Latest News

Science & Technology

Donderi begins four-part lecture on psychology of UFO phenomenon

Last Friday, the Redpath Museum auditorium was filled with students and faculty members attending the first of a four-part lecture series by former McGill professor Don Donderi on the psychology and science behind UFOs and aliens.

During his talk, Donderi laid out his basic thoughts on alien encounters, provided scientific insight into numerous examples of documented “close encounters,” and discussed what he intends to convey over the course of the entire lecture series.

“First, [I want to show] that UFOs are so technically capable that national security is completely compromised and is dependent on their restraint,” said Donderi. “Second, that [UFOs] embody a technology far beyond our modern scientific knowledge, and third, that they are extraterrestrial vehicles.”

According to Donderi, UFO’s are often brushed off as non-science because they are surrounded by a great deal of scepticism and disbelief. Donderi attributes this doubt to Leon Festinger’s Theory of Cognitive Dissonance.

“[Festinger’s theory] explains that people tend to deprecate information that contradicts their beliefs. And in the case of UFOs, the extraterrestrial hypothesis at least contradicts a lot of beliefs,” he said. “As a result, it becomes extremely uncomfortable to acknowledge it. The people most likely to reject it … are, for the large, part natural scientists, because they don’t understand it.”

Donderi’s talks are part of the Freaky Fridays lectures, which solicit McGill scientists to discuss popular misconceptions of science fiction and clarify the factual science behind the myths. After each presentation, there is an audience question-and-answer period followed by a popular film matched to the subject material.

Ingrid Birker, the science outreach coordinator and Freaky Fridays organizer, explained that the lecture series has been popular over the past few years, tackling topics ranging from werewolves and sea monsters to melting glaciers and extreme weather. Birker said that Bruno Tremblay, a McGill professor of atmospheric and oceanic sciences, did a presentation last year on melting glaciers which the audience found so interesting that Tremblay was barely able to get past his first power-point slide without handling 45 minutes of questions.

During the question-and-answer period following Donderi’s lecture, it appeared that some of the attendees felt that there were holes in his argument that needed clarification. However, Donderi assured his sceptics that these questions would be answered in the remaining three lectures.

Natacia Tamburello, a McGill alumna, said she that found the lecture interesting, but is waiting for more information from the future lectures.

“All [Donderi] really did was set the stage for later lectures,” said Tamburello. “[Concerning my belief in UFOs,] I’m not on either side of the fence.”

Tristan Brand, another McGill alumnus, was also intrigued by the lecture and thought that Donderi’s approach for conveying his information was a good one.

“I don’t see this as much about trying to convince us of anything as it is about saying this is how this information is handled,” said Brand. “That to me is more interesting because if I came here to have somebody convince me that a UFO existed, I don’t think I’d be sitting here watching a presentation about it that would change my mind, one way or the other.”

The 1956 Invasion of the Body Snatchers followed Donderi’s presentation. Donderi’s remaining three lectures will take place on January 29, February 12 and February 26, all at 5 p.m. in the Redpath Museum auditorium with free admission. The upcoming topics and their corresponding movies are, respectively, “UFO abductions” followed by Communion, “Close Encounters” followed by Close Encounters of the Third Kind, and “Science, Philosophy and UFOs” followed by Contact.

News

AUS, Caribbean Students’ Society respond to Haiti earthquake

In response to the massive earthquake that struck Haiti last week, McGill student organizations and the greater Montreal community are rapidly organizing to raise money and contribute to relief efforts. With over 100,000 Haitians currently living in Montreal, the disaster has mobilized the city’s student community.

On Wednesday evening, the Arts Undergraduate Society executive sent an email to its members, outlining its Haiti fundraising strategy. For the next week, the AUS will be visiting classrooms to collect contributions, and will solicit donations in the AUS lounge. On January 21, the AUS will also host a Bar des Arts event in the AUS lounge, with all proceeds going toward the Haitian relief effort.

AUS President Karina Gould said that between student interest and the support of the Faculties of Education, Law, and Science, the student response has been admirable.

“The feedback has been incredible … We have about 40 to 50 people who have just said ‘what can I do, how can I help?'” Gould said. “It’s amazing to see how quickly people can come together in a time of crisis. It is unfortunate that we require a crisis to come together.”

As of yesterday, the AUS had already raised $4331.10 in its attempt to reach $6,000 by January 25 – approximately one dollar per AUS student. Because the money will be contributed through Oxfam Quebec, an organization on the Haiti Earthquake Relief Fund list, the Canadian government will match every dollar donated with an equal contribution of its own.

