Latest News

a, Music

Portage and Main: Never Had The Time

Well, it’s February: the Monday of months. The nasty hangover after the wild weekend that is Winter Break. For those that could use some sort of pick-me-up, Portage and Main’s new album Never Had The Time is just what the doctor ordered. It offers a smooth respite from the grey Canadian winter, going down like hot chocolate with a dab of peppermint. This Vancouver six-piece’s sophomore effort is a ten-song album spearheaded by the vocal harmonies of chief songwriters Harold Donnelly and John Sponarski.

Fans of Wilco, Neil Young, and The Band will enjoy the rootsy sounds of Never Had The Time, which has been well received since its release last week. Portage and Main has performed at North by Northeast, Canadian Music Week, and other renowned Canadian music festivals.

The album is strong as a whole, but the song to be whistling to until the ice thaws is the title track, “Never Had The Time.” The vibrato- heavy pedal steel guitar glides through the background of the mix, and weaves in and out with a huge organ that manages to stay consistent with the volume and dynamics of the vocals. At no point does the listener find himself distracted by a specific instrument. Congratulations are in order for keyboardist Georges Couling, who produced and engineered the album.

This record is simple, but in no way minimalist—there’s a lot going on with the various instruments in each track, but Never Had The Time will never overwhelm the listener.

Alice Englert as Lena Duchannes. (www.fanpop.com)
a, Arts & Entertainment

Supernatural creatures are beautiful too

Beautiful Creatures, a soon to- be-released fantasy flick, depicts the turbulent love story of Lena Duchannes (Alice Englert) and Ethan Wate (Alden Ehrenreich), as the teens navigate Lena’s family of witches (or ‘casters’, as they prefer to be called), and the inhabitants of their close-minded Southern town.

According to Emmy Rossum, one of the film’s stars, Beautiful Creatures portrays “females in the Duchannes family as having all the power,” while also hinting at a “girlpower battle” between her character and Lena, the focus of the movie. Rossum says this is what ultimately sets the film apart from others of its genre. Adapted from a successful trilogy of teen novels, Beautiful Creatures is a re-imagining of the classic star-crossed lovers tale.

Rossum says she “gravitate[s] toward strong female characters,” as she was raised by a single mother. Having been cast in “good girl roles as a teen,” she became tired of trying to fit the mould. Playing glamourous, supernatural Ridley Duchannes was a chance for Rossum to explore new waters, and a significant departure from her most prominent role to date: the down to earth Fiona Gallagher in Showtime’s gritty dramedy series Shameless.

Alden Ehrenreich, who was scouted at age 14 by Stephen Spielberg at a Bat Mitzvah, tells the Tribune that Beautiful Creatures is a fresh take on the ubiquitous teen fantasy flick.

“You need a device that brings it down to a human level, to a human understanding,” Ehrenreich says. “To me, the humour keeps the film grounded in a more relatable reality.” His co-star, newcomer Zoey Deutch, singles out the film for its unique portrayal of men.

“I don’t know who came up with this idea that it’s not sexy or cool for men to be vulnerable … but Alden plays it so well,” Deutch says.

Recently, comparisons have been made between Beautiful Creatures and Twilight, since both began as successful young adult books, and feature passionate love stories with supernatural elements.

In response to these claims, Ehrenreich says, “It’s the same demographic and the same audience base and the same genre, but I haven’t seen the Twilight movies so I don’t know how similar they actually are.” He adds that he hopes people feel even “a fraction of the enthusiasm” for Beautiful Creatures as that shown for the Twilight franchise. Alice Englert, daughter of New Zealand director Jane Campion, agrees.

“I understand why the comparisons are being made. It’s very natural, because it’s such a new genre to have such a large audience,” Englert says.

Beautiful Creatures was also a chance for many of its young cast to learn from some of Hollywood’s strongest actors; Emma Thompson, Jeremy Irons, and Viola Davis also star in the film.

“The older actors that we worked with were just so nurturing and open to teaching us everything they knew. It was the greatest acting class watching them work,” says Thomas Mann, star of last year’s Project X.

Is there a franchise in the works? Rossum hints that the actors are all “signed for sequels.”

