Latest News

(Alain Leloup—Boulevard Saint-Laurent. 1980-1982 / Courtesy of CCA)
a, Arts & Entertainment

MTL: then and now

ABC:MTL’s urban series is in the final stages of the alphabet, with a collection titled Streetview now showing alongside a third wave of projects exhibited at the Canadian Centre for Architecture (CCA). While the months-long ABC works have been crowd-sourced from the Montreal masses, the photos in the exhibit have been selected from material in the CCA collection, and feature artists’ nostalgically tinged perspectives on the city. The chosen photographs, all 20th century prints predominantly in black and white, honestly display Montreal’s lovably bizarre pastiche of old and new architecture, gritty dilapidation, and natural beauty.

Parts of Montreal are instantly recognizable, yet obviously aged. A wall on the east side of the octagon by Alain Leloup displays Boulevard Saint-Laurent’s early ’80s commercial diversity. The photos feature head-on pedestrian views of a Spanish bookstore, a Portugese record store, and an Italian bike shop; their international origins proudly displayed on loud shop signs. Across the room, a series of 1958 shots by André Blouin hint more aggressively at rapid change. The series gives a panoramic perspective of Boulevard Dorchester, but the individual frames that compose the series appear as if they were taken from the window of a speeding car, perhaps due to the prominent asphalt foreground.

On the other hand, the age of some subjects is only betrayed by the colour tone of their prints. A series of black and white ’70s residential architecture prints by David Miller, Gabor Szilasi, and CCA founder Phyllis Lamert features handsome houses with humble titles: 4178-4185 Avenue Parc-Lafontaine, or Angle Rue Drolet et Rue Gilford. The houses’ aesthetics are all that is displayed here; cultural context and people are removed from the scene, lending a certain permanence to the structures. One hopes it is still possible to enter the names of the works into Google Maps, and witness this architecture in the present day.

This sentiment is present in the remainder of the works: photographs of the Old Port and Mount Royal. Melvin Charney’s 1956 canals and factories have an ominous grandeur that one still senses when walking by the St. Lawrence, or through Mount Royal park on a foggy evening, the latter of which is captured by Robert Burley in the large Chemin Olmsted. Burley’s other views of the hill are gentler, capturing the dreamy beauty of shadow setting down its slope, or its winding forest paths in ’90s colour prints. At the end of the Mount Royal series is Szilasi’s Angle Rue Cote-Des-Neiges et Avenue Des Pins, a hillside view from the ’70s, with people bustling underneath a mixture of old housing and brand new commercial offices. It serves well as a final photo in the series, reflecting a literal intersection between nature, culture, and business that defines the metropolis.

On the first page of  ABC:MTL’s guestbook, a visitor on its opening night complains, “Why are your exhibition walls dirty and unfinished? Do you have $$$ for sandpaper and paint? This does not look like a finished exhibition.” While the octagonal gallery which hosts Streetview is finely polished, ladders and fixtures lean against unused walls in the recently installed “Stage C” of ABC:MTL, which opened simultaneously. Another guestbook scribbler gives the CCA the benefit of the doubt, asking “are Montreal’s walls finished?” and he’s right—whether because of urban planning, graffiti, or delayed construction scandals, Montreal seems to be in a state of perpetual development. Streetview’s success lies in its selection of photographs that lay bare a sometimes banal, often broken, but always beautiful city, giving a historical context to the ultramodern displays in the rest of the project.

Streetview runs alongside ABC:MTL at the Canadian Centre for Architecture (1920 rue Baile). Free admission for students.

Aleksandar Mitrovic looks to score from the top of the key. (Alexandra Allaire / McGill Tribune)
a, Sports

No Bibeau? No problem, Redmen cruise past Citadins

The McGill Redmen have played the UQAM Citadins three times this season, and each time, they’ve prevailed. McGill played host to the struggling Citadins at Love Competition Hall over the weekend, routing UQAM 83-68 in the final regular season meeting between the two teams. Second-year forward Nathan Joyal led the way for the Redmen, matching his season-high total of 17 total. The victory extended the team’s winning streak to three games, despite the absence of key players Adrian Hynes-Guery and Simon Bibeau, both being out due to injury.