Among the groups mobilized in conjunction with the AUS is McGill’s Caribbean Students’ Society. Despite McGill’s relatively small Haitian community compared to other Montreal universities, the CSS has been extremely active in coordinating relief efforts.

“We encourage all McGill students to dig deep and think about the situation that is going on in Haiti, and just to give as much as possible,” said CSS president Kyle Dorsett.

Dorsett added that the CSS is also working with networks such as the National Society of Black Engineers, McGill African Student Society, and the Black Student Network, to develop additional fundraising efforts.

“We are really concerned with making a coordinated, organized effort so that none of these organizations step on each others toes,” said CSS Vice-President Shari Haynes, who also noted the CSS’ collaboration with Concordia.

“Concordia has a fantastic set up and the Concordia administration has gotten deeply involved, so we have somebody more official to appeal to and somebody who can make appeals for Haitian students to corporations and the provincial government.”

Both Dorsett and Haynes said that the most effective role for the CSS currently is to act as an advisor and facilitate communication among individuals and organizations interested in contributing.

In addition to efforts by the AUS and the CSS, the Ghetto Shul, a synagogue run by McGill students, offered its Park Avenue building to host “Hope for Haiti” last Saturday night. The event, which had an open-donation cover charge, raised over $1,000 for the Doctors Without Borders Haitian relief effort.

“We already had a small Saturday night event planned and I was just feeling so heartbroken … and then I realized that we could easily change it into a fundraiser – get some musicians together, get some people buying beers – and send the money down,” said Leibish Hundert, Ghetto Shul Rabbi. “These are human beings and we care – and that trumps everything.”

Also on Wednesday, McGill Principal Heather Munroe-Blum issued a statement offering the university’s condolences to members of the Haitian community and McGill community who have been affected by the earthquake.

The university also announced yesterday that it will participate in a moment of silence to commemorate the victims of the earthquake. The commemoration is scheduled for 4:53 p.m., precisely one week after the earthquake struck, and will be observed by all other universities in the Conference of Rectors and Principals of Quebec Universities.

Although no current students, faculty, or staff have been identified among the casualties, The Globe and Mail has reported the death of McGill alumnus Guillaume Siemienski, an employee of the Canadian International Development Agency. Siemienkski had previously worked in Georgia, Russia, Turkey, and Slovakia, and was on assignment in Haiti with the United Nations.

News

New fee: it’s complicated

In an effort to close a multimillion-dollar shortfall in the university’s budget, the McGill administration has introduced a small charge on all revenues received by the university’s self-funding units.

These units, which include Students Services, Athletics, Food & Dining Services, and the residence system, operate semi-autonomously from the rest of the university, at least in a financial sense. Student Services, for example, receives funding from a combination of student fees, sales to students, and other smaller sources.

The new charge, known as the Overhead Recovery Fee, redirects 1.5 per cent of revenues generated by these units to McGill’s central administration. Every time students buy beer at Redmen hockey games, for instance, or condoms at the Shag Shop, 1.5 per cent of the profits from those purchases are funnelled toward the McGill administration.

According to Deputy Provost (Student Life and Learning) Morton Mendelson, the income generated by the new fee goes toward paying for services provided to the self-funding units by the central administration. Units such as Student Services, he argues, make use of the university’s human resources staff, the accounting department, the McGill website, and other assets. The new fee helps to pay for those operations.

“There is work that is done for those units, and that is part of the cost of business of those units, but up until now the units haven’t been contributing to that cost,” Mendelson said.

Because the administration has exempted students fees – which make up the majority of the revenue of Student Services – from the charge as part of a phasing-in period, the Overhead Recovery Fee is only projected to bring in about $15,000 from Student Services this fiscal year.

Student Services, said Jana Luker, the unit’s executive director, hasn’t been negatively affected by the new fee.

“We haven’t reduced any services,” she said. “We’ve been able to hold our own.”

According to preliminary budget estimates, however, the charge will redirect approximately $183,000 from Student Services to the administration next year when the exemption is removed.

Rebecca Dooley, the Students’ Society’s vice-president university affairs, said SSMU is currently taking “a cautious line” on the issue.

“We want students to understand where their money’s going,” Dooley said. “And if students think that it’s going directly toward hiring somebody in Mental Health Services, for example, that’s where we want to see it going.”

According to Mendelson, however, this misrepresents the way that the university manages its finances. If Mental Health Services hires a new counsellor, he said, students expect their money to go towards paying that counsellor’s salary, benefits, and perhaps the cost of the building she works in. But the central administration must also pay for the cost of hiring the counsellor and issuing her a paycheque each week, which students often fail to realize.

“It’s all part of the cost of having the extra person in the position,” he said.