“If people embrace the series and want it to continue, I would love to reprise the role,” Rossum says.

Beautiful Creatures hits theatres Feb. 14.

Dianna Ros fought hard to bring the Martlets back in the fourth quarter. (Remi Lu / McGill Tribune)
a, Sports

Streak snapped: Martlets fall to Concordia

The Martlets entered Love Competition Hall on Friday evening in support of Shoot for the Cure— a fundraiser for breast cancer research— in the annual “Pack the House” game. McGill was looking to extend their seven game winning streak into February against the Concordia Stingers. However, despite a strong showing by point guard Diana Ros and forward Mariam Sylla, the Martlets fell to the Stingers 71-66 for the first time since November.

The first quarter was quite competitive, as both teams appeared evenly matched. Concordia had made tremendous adjustments since the last time the two rivals met, when the Stingers were blown out 75-44. On the other side of the court, McGill played with tenacity on offence, crashing the offensive boards, and running the floor every chance they had. The quarter finished an even 16-16.

While the Martlets focused on pushing the tempo in transition and pounding the ball down low to star rookie Sylla, the Stingers sniped from beyond the arc. Concordia’s shooters recorded an outstanding 61.5 per cent field goal efficiency from three-point range in the first half.

The second frame, however, was all about Ros, as the secondyear point guard put on a clinic. She scored the first five points for the Martlets and scored he remaining 10 points in the second quarter, including an ankle-breaking crossover on a Stinger defender. She teamed up with Sylla to put the team up by seven at the 7:09 mark.

Unfortunately, Ros was the lone bright spot for McGill in the second. The team proceeded to collapse, allowing Concordia to come roaring back with a barrage of threes. The Stingers entered halftime with a 42-34 lead.

Remi Lu / McGill Tribune
Remi Lu / McGill Tribune

“[In the second quarter], we slowed the pace down [and] started walking,” Martlets Head Coach Ryan Thorne said. “And then, [Concordia] was able to do different things; they ran a good ball screen action, got some open shots. We didn’t play it properly, so they got good looks out of it, and that was it.”

McGill unravelled further in the final half, as Concordia came out of the locker room on fire. The Martlets continued to struggle to defend the three-point shot, and could not convert on offence. McGill’s turnovers added to their troubles, and they trailed 61-45 by the end of the third quarter.

The Martlets huddled up before the start of the fourth, when Coach Thorne helped his team regroup.

“Coach just [told] us that we had to communicate; that we have to play with more character, and that we are better than what we are doing. Everyone got pumped up and we started to do what we do best,” Sylla said.

This motivation appeared to work its magic, as McGill played with incredible energy in the final quarter and got back to what gives them offensive success—namely, their inside-out passing, transition baskets, and offensive rebounds.

The hard work paid off, as the Martlets made a comeback behind Sylla and veteran forward Helene Bibeau. Following an 18-2 run, Sylla put McGill up by one with three minutes remaining in the game. Ultimately, Tamara Pinard-Devos and Kaylah Barrett kept composure down the stretch for Concordia, and helped the Stingers seal the 71-66 victory.

Despite Friday’s loss, the Martlets remain in first place in the RSEQ, with a conference record of 8-3. However, Coach Thorne does not want McGill’s position atop the standings to affect his team’s approach.

“We won the conference last year, so we’ve had a target [on our backs] since the season started,” he said. “We have to take the approach, which is to go out there and play everyone as tough as we can. … We’re going after another championship.” Ros added that the team will continue to work hard before the playoffs.

“We’ve been working since the beginning of the season [to stay] first,” she said. “We’ve been here before so we just want to stay here and work as hard as we can [to] have home court advantage [in the playoffs].”