The teams traded baskets for much of the first quarter as McGill looked a bit hesitant to start. In the second quarter, however, the Redmen played excellent defence, and they closed out on jump shots, forcing UQAM into some sloppy possessions. The Citadins were limited to just five perimeter attempts after taking nine in the first quarter, and were held to only 31 per cent shooting overall in the quarter.

McGill began executing more precisely on offence in the seventh minute, sparked by Rodrigo Imperador’s three-pointer at the 7:20 mark. Joyal was brilliant in this stretch, and he led the offence with drilling two threes and nine points in the last five minutes of the quarter. Captain Winn Clark sank a foul-line jumper at the buzzer to close out the half, ending a 25-7 scoring run, putting the Redmen up 48-29.

Alexandra Allaire / McGill Tribune
Alexandra Allaire / McGill Tribune

McGill Head Coach David DeAveiro stressed the importance of the team-first approach that has guided the Redmen to first place in the RSEQ. Four Redmen players finished in double figures, and McGill’s bench outscored UQAM’s 33-10.

“We’re not about one or two guys. We’re a team. So when [opponents] are preparing to play us, they can’t key in on one or two guys, they have to key in on the [whole] squad,” he said.

However, the second half turned out to be a completely different story for the Redmen. The Citadins attacked McGill’s defence straight out of the break. UQAM also held the Redmen scoreless for the first three minutes of the third quarter, en route to a 6-0 run. The Citadins applied pressure using a  full-court press and forced McGill into multiple turnovers. Two free throws by UQAM’s Philippe Tamba brought them within seven points at the three-minute mark; the third quarter ended with McGill’s large halftime lead trimmed down to 10, 63-53.

“They came out and hit some tough shots on us [early],” Coach DeAveiro said. “I didn’t think we came out with the same intensity to start the third. … I thought about calling a time-out, but I wanted to see if we could fight through this and get together as a team, [to] take care of it on the floor without [calling] a time-out.”

Coach DeAveiro’s strategy appeared to work, as the fourth quarter unfolded perfectly for McGill. Led by second-year point guard Ave Bross, the Redmen proceeded to address the errors that plagued them in the third and re-established their dominance. Joyal started the rout with a three-pointer, followed by jumpers from Bross and Clark. Te’Jour Riley and Imperador added a layup each in the 11-0 scoring run, and UQAM was forced to call a time-out. The Redmen were on cruise control from there.

Bross played within the flow of the game, creating open shots for teammates and delivering pinpoint passes. This was crucial for a team missing Bibeau and Hynes-Guery, both prolific offensive players and point guards who create opportunities.

“I think we [have] figured out how to play without [Hynes-Guerny] right now, and other guys are stepping up and fulfilling that role. … Bross did a good job in the second half [running our offence],” added Coach DeAveiro.

The Redmen have three games left before the playoffs begin and currently sit atop the RSEQ. McGill battles the tied-for-first Bishop’s Gaiters on Feb. 16.

Anna Katycheva / McGill Tribune
a, Sports

Sports Briefs

Swimming — RSEQ Championships: McGill claims 2nd, 3rd Place – 19 swimmers to attend CIS nationals in March

Both swim teams took a dip over the weekend at the annual RSEQ Championships. Disappointed slightly by the teams’ results at the Quebec Cup IV, both squads rebounded, claiming second place in the women’s division and third in the men’s.

Adding to the positive results was the qualification of freshman Sami Eid for the CIS Nationals in Calgary on Feb. 21-23. Qualifying in the 200m backstroke, he became the 19th McGill swimmer to make the cut.

First-year star Katie Caldwell stole the show, lassoing three gold medals, two silvers, and a bronze, en route to swimmer-of-the-meet honours. In addition, her 200m and 400m IM swims were both McGill and RSEQ records.

Taking a much needed break from now until Nationals, McGill’s top swimmers look to make moves in Calgary. Amongst McGill’s top prospects are Stephen Bielby (200m, 400m IM), Caldwell (200m, 400m IM), and Pierre-Alexandre Renaud (200m butterfly, 400m freestyle).

BASKETBALL—MARTLETS 72, UQAM 52: Martlets hold onto top seed in RSEQ – Sylla, Charest impress

The Martlets notched another big win on Saturday to solidify their first place RSEQ ranking. This time, the UQAM Citadins played the losers, falling 72-52 in Donald Love Competition Hall.