Still, SSMU President Ivan Neilson shares Dooley’s scepticism about the fairness of the Overhead Recovery Fee.

“The position of the Students’ Society [is] that these departments are providing fundamental services to the university and to the students and should not be charged, similar to any other department at McGill,” he said.

Though there is a possibility that the fee could go up in the future, Luker said that is probably an unlikely scenario.

“I can’t imagine that happening,” she said. “It’s not in anybody’s best interest.”

Sports

Martlets come alive late to dispatch Gee-Gees, keep streak alive

Midway through the third period of women’s hockey action at McConnell Arena on Friday night, the McGill Martlets found themselves having to tune out the chants coming from the seats directly above the Ottawa University bench. With the game tied at two apiece and the momentum seemingly on the visitors’ side, McGill’s monumental winning streak seemed on the verge of collapse. A lucky break and two slap shots later, the Martlets were able to let out a collective sigh of relief, as they walked away with their 71st straight win against CIS competition.

Rearguard Caroline Hill rifled in a hard slap shot from the point for the game-winner with a little less than two minutes left in regulation, and defensive stalwart Cathy Chatrand rounded off the scoring with another long-range bomb as the Martlets hung on to beat Ottawa, 4-2.

“It was a really tight game,” said first-year McGill Head Coach Amey Doyle. “Ottawa played us really hard and I thought that they battled really hard. They skated for 60 minutes and our girls had to match their effort. [But] we stuck to our game plan, got the puck deep and got it on net.”

With less than 10 minutes to go, however, all signs pointed towards an Ottawa upset. While McGill was able to control the overall tempo of the game, a series of mental lapses and a tendency for over-aggression nearly doomed the home squad. A bad giveaway on the offensive blueline allowed Ottawa forward Erika Pouliot to score off a breakaway with 10 minutes left, knotting the game and electrifying the Gee-Gee fans in attendance.

Two minutes later, the Ottawa defence managed to spark yet another breakaway, and a stunned silence fell over the arena before the referees blew off what appeared to be another Gee-Gee goal.

“[Ottawa] was just jamming really hard at Taylor [Salisbury’s] pads,” said Chatrand. “The puck came loose, but it never went in and the refs blew off the play.”

Ottawa looked visibly deflated after the referees had made their decisions, and were unable to generate any offensive momentum when it mattered the most. McGill put their championship poise on display as they dominated the Gee-Gees in the closing moments of the game.

“Every time you score off a shot from the blueline, it’s a surprise because goaltenders are so good [these days],” said Chatrand. “We were very fortunate to have been on the right side of the scoreboard.”

Although the Martlets walked away with the win, Friday night’s game made clear the fact that Doyle’s squad still has a lot of work to do if they wish to challenge for yet another championship banner. The team was able to work out some of the kinks from the Ottawa game on Saturday afternoon when they took on cross-town rival Concordia, winning easily by a score of 3-0.

“I think the girls definitely learned something [from last night’s game],” said Doyle. “They showed a lot more grit and positionally, they were better. That’s why we were able to control most of the play.”

Doyle’s attention to detail and the team’s constant desire to improve have played important roles in McGill’s success so far. When asked about the streak, Doyle was hard-pressed to come up with the exact number of wins.

“We definitely have some kind of a mental record in our head, but we don’t think too much about it,” she said. “We focus on the game at hand, and I concentrate on my job to get the right person at the right time to win the game. If we win a game, it’s great, and if we lose a game, we will learn something from it.”

McGill looks to extend their record-setting win-streak on January 17, when they travel to Ottawa to face the Gee-Gees on their home turf. The Martlets arrive back in Montreal on January 22 to take on the Montreal Carabins at 7 p.m.

McGill, News

AMUSE gains accreditation

After a year and a half of campaigning, the Association of McGill University Support Employees, the organization composed of McGill’s 3,000 casual workers, has unionized and affiliated with the Public Service Alliance of Canada.

The campaign, which began in September 2008, started when a group of undergraduate students in the McGill work study program felt they needed a union structure to balance their working conditions with those of the represented colleagues.

After considering several possible representative bodies, AMUSE organizers chose the PSAC, also known in French as the Alliance de la Fonction publique du Canada. Although the exact figure is not public, AMUSE collected signatures from the 35 to 50 per cent of eligible card signing members necessary to move to an official vote. Conducted by mail in ballot beginning October fifth, the poll saw approximately 85 per cent of voters recommend in favour of joining the PSAC. Abstentions were treated as votes in negation.

“This new bargaining unit is huge,” said Véroninque Allard, leading campaign representative from the PSAC. “It is really a major change. You already have on campus [McGill University Non-Academic Certified Association], but when these people go on sick leave or parental leave, or when a job position becomes vacant, it is replaced be a casual worker. [This worker] is accomplishing exactly the same tasks, same job title, but these people were not unionized before.”