The Martlets battle Laval on Feb. 7 in Quebec City, before returning home to play UQAM on Feb. 9. The RSEQ playoffs begin at the end of February.

a, Sports

January transfer window round up

Implemented in 2003, the January transfer window presents an opportunity for soccer clubs around the world to strengthen their squads mid-season. This season, the English Premier League topped worldwide spending with a remarkable £120 million (188 million CAD) outlay—up 50 per cent from last year—but still far from the record setting £225 million (353 million CAD) of 2011. Italy’s Serie A spent the second most, trailed by the French and German leagues. Spain’s lacklustre economy shone through, with La Liga residing among the lower spending leagues. While rash deals are occasionally handed out—like the £40 million (63 million CAD) Fernando Torres transfer two years ago—there are definitely some great bargains to be found in January. For instance, Mark van Bommel was purchased for next to nothing in 2011, and played a pivotal role in Milan’s Scudetto triumph that year. Let’s take a look at some of the winners and losers of this past January transfer window:

WINNERS

A.C. Milan

The Italian giants made one of the biggest splashes, bringing in the enigmatic striker Mario Balotelli. Balotelli is perhaps better known for his antics off the pitch, but there is no questioning his talent. For years, he was lauded as having the potential to become the best player in the world, and to date he has shown flashes of being just that. Look no further than Italy’s dramatic victory in the 2012 Euro Cup semi-final against Germany, when Balotelli chested down a ball and rifled it top corner, past the world class keeper Manuel Neuer. His fee of €20 million (27 million CAD) looks reasonable, and many feel that a return to Italy is best for him, considering Milan was where he first made a name for himself as a youth.

Paris Saint-Germain (PSG)

Finalized in August, PSG’s signing of Lucas Moura from Brazilian club Sao Paulo looks to be a good bet. With a hefty price tag of €45 million, many questioned the move. But does his fee really matter? PSG’s new ownership has shown over the past few summers that money is no issue. Lucas is an exciting, young attacker, who will free up space for Zlatan Ibrahimović up front, and cause problems for defenders throughout France. PSG also purchased David Beckham, but from an on-field perspective, he will provide next to nothing for the club. Beckham’s signing will mostly result in substantial jersey revenue for PSG, and the media attention he will bring to the squad and Ligue 1 will be beneficial for all involved.

LOSERS

Arsenal

The mythical Arsène Wenger hasn’t looked too great this season. A string of poor results have put Arsenal in a dogfight for a Champions League spot yet again. Allowing stars like Cesc Fàbregas and Robin van Persie leave on the transfer market is embarrassing for a club as large as Arsenal. This January window, the club favoured David Villa, but a deal failed to materialize. Wenger has been given the funds to strengthen his squad, but instead, he has bought youth products who take years to develop. Once they do mature, however, he cashes in on them, leaving Arsenal without a competitive squad. It’s a vicious trend that doesn’t look like it will end during Wenger’s reign.

Manchester City

Roberto Mancini has been granted the resources to spend as much as he desires. However, he spurned that opportunity this summer, buying flops like Jack Rodwell and Javi Garcia. Man City has been exposed this season, competing with a more experienced Manchester United club that is back on top of the table and doesn’t seem likely to falter anytime soon. With purchases in attack and defence, Man City would have the potential to compete with the world’s best; instead, trophies are unlikely to grace the Etihad Stadium—at least not this season.

a, Sports

10 questions with Vincent Dufort

MT: When did you start playing basketball?

VD: I started when I was probably four or five years old. I’ve been playing my entire life; I played club ball in high school and elementary school—I’ve always played with my older brother too, so that helped a lot. I’ve just always loved it for my whole life.

MT: Why did you want to play basketball at McGill?

VD: Coach DeAveiro recruited me my whole last year. He came to all of my games; he showed me the campus and everything about the school, and I really liked it a lot. I met some of the guys on the team, and he explained to me that it would be the best balance for basketball and school, so I really bought into that. Obviously, basketball is really important, but so is education, and I got into the program that I wanted to here. I got recruited from a lot of schools in the OUA like Carleton, Queens— those were my other two main schools, but I was recruited all over the place. I just figured that McGill was the best balance for me [in terms of] basketball and academics.

MT: How do you feel about the team at this point in the season?

VD: I feel really good about it, actually. I think we’re starting to really gel, and the chemistry is really good. Obviously, we lost our starting point guard, which hurt a lot, but Simon Bibeau is stepping up as our point guard now. We’re really coming together as a unit and playing well, so I feel good about our team now.

MT: Tell me a bit more about the team chemistry and dynamic on and off the court.