The win moves McGill to 10-3, with three games left to play before the postseason. The team’s primary goal will be to hold onto that position into the playoffs and perhaps even take the Conference. The goal is attainable, especially if point guard Françoise Charest and rookie sensation Miriam Sylla keep up their strong play.

On Saturday alone, the pair combined for 32 points; Sylla carried the majority of the burden, with 18 points of her own. Charest has moved the ball well, over the past couple of affairs, which has created chances for McGill’s big scorers, like Sylla, or Anneth Him-Lazarenko.

McGill battles the winless Bishop’s Gaiters next Saturday, Feb. 16, in what should be an easy, yet essential, victory.

HOCKEY—MARTLETS 6, RAVENS 2: Two Games from Perfection, McGill Improves to 18-0 – Top line continues to dominant competition

It was business as usual for the dominant Martlets, who improved to a spotless 18-0 on Sunday, following a 6-2 victory against the struggling 6-12 Carleton Ravens.

Also in line with season norms was the commanding play of Mélodie Daoust. Daoust added two more goals and an assist to her CIS leading points total. With the three tallies, she climbs to 51 points over 19 contests.

Only two games remain for McGill to cap off a flawless season, with a date against division foes the Montreal Carabins on Friday, then the season finale on Saturday against Concordia. From there, the playoffs commence on the Feb. 20, culminating in the CIS Championships in Toronto on Mar. 7-10.

First-year forward Max Le Sieur rushes up from the right wing. (Liam Maclure / McGill Tribune)
a, Sports

Redmen claim violent clash against Rams

In their final homestand of the 2012-2013 season, the McGill Redmen (17-7-4) ended on a high note, emerging victorious over the Ryerson Rams (12-16) by a score of 4-1 on Friday night. This final stretch marked the culmination of a relatively tumultuous season for the Redmen, who were inconsistent for much of the year.

The injury bug remained pervasive in the New Year, and McGill  lost four out of their last five heading into Friday’s tilt. Though, this was not a cause for concern for Head Coach Kelly Nobes.

“Three of them were in shootouts, [and] as a coach, I don’t really count those in my head. … Essentially, we ran out of time to win and losing in shootouts isn’t the same as losing in regulation, as we’re still picking up a point,” Nobes said.

(Liam Maclure / McGill Tribune)
(Liam Maclure / McGill Tribune)

The Redmen put together quite the exhibition of slick passing and physicality against Ryerson. As a result, McGill jumped out to an early 2-0 lead in the first 10 minutes behind goals from Trevor Braun and Nicolas Biniek. McGill’s aggressive forecheck was noticeable throughout the period because it kept the Rams on their heels. Coach Nobes was pleased with the team’s start.

“We had good structure in the neutral zone, and we countered well off of their turnovers while being opportunistic,” Nobes explained.

Goaltender Hubert Morin was especially impressive in the first period and continued the strong effort for the remainder of the contest, turning aside 22 shots to earn the first star of the game.

The second period was a back and forth affair. Although the Redmen had multiple opportunities on the power play, they ultimately went 0-5 on the night and generated few scoring chances. The special teams play was not particularly inspiring in the second, as the Rams capitalized on McGill’s man advantage, after a sloppy Redmen turnover. This seemed to light a fire under the Ryerson players, but their momentum was quashed midway through the period as a cross-ice pass from David Rose—who finished with two assists—found Mathieu Pompei, who sniped a shot into the top right corner past Rams goaltender Troy Passingham.

This proved to be the turning point in the game, as the Redmen held control for the remainder of the contest, even after their potential fifth goal was disallowed. The final stanza of the game was marred by chippy play. Even though McGill and Ryerson aren’t heated rivals, the looming presence of the postseason play intensified the game’s proceedings.

Third-year Redmen forward Benoit Lévesque commented on the gritty third period.

“They’re fighting for a playoff spot, [so] things were chippy. They have a few players with heated tempers and they were running around trying to injure some of our guys,” he said

(Liam Maclure / McGill Tribune)
(Liam Maclure / McGill Tribune)

Unfortunately, the Rams were successful. Redmen left-winger Justin Ducharme laid on the ground for several minutes after being hit to the head mid-way through the third. He struggled to get back on his feet and eventually left the ice. The body count continues to pile up for the Redmen, whose numbers are dwindling at an alarming rate. Hopefully ,this doesn’t come back to bite them in the postseason.