Allard emphasized that the distinction between student and worker should never be confused.

“Our student status should never be confused with our worker status; it is not the same,” said Allard. “Sometimes, because we are so keen to work on campus and we need to work on campus because we can’t get by with student loans, the work on campus becomes a part of our education. We tend to forget that it is a job and accept working conditions that are unfair.”

Casual workers who will now be unionized include campus tour guides, athletic centre employees, food service workers, and temporary secretaries. Because AMUSE is exclusive to non-academic workers, teaching assistants are not included under the organization.

“It is an exciting result with the massive amount of support that came out, but we were not expecting much else given the amount of support that we have received up until now,” said Max Silverman, AMUSE student volunteer and Tribune columnist.

Despite the inevitable high turnover rate of temporary employees, particularly undergraduate students, Silverman believes that widespread support across various positions indicates the need for workers to organize.

“The diversity of the field that still all gave positive support … shows me, at least, that the workers may change year to year but the issues are still there and the issues stay the same,” said Silverman, who previously served as the Students’ Society vice president external. “Therefore I have no doubt that even if there has been a lot of turnover, the new people who are there are going to see this as just as valuable as [those before].”

Silverman also believes that although a wide variety of positions are covered under the agreement, the common need for representation of casual workers creates a shared interest.

Before negotiations over a collective bargaining agreement with McGill commence, AMUSE must still assemble executive and bargaining committees, establish operating bylaws, and agree internally upon demands.

The PSAC now represents roughly 19,000 workers across eight Quebec Universities.

News

Talking to John F. Burns, the globetrotting foreign correspondent

On a Saturday evening several weeks ago, John F. Burns and I filed into King’s College, Cambridge, for evening services. Burns, the chief foreign correspondent for The New York Times, does not seem at first glance like a particularly religious man. The 65-year-old McGill graduate is a tall man, solidly built, with a mop of curly, light grey hair and a white beard. In the years he has spent reporting abroad, Burns has filed stories from some of the world’s most disparate and dangerous locales – everywhere from Afghan mountaintops to armoured Land Rovers in Bosnia. But when you lead such an unpredictable life, he told me, there is something comforting about attending services every so often.

From Britain to McGill

Born in 1944 to a South African father and an English mother, Burns grew up attending British boarding schools, an experience he seems to have both valued and detested.

“The headmasters and housemasters at private schools in this country in the 1950s were running dictatorships,” he said during a recent interview in Cambridge, comparing the atmosphere in the repressive societies in which he reported later in life.

Just after his graduation from secondary school, Burns’ father, an officer in the Royal Air Force, accepted a posting in Vancouver. Though he had already secured a place at Pembroke College, Cambridge, Burns decided to take a gap year with his parents in Canada.

“Having been through a British boys’ school that had changed little since the time of Dickens, I felt the moment I stepped on shore in Canada like I’d found freedom,” Burns said, adding that he met his first serious girlfriend in Canada that year. “I loved it, absolutely loved it, and nothing was going to bring me back to [Britain].”

Startling his mother, whose family had attended Cambridge for generations, Burns instead decided to enrol at McGill, where he studied political science and economics.

Charles Taylor, the eminent political philosopher and current emeritus professor, was Burns’ chief intellectual influence while he was at McGill, lecturing Burns and other admiring students on Locke, Hobbes, and Milton.

“We loved him. We would have done anything for him,” Burns said. “What I learned in the classroom at McGill from Charles Taylor has informed my entire personal and professional life.”

An Unlikely Journalist

It was in the McGill library that Burns first read The New York Times, which turned him into a voracious newspaper reader. Burns persuaded an editor at the now-defunct Ottawa Journal to give him a week’s trial as a reporter one summer.

“I got involved in interesting stories and I loved it and I thought every single day I spent in the newsroom was more interesting than any day I’d spent in the university library,” he said. “That’s how I got into this business.”

After a stint reporting for the Ottawa Citizen following his graduation from McGill, Burns was recruited by The Globe and Mail, where he became a parliamentary correspondent covering Pierre Trudeau’s government.

In 1970, Quebec separatists ignited the October Crisis by kidnapping James Cross, the British trade commissioner, and Pierre Laporte, the Quebec government’s minister of labour. On one particularly tense day, Burns became embroiled in a confrontation with Trudeau’s press secretary, Romeo LeBlanc, as he was rushing to ask the prime minister a question.

“He accused me of eavesdropping, and I said, ‘No, I’m not eavesdropping, I’m trying to get the prime minister.’ Trudeau, hearing this, turned around – and he punched me. Knocked me over into an overstuffed armchair.”