VD: Well, there’s definitely a huge connection between the two, because we’re all such a tight group. On the court, we’re not afraid to maybe tell each other if we screwed up somewhere; we won’t take it to heart or anything like that. We’re so close and we’ve played together so much now, that you know where some guy’s gonna cut, you know where he’s going to be; so that helps a lot, and that’s just a huge part of basketball. I think—having good chemistry on and off the court is necessary to be successful.

MT: You guys have five games left in the regular season, what are the goals for the end of the season?

VD: Well we’d like to win all five, obviously and finish first in the league, because we want to improve every single year. We just went through a rough stretch playing the second and third place teams, and now we’ve got the forth and fifth placed teams to play for the rest of the season. We should come up with some wins if we play well together— and that’s what we’re expecting to do.

MT: How does this season compare to last season personally and as a team?

VD: Personally, I’ve learned a ton. Obviously, experience helps a lot. Just little stuff, mistakes. Coach really taught me to play hard for 40 minutes, and not take plays off here and there, so that definitely helps me a lot. As a team, we’ve all come up just, like I have. I’ve grown as a player; we’ve grown as a team, with everyone together. The chemistry comes into play again, where we all just know each other that much better now—one year makes a huge difference. Everyone worked really hard this summer, and we’ve taken a really big step forward.

MT: Looking forwa rd pas t McGill, where do you see your basketball career going?

VD: I would like to play pro in Europe if I would have that opportunity. I’m going to keep working hard over the next three years, and hopefully I’ll get that chance. But if not, it’s not the end of the world. I’ll start my career as a teacher, which I’m looking forward to as well, and hopefully get to coach some high school teams or something like that—I really enjoy that stuff too.

MT: Do you have a specific routine on game days, or are you superstitious at all?

VD: A little bit. As a team, we always go out for a team meal; then, we go back to the gym, hang out, and watch the girls’ game. At the start of the year, I always had shin splints; so I always got calf massages before the game and we won 11 straight games. Even though I don’t have shin splints any more, I still get the calf massage; so that’s my superstition.

MT: Who is your all-time favourite basketball player?

VD: Well, this might be contradicting to my favorite team, but I’ve gotta go with Vince Carter. I grew up watching the Raptors when he was on them, and I’ve just always loved him. Even though he kind of backstabbed us, I’ve always been a big Vince Carter fan.

MT: Do you play Fantasy Basketball?

MT: I’m actually in two different leagues; I’ll tell you the team that’s doing well. I’ve got Kyrie Irving, Andre Iguodala, Rudy Gay actually—I’ve got Chris Bosh, JaVale McGee, George Hill, Luis Scola. Iguodala is doing a little better now, but he’s been struggling abit. JaVale is frustrating too.

Marie-Christine Lapointe volleys it up. (Anna Katycheva / McGill Tribune)
a, Sports

Tears flow as season ends for Martlets

Tears flooded the court at the conclusion of the McGill Martlets’ last volleyball match of the season on Saturday evening. Although the Martlets fell in straight sets, the loss was not the main source of this outpouring of emotion. As with the end of any season, the Martlets had to say goodbye to their graduating seniors—and this year’s crop was a particularly talented and motivated group.

Setter and perennial All-Star Marcela Mansure will certainly be moving on next season, as she has used all of her five years of CIS eligibility. Joining her is Rebecca Canam, and potentially, captain and star power hitter, Geneviève Plante. Plante is graduating this year from a three-year program, but hopes to continue with the team in upcoming years, during a graduate degree.

Already eliminated from the playoffs, the Martlets still sought to finish the season on a positive note. First up were the Montreal Carabins on Thursday night, who rode the explosive talent of Sophie Bergeron- Leblanc and Marie-Sophie Nadeau, en route to a 26-24, 25-19, 25-15 victory. The Carabins closed out the last half of the season on fire, winning nine of their last 11 games to climb to seventh in the national CIS rankings.

Anna Katycheva / McGill Tribune
Anna Katycheva / McGill Tribune

To finish off the season on Saturday, the Laval Rouge-et-Or visited McGill. However, the result was much of the same for the Martlets. McGill looked a little taken aback by the power and ferocity of their opponent—as they have for much of the season—and had to play catchup from the beginning.