Nevertheless, Coach Nobes was adamant that the Redmen would ride the momentum they received off of this tough victory, and the team did just, defeating RMC (3-22-3) 2-1 in overtime on Saturday in their regular season finale. McGill will need to carry this momentum against Nipissing (14-12-2) in game one of the opening round of the OUA playoffs, on Wednesday night.

Despite all the injuries, the Redmen should be ready to start their CIS Championship defence.

“We’re trying to repeat what we did last year,” Lévesque said. “It’s a big challenge, especially with all the [injuries], but there’s no fun when there’s no challenge.”

a, Behind the Bench, Sports

Who says golf is boring?

Golf has a reputation around the sporting world as one of the most boring and serious sports out there. However, the fans at the Waste Management Phoenix Open in Scottsdale, Arizona beg to differ. There is nothing in golf quite like this tournament, which takes place every year around the end of January. It is appropriately appraised as “the greatest show on grass,” with some going as far as describing it as a four-day party, featuring some golf in between.

The tournament’s atmosphere and traditions are unmatched by any other competition on the PGA Tour. Much of the excitement results from the newly renovated par-three, 16th hole at TPC Scottsdale. While there are many famous par-three holes in the United States, the course’s 16th is neither challenging nor beautiful. However, it is the only fully enclosed hole on Tour. During the Phoenix Open, the hole becomes a stadium filled with 20,000 wild and enthusiastic golf fans, giving it the well-deserved name of the loudest stop on the PGA tour. Fans let the players know when they’ve made good tee shots, as rowdy cheers and chants erupt from the stands. In 1997, when Tiger Woods made his famous hole-in-one, the spectators were sent into a frenzy as Woods made his way to the green. Tiger eventually responded with a subtle “raise the roof” move.

However, the players do not always appreciate the rowdy crowd. When a player hits a bad shot, the crowd mercilessly heckles and boos—a behaviour that is frowned upon in any other tournament on the Tour. If players fail to hit the green, they are required to throw out souvenirs to the fans as they walk to the green. Then, the boos turn to cheers, as players toss hats, footballs, and the like, into the crowd. The 16th hole also features the famous caddy race tradition, from the tee to the green. They run, they tackle, block, trick, somersault, and ultimately dive onto the green to beat the other caddy to the putting surface.

While this hole adds a fun, exciting dimension to golf, some players dread it. Many compare their experience to a gladiator entering the Roman Coliseum, where they are expected to perform well and satisfy the fans’ expectations. As a result, many young players refuse to play here, as the environment and atmosphere can be too much to handle. Three-time tour winner John Rollins said, “It’s the most nerve-racking short iron you’ll ever hit.”

Some other golf traditionalists are not fully supportive of the hole’s atmosphere, as it ruins the sport’s pristine image as a quiet ‘gentlemanly game.’

On the other hand, some players make sure to include this tournament on their bucket list, since there is nothing that matches its atmosphere. Hopefully the Phoenix Open will continue to bring in more enthused fans, and give golf a fresher, younger, and more energetic reputation. Think golf is boring? Watch this tournament and think again.

a, Sports

Around the Water Cooler

In case you were too busy booking your reservation at Lola Rosa for Valentine’s Day, here’s what you missed this past week in the world of sports …

SOCCER — A Europol investigation uncovered a match-fixing scandal orchestrated by organized crime syndicates last week, which fixed—or tried to fix—hundreds of soccer matches around the world over the past few years. According to the report, up to 680 games were compromised, including World Cup qualifiers, European Championship qualifiers, and two UEFA Champions League games. An ESPN report noted that the probe found almost €8 million (10.9 million CAD) in betting profits and €2 million Euros (2.7 million CAD) in bribes to both players and officials. Europol refused to release the names of any suspected to be involved. Its director, Rob Wainwright said that the scandal undoubtedly “threatens the very fabric of the game.” So essentially, the sport is corrupt. Forgive us for not being too surprised.