In the confusion that followed, security ejected Burns from Parliament and stripped him of his press credentials. Though these were eventually reinstated, The Globe and Mail’s editors chose to reassign Burns to China.

Oddly enough, Burns and Trudeau met again in 1973 when the prime minister made his historic visit to China. Trudeau, remembering the young reporter he had hit three years earlier, asked Burns to ride with him for the duration of his visit. Burns agreed, and the men spent the next two days talking.

With a laugh, Trudeau asked him what had happened after the incident during the October Crisis. “Well,” Burns replied, “you punched me in the nose, and you changed my life.”

On Assignment for The Times

After Burns had spent several years in China, A.M. Rosenthal, the Canadian-born managing editor at The New York Times, took notice of his work. One article in particular, entitled “1,001 Ways to Lie in China,” which described the duplicitous nature of the Chinese bureaucracy, caught Rosenthal’s eye. He offered Burns a job in New York, and in 1975, Burns reluctantly accepted.

Burns was convinced that he wouldn’t make it at the Times when he took the job, even staying in a hotel rather than finding an apartment because he did not believe the job would last. One night in 1975, however, he got his break. According to Burns, he was standing at the elevators at The Times waiting to leave when the city editor told him to get to LaGuardia Airport. “Something’s happened,” the editor said. “Sounds like an explosion.”

Burns raced to LaGuardia through heavy traffic and leapt out of his cab a mile from the airport, scaling a fence and sprinting across the tarmac in the rain toward the terminal. Once inside, he found a payphone and called his editors, describing the chaotic scene. Police were everywhere. Several people were dead, and others were injured. After several hours of chasing through the airport and the local hospitals, an exhausted Burns returned to the Times, convinced he’d botched the assignment.

“When I walked into the newsroom, people on the metro desk applauded,” Burns recalled. “I thought, ‘This is some sort of a joke.'”

It wasn’t. His telephoned reports had been rewritten into a front-page story with a banner headline, which ran under his by-line though Burns hadn’t technically written a word of it. The editors congratulated him on the piece and, according to Burns, his career at the newspaper turned around.

Sarajevo, Afghanistan, and Beyond

Over the next decade and a half, Burns reported for The Times from many far-flung locales. In 1991, he was assigned to Sarajevo to cover the escalating war in the Balkans.

By May 1992, however, the United Nations and the foreign press corps had decided to evacuate Sarajevo, as thousands of artillery shells hammered the city. Burns reluctantly joined the exodus, but stopped when the convoy reached the outskirts of the city.

“As soon as we were gone, the Serbs, who were shelling the city, thinking that they’d put out the eyes of the world, redoubled their attacks,” Burns said. “Within 24 hours of our leaving, the city was on fire. And I thought, ‘This can’t be right.’ So I filled my car with food, and I drove back in there.”

Burns couldn’t believe what he saw as he returned: burning cars with dead bodies in them, breadlines hit by artillery shells, soccer stadiums turned into cemeteries. Though he initially intended to stay only an additional weekend, Burns found shelter with a local family and decided he had a duty to remain in Sarajevo.

After several more weeks in Sarajevo, Burns lost touch with his editors at The Times, who had ordered him out of the city. “For three months, four months, I was the only journalist there,” he said. “The whole press corps was gone.”

At the end of the year, however, an editor at The Times contacted him and asked him to write one final story about what he’d seen that year – usually a sign that a reporter’s work is being considered for the Pulitzer Prize. According to Burns, he filed the story from his armoured Land Rover in the middle of the night, praying a Serbian soldier wouldn’t fire at the glow from his laptop. In 1993, he won the Pulitzer Prize for International Reporting.

In the following years, Burns reported from both Afghanistan, where he won a second Pultizer
for his coverage of the rise of the Taliban, and Iraq, where he spent five years covering the American invasion and the sectarian fighting that followed. In 2007, Burns finally returned to Britain after 45 years abroad to take a post as The Times’ London bureau chief.

Though he admits to missing some of the thrills of life abroad – flying low over the mountains of Afghanistan in a military helicopter, for instance – Burns appears content to be back in Britain. If nothing else, he can now attend evensong at the King’s College chapel at Cambridge.

McGill, News

McGill joins Blair foundation

Last month, McGill University became an official partner of the Tony Blair Faith Foundation and a committed member to the foundation’s Faith and Globalization Initiative.

Founded in 2008 by former British prime minister Tony Blair, the foundation seeks to cultivate respect and cooperation among the world’s major religions, as well as to work with religious groups on development projects and education programs.

