate whether this failure to do so was the result of bias or a conflict of interest. Citing specific clauses from Roberts’ Rules that allow for preamble clauses to be amended, the J-Board determined that Newburgh had fulfilled his duties as bound by the constitution, and therefore dismissed the petition.

Newburgh, for his part, was happy with the decision on a personal level as well as for the clarification it provided regarding GAs.

“I’m glad that my name has been cleared of wrongdoing, and I think that a little more light was shed on the conflict of interest policy that we have,” he said. “This was a re-affirmation that General Assemblies and our various governing bodies are governed by Robert’s Rules of Order and not by precedent.”

Justyn Teed, SPHR VP finance, said that although the organization is disappointed that their petition was dismissed, they hope that the incident will serve as a tool for preventing similar disputes in the future.

“While we are disappointed with the decision, we understand that it was a complicated issue, with many different factors coming into play,” Teed wrote in an email to the Tribune. “We hope that we were able to raise awareness about the potential for bias within the General Assembly procedures to prevent any occurrences in future years.”

In addition to the specific decision in the case, SPHR v. Newburgh may have a larger impact on the rules that govern the J-Board as a whole. J-Board rules state that any petition must be submitted within 10 days of an incident. However, after consulting with the Board within a week of the GA, SPHR filed their initial factum after the 10-day period. While such an extension is under the purview of the J-Board, Newburgh said that a committee will be formed this year in order to examine the rules that govern the J-Board as an institution.

“There were many issues with the J-Board from the last year, and in particular the acceptance of this case,” he said. “So we’re going to be working over the course of this next year to set up a committee to look at the rules that govern the judicial board, for the reason that they should be accountable to certain rules and procedures.”

Ivan Neilson, last year’s SSMU president, agreed that the arbitrary nature of the rules that govern J-Board often provide the justices with too much discretion.

“The rules are fairly out of date simply because they haven’t been looked at in depth for a long time. Particularly last year, we saw where, or how much, discretion is really left to the Judicial Board,” he said. “We have a whole series of rules, and then what happens depends on the circumstances. the J-Board can choose to ignore those rules altogether.”

Despite the result of the case, Teed said he was confident that SPHR will be able to work productively with the SSMU during the school year.

“The Judicial Board made its ruling and we have accepted that ruling; we have no reason to believe that Zach will let the J-Board influence his future decisions and we are looking forward to a professional relationship in the coming year,” he said.

Newburgh echoed the sentiment, and assured that SSMU would hold no personal vendetta against the group.

“I think now that the case is settled, there is now headway for us to really build a strong relationship and I hope that SPHR will take the opportunity to get close with this year’s executive,” he said. “Just like every other club on campus they are a very integral part of our community, and if we’re going to build a community together we’re going to need their hand in partnership.”

Student Life

Library Reviews: Episode 4 – Redpath

flickr.com

Redpath isn’t so much a library as a hallway with some desks set up in it. The main study space in Redpath lies in the high-traffic connection between McLennan and the  cafeteria/Cybertheque. The library houses some of the more technology-based parts of the library system, such as computer labs, film viewing rooms, and laptop checkouts. The hallway also often has pictures of things, which I’ve yet to actually stop and look at.

Noise Level – Because Redpath is situated on the main route between cafeteria and McLennan, it can get quite loud. Many users of the hallway are on their seventh study break in the last hour, and are having an urgent conversation about the sweet party they went to last night. With little protection between the actual hallway and the study space, the noise level more strongly resembles that at a coffee shop than a library. Bottom Line: The R in Redpath probably stands for “really loud.” (1/5)

Accessibility – Like McLennan and Cybertheque, Redpath is easy to get to, and perhaps a bit easier to find than, say, Cybertheque. The opening hours match those of McLennan, currently open 24 hours. The main issue that users might find is that, due to the small number of spaces, it can be quite busy. In fact, the first two times I went, I wasn’t able to find a seat. There doesn’t seem to be enough space to meet the demands of users. Bottom Line: Easy to get to and open late, Redpath is pretty accessible, if you can find a seat, that is. (3/5)

Study Setup – The desks in Redpath are similar to those in McLennan and Cybertheque, with dividers separating most spaces. It’s easy to get in the zone when you’re studying here, as the desks give you a sense of independence from the people around you. The lack of computers makes it unusable for those looking to do computer-based work without laptops. Bottom Line: Redpath has some nice desks and chairs, which help you get into a study mood, but no computers are a problem for some. (4/5)

Facilities – Redpath is near the cafeteria, which is just downstairs. It’s also close to downtown, much like McLennan or Cybertheque. The bathrooms just across the hallway aren’t hard to find, but a bit limited in size, much like the library itself. Bottom Line: You need not travel too far for a study break when you’re at Redpath. (4/5)

Décor – Redpath’s setting is much like McLennans, but without the bonus of being able to look out the window at a nice setting. Rather, the window overlooks smokers taking a break. The library features the same, unattractive concrete as McLennan. The only saving feature is the interesting exhibits set up in the hallway. Bottom Line: The Redpath experience is certainly not enhanced by the unappealing décor. (1/5)

Overall Appeal – Redpath seems to be one of the more popular libraries on campus, for reasons I can’t determine. The main draw is the nice desks, allowing studiers to escape the world around them. The poor location is the cause of most of the problems that plague the library. The library is generally unexciting. Bottom Line: Redpath doesn’t offer anything unique or great in terms of campus libraries. (2/5)

Total Score: 15/30 [4th]

Strengths: Study Setup, Facilities

Weaknesses: Noise Level, Décor, Overall Appeal

Read the latest issue

Read the latest issue