The first two sets finished an uninspired 25-21, 25-20. The lone bright spot arose in the third, when McGill took it to Laval on the backs of Plante and rookies Catherine Amyot, and Ashley Norfleet. It was the first time in the match that the Martlets did not seem intimidated by the size of their opponents. The Martlets built a lead, but a few unforced hitting errors gave the Rougeet- Or enough momentum to tie the game at 24 and ultimately come out victorious 27-25.

With no chance to replicate last year’s stunning bronze medal at Nationals last year, this season was undoubtedly a rebuilding year for the Martlets. Several starters from last year’s squad were lost to graduation, while 2012 Libero-of-the-Year, and Team Canada member, Daphnée André-Morin was absent the whole season with a knee injury. Morin’s absence left a gaping hole in the Martlet defence—one they failed to fill all year.

To add to this, while McGill was battered and inexperienced, the three other members of the league were really hitting their strides, each ranking in the CIS top 10, and making the RSEQ arguably the most competitive league in the country.

The Martlets battled with the weapons they had, and Head Coach Rachèle Béliveau did well in fostering the development of the freshmen, who were adjusting from the slower CEGEP—or high school— game to the more physical and powerful CIS volleyball level.

Development will be crucial next year as André-Morin returns, and the team looks to be competitive once again. The one question mark looming on the horizon is the loss of Mansure, who has been the lone setter for the last four years of Martlet volleyball. Converted right-side hitter Marie-Christine Lapointe has played setter in the past, but never consistently at the CIS level, and listed sophomore setter Yasmeen Dawoodjee has failed to make her mark in the CIS game. This void will need to be addressed as the team moves forward to next season.

Although the CIS sanctioned competition is over for the year, Mc- Gill still has a series of upcoming exhibition tournaments, giving them an even greater opportunity to gel. Those tournaments compose the illustrious “Coupe du Québec,” which starts in March and runs through April.

Luke Orlando / McGill Tribune
a, Sports

Redmen slam rivals in full-house thriller

After a difficult loss to Bishop’s on Wednesday, the McGill Redmen were hungry to bounce back. The team battled the No. 10 Concordia Stingers on Friday night at Love Competition Hall. McGill Athletics chose the right contest for its annual “Pack the House” game, and the capacity crowd experienced a thriller.

McGill edged out their opponents 63-61 after Concordia guard Kyle Desmarais missed a last second shot that would have pushed the contest into overtime.

Luke Orlando / McGill Tribune
Luke Orlando / McGill Tribune

The matchup got off to a fastpaced start, with both teams’ raw athleticism on display. McGill dictated the flow of play early on, clearly inspired—while the Stingers appeared sluggish. The Redmen really took off after McGill third-year guard Simon Bibeau launched the offence with a three pointer. They continued to make most of their shots, while Concordia’s typically dynamic offence struggled to penetrate McGill’s defensive interior.

The crowd propelled the Redmen in the second quarter, as the team built a 13-point lead by the midway point. Concordia picked up their play by the end, but the Redmen held a 34-25 lead heading into the half. Bibeau, Vincent Dufort, and Aleks Mitrovic were all key to McGill’s dominant start.

The final half, however, played out very differently for the Redmen, as the Stingers slowly clawed their way back into the game. Despite McGill’s consistent defensive stands for McGill, the Stingers shots started to fall, and the crowd was taken out of the game for a stretch. Concordia second-year point guard Jerome Blake and fifth-year forward Evens Laroche led the Stingers comeback, which seemed to light a fire under the rest of the team.

Luke Orlando / McGill Tribune
Luke Orlando / McGill Tribune

The game’s turning point was in part, thanks to Concordia coach John Dore, who implemented a full-court press. As the game grew closer, the animosity between the two sides became apparent, and the contest grew more physical.

Redmen shooting guard Te’Jour Riley—by far the most effective player on the court in the second half—took his game to another level when the Stingers started their run. He was everywhere—diving on loose balls, stymieing Concordia’s offence in the paint, and contributing to the Redmen offence. Without his effort, the Stingers would have sealed the victory. Riley spoke after the game about what inspired his performance.