The foundation’s Faith and Globalization Initiative focusses on researching the ways in which the boundaries between religions have impeded efforts to combat poverty and other maladies.

McGill is the fourth university to partner with the foundation, joining Yale, Durham University in England, and the National University of Singapore. Research at McGill under the initiative will focus on faith issues relevant to Canada, such as the faith of indigenous peoples and the connection between faith and human rights.

“I’m really quite energized about the initiative,” said Ellen Aitken, dean of the faculty of religious studies. “I think it’s a very exciting partnership for McGill that has a lot of exciting possibilities for students, for the research community, and for McGill’s connections to universities and others worldwide.”

According to Aitken, the university is planning a variety of events designed to engage the surrounding community, such as public lectures, research conferences, and campus-wide events.

McGill is also developing a new multi-disciplinary program of study, including a new course for undergraduates. The course will be open to approximately 120 students and will explore the links between globalization and the world’s religions.

“There are a lot of students at McGill who really see an understanding of the world’s religions as crucial to being an effective and innovative member in today’s society, in whatever they choose to do in the future,” Aitken said.

The program delves into the principal issues addressed by the Tony Blair Faith Foundation, as well as establishing connections such as internships for undergraduates, with the organization.

“At this point the horizon is wide,” Aitken said. “A lot is possible. The foundation is deeply committed to working with all the ideas we generate from here, and our partnership with other universities, people and communities will just add to the capacity we have here at McGill.”

Features

Suicide: it’s everybody’s problem

On November 18, a revision to the Criminal Code that makes it illegal to “counsel a person to commit suicide” or aid or abet them in doing so, regardless of whether they are successful, was passed unanimously in the House of Commons. The revision, which was proposed by Kitchener-Conestoga Member of Parliament Harold Albrecht, was a response to the March 2008 suicide of Nadia Kajouji, a first-year student at Carleton University who drowned herself in the Rideau River. A police search of her laptop revealed conversations with a 47-year-old male nurse who, according to chat room transcripts, both encouraged her to kill herself and suggested she hang rather than drown herself so that he could watch.

Among Canadian university students, suicide is a leading cause of death, second only to car accidents. And while suicides are nothing new, questions over what drives young adults to end their lives, and what prevention measures universities should employ, are still unresolved.

“Suicide is a human disaster,” says Rory Butler, president of Your Life Counts, an online resource for youth considering suicide or engaging in self-destructive behaviour. “For every death by suicide, there are over 100 attempts. It really is a silent epidemic that affects communities across the country and there is no strata of society that is more susceptible to it than anyone else. It’s everybody’s problem.”

Suicides on university campuses

According to Robert Pihl, a McGill psychology professor, surveys of university students show that 46 per cent have a diagnosable disorder. “For the majority of youth it’s alcohol and drugs, and that’s an ephemeral problem. But there are still 10 to 11 per cent who have mood or personality disorders, where it is a concomitant risk for suicide.”

Dr. Robert Franck, clinical director of McGill Mental Health Services, explains that there are many factors involved in the occurrence of mental disorders and suicidal acts amongst university students. “Students being away from familial support combined with potential triggers such as financial worries, self-isolation, drug abuse, excessive perfectionism resulting in self-disappointment, relationship problems, questions around sexual identity, etc.,” he says.

According to Franck, late adolescence is also when ailments like major depression and anxiety disorders are often first diagnosed. Butler adds that certain individuals can find this stage of development, and the changes it entails, particularly trying, which can lead to destructive behaviour.

“When it comes to university, being away from home, there comes into play a whole host of new things that you begin to deal with on a day-to-day basis, in residence or living in rented accommodation, that you haven’t come across before,” says Butler.

McGill is doing its part to help students struggling with mental health issues. Mental Health Services has witnessed an increase in students seeking aid and counselling, which is part of a larger upward trend in universities across North America. A recent study conducted by the University of Pittsburgh’s National Survey of Counseling Directors found that 94 per cent of college counselling directors reported an increase in students with significant psychological conditions such as depression, drug and alcohol addictions, and eating disorders.

“There is ongoing debate as to whether the incidence of these illnesses is on the increase, or whether we are better at identifying these conditions which are already there,” says Frank. “De-stigmatizing psychological problems facilitates students seeking help, as does encouragement from floor fellows, faculty advisers, and academic staff. Unfortunately, however, many students still hide their symptoms of depression or anxiety from their family or peers.”

McGill is taking measures to ensure that students in residence are provided with appropriate resources. Floor fellows are trained to help students who may be experiencing depression or anxiety, ranging from everyday stresses to more destructive behaviours. “When we have students who are having suicidal thoughts and who approach us, we first make them promise not to take any actions until we can work together to find a way to improve the situation,” says Nida Nizam, a floor fellow at New Residence Hall. “We can set them up with Mental Health and work with the student to find the best solution to their issues.”