COLLEGE BASKETBALL — It’s madness in the college hoops world! For the fifth straight week, the nation’s top-ranked team lost. This time around, it was the Illinois Fighting Illini who took out the No. 1 Indiana Hoosiers after a last second layup by Tyler Griffey. In other crazy results, the No. 11 Louisville Cardinals fell to the No. 25 Notre Dame Fighting Irish in a five(!) overtime thriller on Saturday, after the Irish made a late rally at the end of regulation. It was recorded as the longest game in the Big East conference’s regular season history. Also on Saturday, Wisconsin upset No. 3 Michigan in overtime, after tying the game with a buzzer-beating half-court heave by Badgers’ guard, Ben Brust. In other words, have fun filling out your NCAA tournament brackets next month.

BASKETBALL — The Rudy Gay era in Toronto is officially underway as the 6’8’’ highlight reel forward made a pretty good impression during his first week as a Raptor. While the team hasn’t improved much in the wins column, Gay sent Raptor fans into a frenzy after nailing the game-winning shot against the Indiana Pacers on Friday night. In other Raptor news, Terrence Ross was chosen to compete in the Sprint Slam Dunk competition at All-Star weekend in Houston. Check him out on YouTube if you haven’t already—the man can fly. Also, Andrea Bargnani is back, which is good because we missed our scapegoat. Let’s just hope he isn’t—or is, I guess—being moved to Chicago, as reports hinted late last week. South of the border, the Miami Heat, Oklahoma City Thunder, and San Antonio Spurs are all fighting for the top spot in the league heading into the All-Star break this weekend. Here’s a suggestion: fill out an NBA playoff bracket in order to win back all the money you lost on the NCAA; it’s a whole lot easier.

HOCKEY — We’re almost at the quarter mark of the NHL season. So soon, right? Somehow, the New Jersey Devils sit atop the Eastern Conference. We shouldn’t be surprised considering they’re the defending conference champions; but after losing Zach Parise, many thought the team would struggle to score on a consistent basis. That doesn’t seem to matter when you have the ageless wonder Martin Brodeur behind you. In the West, the Chicago Blackhawks look like the real deal and should compete for the Stanley Cup after a couple of disappointing years. They lead the league with 22 points and still have yet to lose in regulation. The Canucks are silencing any critics about their two-headed goaltender situation, as both Roberto Luongo and Cory Schneider are putting up impressive numbers. Finally, the Toronto Maple Leafs won their third straight after crushing the Montreal Canadiens 6-0 on Saturday night. The Tribune sports team is divided on whether such a result is a good or bad thing.

Politics

Dmitry Medvedev’s two-day state visit to Norway has begun

medvedev_land_dmitry_valberg
This is some dummy copy. You’re not really supposed to read this dummy copy, it is just a place holder for people who need some type to visualize what the actual copy might look like if it were real content.

If you want to read, I might suggest a good book, perhaps Hemingway or Melville. That’s why they call it, the dummy copy. This, of course, is not the real copy for this entry. Rest assured, the words will expand the concept. With clarity. Conviction. And a little wit.

In today’s competitive market environment, the body copy of your entry must lead the reader through a series of disarmingly simple thoughts.

All your supporting arguments must be communicated with simplicity and charm. And in such a way that the reader will read on. (After all, that’s a reader’s job: to read, isn’t it?) And by the time your readers have reached this point in the finished copy, you will have convinced them that you not only respect their intelligence, but you also understand their needs as consumers.

As a result of which, your entry will repay your efforts. Take your sales; simply put, they will rise. Likewise your credibility. There’s every chance your competitors will wish they’d placed this entry, not you. While your customers will have probably forgotten that your competitors even exist. Which brings us, by a somewhat circuitous route, to another small point, but one which we feel should be raised.

Long copy or short – You decide

As a marketer, you probably don’t even believe in body copy. Let alone long body copy. (Unless you have a long body yourself.) Well, truth is, who‘s to blame you? Fact is, too much long body copy is dotted with such indulgent little phrases like truth is, fact is, and who’s to blame you. Trust us: we guarantee, with a hand over our heart, that no such indulgent rubbish will appear in your entry. That’s why God gave us big blue pencils. So we can expunge every example of witted waffle.

For you, the skies will be blue, the birds will sing, and your copy will be crafted by a dedicated little man whose wife will be sitting at home, knitting, wondering why your entry demands more of her husband‘s time than it should.