“It was all the crowd. It really lights a fire under the whole team when the fans get into the game like they did,” Riley said. “Especially because I am an emotional player, I really feed off of that energy.”

As the game went down to the wire, there was frantic play at both ends of the court, with McGill attempting to hold onto their twopoint lead. On the last possession, Riley got just enough of his hand in Desmarais’ face as he put up the game-tying shot, which clanked off the rim, ensuring a Redmen victory.

Other than a Concordia blowout in January, just five total points in their other three meetings this season have separated the two teams. Second-year guard Ave Bross, who has been increasingly reliable this year, commented on the great rivalry between the two up-and-coming programs.

“The dynamic of McGill [versus] Concordia games has changed this year. We used to feel like we needed to play above ourselves to win. We still respect them, but now we go in knowing we can, and should, win these games,” Bross said. “I think our team has really grown this year and our play on the court, especially against Concordia, shows it.”

The win puts the Redmen back into uncontested first place in the RSEQ, but they have a lot of work ahead of them, with a busy second half of the season looming. The Redmen will need to put together some similar performances if they hope to win the RSEQ, and make an underdog push at the CIS Championship in March.

a, Behind the Bench, Sports

Chris Bosh: the ultimate ‘third-wheel’

My Toronto Raptors fandom was born when Vince Carter and Tracy McGrady first flew through the newly opened Air Canada Centre, leading what was arguably the most exciting young team in the NBA. Admittedly though, my clearest Raptor memories are rooted in the Chris Bosh era, when mediocrity was the norm and yelling ‘onions’ after three pointers was acceptable.

As a result, most avid Raptors fans of my generation have a strong opinion about Bosh— whether we regard him as the leader of the team’s transition from the Carter years, or the backstabber that left the organization out to dry when he departed for South Beach in 2010. In any case, the NBA community—particularly Raptor fans—were shocked by and mocked Bosh’s response to a question about his Hall of Fame chances on Jan. 25:

“I [was] a Hall-of-Famer like four years ago; and I say that very seriously, though. I’ve talked about it before with my friends.”

While Bosh seems quite sure of himself—“four years ago” seems a bit extreme—is he out of line in his prediction? Looking at the crude numbers and past trends, he might not be too far off. He is one of only 35 players to amass over 13,000 points, 6,000 rebounds, 700 blocks, and 500 steals. Of this group, 20 are either in the Hall of Fame, or are considered locks to make it once eligible. At just 29 years old, Bosh is the youngest in this group and his numbers will continue to rise, barring any injuries. Bosh also has eight All-Star selections to his name—only one eligible player in NBA history with eight All-Star appearances has yet to make the Hall (Larry Foust). Bosh, in all likelihood, will be selected to a few more All-Star games before his career is over. Finally, he has a great chance to add a few more championship rings (“not three, not four …”) to his hand, assuming Miami can keep the ‘Big Three’ together.

However, as Kelly Dwyer of Yahoo! Sports noted, basketball— unlike sports like baseball—does not have the type of significant numerical benchmarks that all but guarantee a player’s spot in the Hall. So while Bosh is on pace to reach all of these numbers, do they actually matter? It’s fair, then, to question whether Bosh will leave a legacy in the NBA. Upon discussion with anyone who follows the league, the initial consensus answer is ‘No.’ When he was the leader in Toronto, his teams were never serious contenders. Currently in Miami, the perception is that Bosh is playing ‘third fiddle’ to LeBron and Wade’s duet.

However, it can be argued that Bosh did, in fact, play an instrumental role in their championship run last season. When he was hurt, the team faltered and looked as if ‘LeBron wasn’t clutch.’ His return sparked the Heat’s dominance (LeBron may have helped, too.) Perhaps Bosh will follow the path of Hall-of- Famer James Worthy—who won three championships with the Los Angeles Lakers in the ‘80s, playing ‘third-wheel’ behind Magic Johnson and Kareem Abdul-Jabbar— and cement his legacy as the ‘ultimate third-wheel.’ That probably wouldn’t look so good on his plaque, though.