Franck also emphasizes the positive role of student-run services in encouraging students struggling with mental issues to seek help. Nightline, for instance, is a confidential service allowing students to anonymously connect with student volunteers who are trained to deal with a variety of questions or concerns, even suicidal thoughts.

“Student-led initiatives are extremely helpful – Nightline, Queer McGill, SAACOMS, Headspace, etc. – in providing peer support,” says Franck.

Jane Everett, dean of students at McGill, explains that student services at McGill have multiplied in the past decade in order to make students’ lives easier. “[Aid from student services] is a way to get many of the distractors and the stress out of your life so you can go forward smoothly. Take advantage of this – you’re paying for it, so it’s something you’re entitled to,” says Everett.

In loco parentis

Another aspect of university suicides is where to draw the line between a student’s right to privacy and the school’s responsibility to intervene in the event of a crisis. Under the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act Carleton University failed to notify Kajouji’s parents that she had been receiving counselling and exhibiting suicidal behaviours. Similarly, in the case of Elizabeth Shin – a student at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology who set herself on fire in her dorm room in 2000 – her parents claimed that the university made matters worse by not informing them of the suicidal tendencies their daughter displayed in the month before her death.

Assuming that their students are adults with the right to autonomy and privacy, administrators at MIT follow a policy of only involving parents if they provide invaluable assistance to the individual in question. Like MIT, McGill operates under the assumption that they are dealing not with children but adults, and as such no exception is made for students living away from home. The university is not responsible for acting in loco parentis – Latin for “in the place of parents” – and therefore treats its students as they would staff members, i.e., as consenting adults.

Everett explains that until the individual’s life is directly in danger, provincial legislation prohibits the disclosure of personal information without the student’s consent. In the event that a certain “crisis point” has been reached, often health care professionals as opposed to parents will be notified.

“[Counsellors and health care professionals] are bound by professional codes of ethics … There are very specific instances in which they can communicate with family members,” says Everett. “From what I understand, the crisis point would be the direct threat. This is a duty that we all have as citizens – if someone’s in harm, you tell someone. But you may not necessarily tell family members.”

Under provincial privacy legislation, the university may not release the private information of its students – including any counselling records of a history of mental disorders – to any third party who is not directly involved, except in the event of an immediate crisis. A revision to Section 59.1 of Bill 180 states that relevant information may be released only “without the consent of the persons concerned, in order to prevent an act of violence, where there is reasonable cause to believe that there is an imminent danger of death or serious bodily injury.”

“There are cases when one should inform whoever can help prevent,” says Pihl. “It is a temporary problem and if you don’t do something, then you are being unethical.
If a person talks to a professional about suicide, they’ve come to you for help and it’s your job to do what you can to help them.”

McGill Mental Health Services is doing all that they can to provide resources to the students who seek their help, and operates within the confines of Quebec confidentiality law when it comes to releasing information about a patient’s health.

Though the school will not act in the parents’ place, students may choose to maintain a higher level of parental participation in his or her university life. “Some students are perfectly happy to sign waivers allowing their parents to have access to information,” says Everett.

Your life counts – whether you think it does or not

While Canada does lack a national suicide prevention strategy, smaller groups and organizations outside of the university context such as Your Life Counts are also providing means of prevention.

“We want to be there before a crisis hits,” says Rory Butler, CEO and president of YLC. “I’m a suicide survivor myself, and I reached a point in my life when I really believed that my family would be better off without me, so I know what it is like to feel as if life is no longer worth living.”

Through an email response system, YLC aims to provide an anonymous platform in which youth – mostly between the ages of 14 and 24 – can vent. In contrast to therapists, hotlines, or even parents and friends, YLC enables youth to speak to trained professionals in a less confrontational manner than one-on-one counselling.

“Sometimes reaching out for help is the hardest thing of all,” says Butler. “There are some youth who would rather die than speak to anyone. Someone who is spinning into crisis is not in the right shape to make a phone call. We’re trying to go straight into their world in an unthreatening way.”

In the last year, the site received over 980 emails from concerned youth, and this year The Institute of Communication Agencies has even adopted YLC as their focus charity in 2010. By offering a safe heaven in which those looking to voice some of their difficulties can do so, YLC hopes to enable youth to recognize that with a little help and support, their problems can be fixed.

YLC’s success is also in large part due to the help of those who have suffered the tragic loss of a family member to suicide. Two such volunteers are Muhammad and Mark Kajouji, father and brother of Nadia, who have become ambassadors on behalf of YLC.