But you will know why, won‘t you? You will have given her husband a chance to immortalize himself in print, writing some of the most persuasive prose on behalf of a truly enlightened purveyor of widgets. And so, while your dedicated reader, enslaved to each mellifluous paragraph, clutches his newspaper with increasing interest and intention to purchase, you can count all your increased profits and take pots of money to your bank. Sadly, this is not the real copy for this entry. But it could well be. All you have to do is look at the account executive sitting across your desk (the fellow with the lugubrious face and the calf-like eyes), and say ”Yes! Yes! Yes!“ And anything you want, body copy, dinners, women, will be yours. Couldn’t be fairer than that, could we?

Students draw their ideas for new student space on SSMU building floor plans. (Remi Lu / McGill Tirbune)
a, News

Students share ideas for newly open space in SSMU building

Last Friday, the Students’ Society of McGill University (SSMU) held a strategic summit on student space to assess students’ priorities for the SSMU Building. The summit kicked off SSMU’s month-long campaign to determine how the building’s space will be used after Voyages Campus’s sublease ends in May. Possibilities presented at the summit included new student space food service options, such as a cheap, sustainable, student-run café.

“SSMU in the past has done a lot of strategic summits, but this one is really exciting because it’s really real,” Allison Cooper, SSMU’s vicepresident of clubs and services and one of the SSMU Building’s managers, said. “We have a lot of changing space going on.”

Twenty participants, including students, Student Services coordinators, and SSMU executives, attended the event to engage in dialogue about students’ aspirations for the building.

SSMU President Josh Redel invited attendees to draw their ideas for student space onto five blank floor plans—one for each level of the SSMU Building. “It could be as simple as a vegan restaurant, or you could literally draw offices in—it could be as much or as little as you want,” Redel said. “You’ll be seeing these [floorplans] around campus for the next month and a half as well, urging students to get involved.”

Daphne Ben David, a U3 environment student and Organic Campus volunteer, asked SSMU to avoid leasing out space to large businesses.

“Something really important to us is local and organic initiatives,” Ben David said. “I don’t personally see the value in another big franchise. If we started an organic co-op, students would be able to support themselves.”

One of the main discussion topics was the possibility of introducing a student-run café to the building. Plans for such a café have been in the works for over a year, but stalled last September due to concerns about the project’s financial feasibility.

Participants at the summit raised concerns about costs, health, student management, sustainable choices, dietary restrictions, and hiring student staff. Overall, however, students were enthusiastic about the idea of such a project, and optimistic about overcoming potential difficulties.

“It’s a good way to provide students from different faculties with different skills,” Anna Cybulsky, U2 engineering, said. “For management students, even if they’re not making a lot of money for the work they do, it’s just a good project for them to get good experience. So I don’t think it should be a problem to make [a student-run café] profitable.”

Students agreed that the SSMU building needs a comfortable, lounge-like location where students can eat, socialize, and study without feeling rushed, and suggested that this kind of a setting does not currently exist on campus.

Amanda Unruh, Health Promotion coordinator at McGill, expressed concern over the nutritional value of food options currently available on campus and those that might be available in the future. She also pointed to the internship program at Macdonald campus as a potential way to get students involved in the building.

“I work quite a bit with the dietetics program at [Macdonald Campus], and they’re always looking for placements for students,” she said. “That’s something to look into, in terms of a sustainable internship program.”

Sustainability and pricing were also focuses of the summit. Cooper suggested that reusable dishware would better aid waste management in the building, while equitable pricing would attract more students.

“Pricing is important to students,” she said. “[We should have] social equity in the menu—being able to have a three dollar dahl option, then also the more expensive butter chicken—to have it accessible to all.”

Throughout the summit, SSMU executives stressed the importance of student input regarding changes to space use in the SSMU Building.

“We have the funds to do it,” Vice-President Finance and Operations Jean Paul Briggs said. “I’m very interested in getting feedback … We want a dialogue—it’s about engaging with students.”

McGill will host two Consultation Fairs to discuss the new Statement of Values and Operating Procedures. (Simon Poitrimolt / McGill Tribune)
a, News

McGill releases new documents on how to deal with protests

McGill released the latest set of documents regarding protests and demonstrations on campus on Monday. Originally a draft protocol on demonstrations, these documents consist of a Statement of Values and Principles on freedom of expression and freedom of assembly, and a set of Operating Procedures regarding demonstrations, protests, and occupations on McGill University campuses.