For those still skeptical, it is possible that Bosh can find his legacy outside of the championships he wins in Miami. As more teams try to emulate the Heat’s brand of “small-ball,” organizations will seek out centres likes Bosh—athletic big men, who can rebound and run the floor. If the NBA continues in this direction, Bosh may eventually be perceived as the prototype centre for this new era of basketball.

Although Bosh’s legacy with the Raptors isn’t particularly impressive when taking into account the team’s lack of success, Toronto fans should come to terms with the fact that he will likely be inducted to Springfield one day. He is deserving, after all; even if it kills us that his time in Toronto didn’t play the largest part.

Dean Manfredi speaks to students about course reductions planned by the faculty. (Simon Poitrimolt / McGill Tribune)
a, News

Dean of Arts addresses student concerns over course cuts

Last Tuesday, Dean of Arts Christopher Manfredi listened to students’ concerns about cuts to arts courses, during a Town Hall hosted by the Arts Undergraduate Society (AUS). AUS Vice-President Academic Tom Zheng invited Manfredi to speak about the faculty’s decision to cut up to 100 courses and reduce the number of temporary lecturers teaching in the faculty for the 2013-2014 academic year.

Manfredi said he would pass students’ concerns along to department chairs during the next step in the process, where individual departments will decide which courses they can cut without affecting students’ ability to complete their programs. He announced the reductions to professors and students at a faculty meeting on Jan. 15.

According to Manfredi, the restructuring is intended to increase the proportion of courses taught by permanent teaching staff, and to get rid of classes that are typically under-enrolled. With the remaining funds, the faculty intends to hire more teaching assistants (TAs). The goal is to hire one TA for every 60 students, rather than the current ratio—one TA per 80 students.

Some students, however, expressed frustration at the implication that full-time faculty members provide a better educational experience than part-time lecturers.

“A lot of course lecturers are better at teaching courses than fulltime professors,” Arts Senator James Gutman said. “I know a lot of full-time professors who are great at research but aren’t so good at talking to a crowd of 200 people. Course lecturers are great at that, so why, I ask, are we cutting them?”

Manfredi said consultation on the subject took place with teachers and students in 2008, and a dean’s working group on academic program delivery was held in 2010-2011. He expressed surprise at recent student criticism of the decision, saying that he had already discussed the upcoming course reductions at faculty meetings in September and November, although he and the AUS were unable to plan a Town Hall until last week due to exams.

“There’s nothing secret about it,” Manfredi said. “We did these consultations, and we learned that students were dissatisfied with the level of teaching assistant support, [and that] students were concerned that there was a disconnect between research and teaching in the faculty.”

Although the cuts will target courses with fewer than 20 students, Manfredi emphasized that the intention is to cut courses that are under-enrolled, and not simply small.

“If a course is small by necessity … [or] because pedagogically it has to be small, no problem,” he said. “However, some courses are small by design because the professor doesn’t want to teach more students … and some courses are small because their topics are so esoteric and uninteresting to students that they don’t enroll in those courses.”

Associate Dean of Arts Gillian Lane-Mercier, who also attended and spoke at the Town Hall, emphasized that relatively few courses will be “retired.” Options include offering courses every two or three years, and creating new courses that combine the topics of several smaller courses.

Manfredi said funds from courses that are no longer offered would be reallocated towards teaching assistantships, internships, and advising. However, some students expressed skepticism that the additional funds created by reducing courses will lead to an improved learning experience.

“We’ve been told to get less with a very whispering promise of ‘more,’ ” Gutman said. “What we do know is that course lecturers [and] small courses are going to be cut.”

Manfredi responded to the claim that students may not see “more.” He estimated that the faculty will be able to reallocate $500,000 towards teaching assistantships and $200,000 towards advising and internships.

Students also questioned TAs’ ability to compensate for smaller classes taught by temporary instructors.

“I’ve heard from TAs that they feel ill-equipped when they go into conferences because they’ve never facilitated conversations before or they’ve never really learned how to teach,” Talitha Calder, president of the Political Science Students’ Association, said. “If there are more resources that are being put into the number of TAs … will they also receive the adequate training that is needed to fulfil that position?”

Manfredi encouraged students  like Calder to submit their general feedback about the quality of teaching at McGill by completing course evaluations, and by reaching out to the undergraduate representatives of their department.