“Their concern is to work with the system, to help the system, to understand where the pitfalls and dangers lie,” says Butler. “And how we can begin to ensure that the dreadful loss of Nadia doesn’t happen again.”

The criminalization of suicide attests to the desperation on the part of the government to dissuade those contemplating ending their own lives. That is why mental health services on campuses and online organizations like YLC seek to remind youth that their problems can be addressed long before suicide becomes the only alternative. Both Butler and Pihl affirm that “suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem” – it is a remedy to an ephemeral state of mind, and one that cannot be taken back.

Student Life

Food for Thought: It’s the attack of the Killer tomatoes

It’s not always hard to be an ethical eater. I grew up on Long Island where fresh fish is easily found and organic produce comes from local farms on the east end of the island and nearby New Jersey (surprisingly fertile), and winters are relatively mild.

Montreal, however, provides a distinct set of challenges to ethical eaters. While during summer nearby Quebec and Ontario farms produce delicious foodstuffs, the harsh winters place limitations on vegetable production. Is it possible to eat fresh vegetables and still be an ethical eater? Yes and no. There are some seasonal vegetables that are available to satisfy fresh-food cravings. But there are some vegetables, I’m afraid, that we’re going to have to forego in their just-picked form if we want to be environmentally responsible and treat ourselves well.

Winter produce is pretty obvious: dark greens like kale, chard and broccoli; roots like potatoes, carrots, Jerusalem artichokes; and the gourd family. The meals this ingredient list calls to mind seem heavy – along the lines of thick stews and roasts – and they are. Salads in the middle of winter don’t make any sense at all. For instance, one of the most disgusting inventions of agriculture is the winter tomato. It might be grown in California, or South America, but after it’s been flown to Montreal, it arrives pale pink, mealy, and a pathetic reminder of what tomatoes are supposed to look and taste like in August. Please stop purchasing these monsters. Chop up a nice pear instead to throw into your salad.

Here’s what I’m really babbling about: eating sub-par produce out of season just isn’t worth it. In the frigid winter, our bodies crave warm meals with a ton of carbs and fat. And I think we should listen. Out-of-season vegetables should be purchased in their canned, dried, or frozen forms. I know that we’ve been taught that every vegetable is better when it’s just been pulled from the vine, but in this case, that’s wrong. Fresh tomatoes, bell peppers, raspberries, and peaches in January, in Montreal, are bizarre.

Last night I cooked a dish that I enjoy more or less year round. I seared a few thick chicken breasts and braised them in white wine and tomatoes. This time, I began the dish with chopped shallots, dried oregano, and a bay leaf. When I had browned both sides of the chicken, I stirred in some wine to deglaze the pan and added half of a can of diced tomatoes. I served the chicken in its thin sauce over beautiful, thick mashed potatoes blended with some sautéed leeks (keep the tops of your leaks to make vegetable stock). In the summer I would have used fresh tomatoes, perhaps added some baby spinach, and fresh basil instead of dried oregano.

Winter doesn’t look bleak to me at all from my kitchen window. It looks a little bit rich, with some extra tablespoons of butter here and there, but honestly it’s what I believe nature intended.

Recipes, Student Life

The only Irish coffee you’ll ever need

Irish coffee combines two of life’s greatest joys – caffeine and booze – in one convenient glass. The recipe below uses Jameson whiskey both because it’s delicious and tastes slightly sweet, which compliments the coffee very nicely.

There are variations of this drink that include Bailey’s, crème de menthe, spices, decorative coffee beans, and lighting things on fire at strategic moments. But instead of relying on gimmicky green food colouring to add zest to your drink, let delicious simplicity speak for itself.

Ingredients

  • 12 oz hot coffee
  • 1 oz Jameson Irish whiskey (or to taste)
  • 1 Tbsp. sugar (or to taste; sugar is necessary, however, for floating cream on top)
  • 4 Tbsp. heavy cream
  • Boiling water

Directions

  1. Fill a mug with boiling water. Set aside (later, the heated mug will keep the coffee hot longer).
  2. Whip cream lightly until slightly thickened; it should be light enough to float on coffee, but still liquid enough to pour. It’s best to use eggbeaters or a whisk, but a fork, a small bowl, and sheer will also do the trick. Set aside.
  3. Empty the mug of water. Add sugar to taste, then the coffee, leaving about three centimetres of space from the top of the cup. Stir until sugar is dissolved.
  4. Add the Jameson and stir once. Immediately add the prepared cream by pouring it over the back of a spoon held just above the coffee in order to keep the coffee and cream from mixing. Do not stir. Share and enjoy.

Read the latest issue

Read the latest issue