Vice-Principal (Administration and Finance) Michael Di Grappa and Provost Anthony Masi first announced that the administration would take this course on Jan. 16, following consultation for the draft protocol in December and January. The documents are meant to eventually replace a provisional protocol that has been in effect since Feb. 12, 2012, since the five-day student occupation of the 6th floor of the James Administration building.

According to the second document, the Operating Procedures will serve as guidelines for determining “when attention or intervention may or may not prove necessary in the case of demonstrations, protests, occupations, and actions that contravene internal policies or the law.”

“In general, tolerance is expected for the expression of dissent, and for a certain degree of inconvenience arising from the means by which dissenting opinions may be expressed,” the document reads. “At all times, decisions will be sensitive to context and will reflect the exercise of sound judgment by those in charge.”

The document then outlines in what contexts demonstrations, assemblies, and protests are considered to be peaceful, which include the consideration of “intensity, intentionality, duration, and location.”

While both the Senate and the Board of Governors (BoG) were originally intended to vote on the draft protocol, the Operating Procedures will not face a vote in either body. Di Grappa has said that this is common procedure for university administration, because the Operating Procedures are an “administrative document,” rather than a matter of academic or fiscal policy.

Both the Senate and the BoG will vote on the Statement of Values and Principles on Mar. 20, and Apr. 26, respectively.

“The Statement of Values will be an over-arching statement that will influence how McGill responds to events on campus, including the implementation of the Operating Procedures,” Di Grappa said.

The email that announced the release of the documents on Monday notes that the administration created the Statement of Values to closely resemble the preamble to the draft protocol.

“Based on consultation on the draft of a revised protocol circulated to the community before the Holiday break, we concluded that the preamble of the proposed protocol was generally well received,” the email reads.

Students’ Society of McGill University (SSMU) President Josh Redel said he felt the new documents were “a step in the right direction” for McGill, although he questioned the administration’s decision to forego discussing the Operating Procedures at Senate or the BoG.

“Does it belong at Senate? Does it belong at Board?” he said. “I can see some Board members saying that ‘this is management and we usually deal with governance’ … but that doesn’t mean that it shouldn’t go there at least for discussion.”

Although Post Graduate Students’ Society (PGSS) Secretary-General Jonathan Mooney expressed that he saw improvement in the language of the latest draft of the Operating Procedures, he also shared Redel’s view of the administration’s decision.

“It is clearly stated that [the Operating Procedures] ‘do not replace policies such as the Charter of Student Rights, [nor] the Code of Student Conduct,’” Mooney said. “We think it is critical that no administrative document supersede any of the policy documents [that] are approved through the Board and Senate, which include student input.”

“Still, since these Operating Procedures clearly touch on matters related to the Student Code and the Charter of Student Rights, [PGSS thinks] it’s critical that these [Operating Procedures] come before democratic mechanisms in place—the [Board] and Senate—both of which include students’ voices and the ability for people to suggest changes [and] debate,” he continued.

Critics of the draft protocol, including students, campus unions, and the Canadian Civil Liberties Association (CCLA), described the document as being vague and open to interpretation. U3 arts student Eli Freedman filed a grievance with the university against the draft protocol in December 2012, asking that both the draft protocol and the provisional protocol be nullified. According to Freedman, the new documents “repackage the exact same document” into two.

“[The administration] certainly haven’t changed any of the sections that have been criticized [by the CCLA], so it seems like the Mc- Gill administration believes it can bully students, unions, and civil rights watchdogs,” he said. “The same types of concerns have been brought forth by so many parties at this point, that it seems like [the administration is] … ignoring any criticisms and pushing through the type of document that they wanted all along.”

Freedman said his grievance has been delayed by the administration’s decision to split the document, but that he should hear back from the Senate Committee on Student Grievances by mid-February.

Although the documents are separate from one another, they will receive feedback together at two Consultation Fairs in February— one at the Macdonald Campus and one at the downtown campus.

“Experience tells us [attendance] won’t be huge, [but] I think people will have ample opportunity to make their views known,” Doug Sweet, McGill’s director of internal communications, said.