“We don’t want to offer a low quality educational experience,” Manfredi said. “We’re trying to deliver the best programs we can deliver with the resources we have, and none of us benefit from doing that poorly.”

Zheng said the AUS is committed to preserving the diversity of courses offered by the faculty of arts, and will try their best to ensure that student consultation continues to be part of the process.

“There were a lot of questions that were answered [at the Town Hall] … and there was some good rationale on his side of the story,” Zheng said. “But the changes are going to occur, and people still aren’t going to be happy about it.”

Flood takes on McGill campus. (Luke Orlando / McGill Tribune)
a, News

Burst water main damages buildings

Severe flooding from a 48-inch water main break Monday evening caused widespread damage to buildings on campus, confirmed Doug Sweet, Director of Internal Communications of McGill’s Media Relations Office (MRO).

“[The damage is] very extensive to James Annex, where water broke windows in the back of the building and rushed through the main floor,” Sweet said. “That building requires significant repairs.”

According to Sweet, McGill staff and a cleaning firm worked through the night to clean up debris and complete repairs.  Water continues to flow near the Wong and James Administration Buildings, but according to a message from the MRO, the water does not pose a threat to the buildings and is being diverted into the sewer system.

Classes reopened on Tuesday in most buildings following the cleanup operation.  Classes in Wilson Hall and Birks Hall were cancelled, and those at the Wong Building were relocated. Additionally, Service Point and the James Administration Building were closed.  Sweet noted that Wong will likely be closed for a few more days and that administrators are trying to determine when other buildings may be reopened.

The flood began at 4 p.m. when a water main burst under Doctor Penfield Ave. in front of the McTavish Reservoir. Campus buildings were evacuated and all evening classes were cancelled.

The flooded area stretched from Dr. Penfield Ave. to Ste. Catherine Street, and from Union Street to Peel Street, causing pedestrians and traffic to be re-routed in downtown Montreal. At about 9 p.m., the MRO announced that the City of Montreal had shut off the water from the burst main.

The Reservoir is in the middle of the second phase of renovations, which aim to replace the surrounding tank and water mains. The repairs, conducted by the City of Montreal and estimated to cost $16.4 million, began in October 2012 and are expected to be completed in August 2013. Built in 1852, the Reservoir provides drinking water to 500,000 Montrealers in seven boroughs of the city.

A McGill Fire Prevention Crew worker who chose to remain anonymous said that, despite the harsh weather conditions of the past week, the cold was probably not the reason for the break.

“[The construction workers] were working with the big machinery,” he said. “They hit the seal, it broke, and they thought there was no pressure in that pipe, but there was pressure in the water.”

The Students’ Society of McGill University (SSMU) Vice-President Clubs and Services Allison Cooper said the flooding was a great inconvenience for SSMUfest, the Winter semester’s Activities Night. The event was planned for the evening, but had to be rescheduled for Tuesday night, the day after.

“It’s the worst possible timing,” she said. “We told the club leaders to get here at 3:30 p.m., and now they are trapped with no people to greet.”

The MRO sent out a series of emergency emails throughout the evening. One message referred to the flooding as “a serious situation,” and mentioned that “a number of buildings” on the downtown campus had been flooded.

“We are trying to assess damage as best we can, but it will be extensive,” read an MRO message from Monday at 4:55 p.m. “We will provide more information as it becomes available.”

Following the evacuation of the SSMU Building, SSMU President Josh Redel said that there were no signs of flooding in the building.

“We’ve been checking the basement, and everything’s good to go,” Redel said. “We haven’t seen any leaks in areas where we’ve noticed them before.”

In Sept. 2011, a leak in a 16-inch water main at the entrance of the pumping station of the Reservoir

flooded Service Point, McLennan Library, and Wilson Hall. In 2009, a burst in a 42-inch pipe at the top of Dr. Penfield Ave. flooded many of the same buildings.

“We continue to assess damage and costs and will work as hard as we can to get our teaching and research spaces reopened,” Sweet said. “Our prime consideration, of course, is the safety of the members of our community.”

Read the latest issue

Read the latest issue