The administration also created a comments section, where members of the McGill community may post comments and view other participants’ comments. According to Sweet, those interested in submitting a comment should do so by the beginning of the second week of March for the administration to consider their remarks.

According to Di Grappa, the provisional protocol will likely remain in effect until Apr. 26, when the BoG is expected to vote on the Statement of Values. Redel said he intends to encourage the administration to create an opportunity for Senate to discuss both documents.

“I hope people do get out and provide feedback,” he said. “Hopefully the university is truly willing to … consider splitting [the documents] again, combining [them], or reforming [them] significantly if the consultation feedback they get in the next phase is drastic enough to warrant another change.”

Joel Suriano from the Grounds Department. (Simon Poitrimolt / McGill Tribune)
a, News

McGill still recovering from flood

The cleanup of McGill’s downtown campus continues this week after severe flooding occurred on Jan. 28. Several buildings remain inaccessible to students and staff, and several hundred people have been relocated until building repairs are completed.

The flood occurred when a 48- inch water main at the McTavish Reservoir broke, releasing 40,000 cubic meters (just over 10.5 million gallons) of water. Last Thursday, the city of Montreal announced that the incident concluded that the burst may have been caused by construction workers shifting earth around the pipe. Financial responsibility for the incident has not yet been assigned.

According to McGill Vice- Principal (Administration and Finance) Michael Di Grappa, the flood caused the cancellation of 80 classes and the relocation of 12 laboratories on Monday. He said approximately 12 buildings were affected, including Service Point, the James Administration Building, and the Wong Building.

While most buildings have been reopened, the Wong Building remains closed, as well as basement spaces in Birks Building, Wilson Hall, and 3534 University—the building that houses the School of Environment. People in these spaces have been relocated to places like the Ferrier Building and the Stewart Biology building while repairs are conducted, which are predicted to take two to three months.

“The damage has been flooding in foundations, there’s a risk of mold, there’s damage to furniture, [and] damage to equipment,” Di Grappa said. “We don’t know what the dollar amount is, but believe it will be hundreds of thousands of dollars.”

Some of the most extensive damage has been to the James Annex— a small building by the James Administration building that houses McGill’s graphic design team– where water smashed a window and flooded the building. According to Director of Internal Communications for the Media Relations Office Doug Sweet, staff members who work in the Annex and the second floor of James Administration will not be able to return to their offices until repairs are complete, which could take several months. This further delays damage assessment.

“We don’t have a precise estimate of the costs, and in fact, some of them haven’t been incurred yet— for example, whatever it will cost us to relocate people from James Annex and from the second floor of the James Admin Building,” Sweet said. “[We] will be filing a claim with our insurers.”

A clean-up effort on campus has been underway for over a week to remove debris, before freezing temperatures complicate the process.

Alexandra Allaire / McGill Tribune
Alexandra Allaire / McGill Tribune

“There’s a very fine silt of mud that is very hard to remove when it freezes,” Angelo Tambasco, supervisor of McGill’s Grounds and Vehicle Services, said. “If all this mud freezes up, we’re going to have to wait for the next window of opportunity to be able to clear it up.”

Tambasco said his crew focused on freeing emergency exits, since a building must remain closed if its emergency exit is blocked. Tambasco also said that the flood may have caused more serious problems in places like McTavish Street, where entire areas were washed away by water, and cracks in the road have appeared.

“Right now, a lot of the earth underneath is still frozen, so you could have some voids underneath your roadways,” he said. “A lot of this is going to have to be looked at come spring, [because] at this particular point in time, we can’t really tell [if it’s dangerous].”

A student-run garden located behind McGill’s School of Environment on University Street was also severely damaged when floodwater washed soil away, dumped bricks and rocks in the area, and may have carried pieces of a nearby invasive plant into the garden. The garden is run by Campus Crops, a student-run collective that promotes urban agriculture.

“A lot of time, energy, and money has been lost for us, especially since the little good quality topsoil we managed to have accumulated so far seems to have been washed away,” Campus Crops Coordinator Carl Dion Laplante said. “We’ll have no choice but to remove as many rocks as possible and see what we can do with the soil that is left.… We might not be able to use it to grow vegetables next summer.”

Read the latest issue

Read the latest issue