Latest News

Opinion

Campus Conversations: Curiosity 

by Lulu Calame, Jayda Smith, Sophia Micomonaco on

More in Opinion:

On preserving childhood curiosity

Lulu Calame, Contributor

The greatest tragedy that comes with adulthood is that it is no longer acceptable to be freely curious. 

I grew up on a small island on the eastern tip of Maine, and my greatest victories lay in the discovery of a washed-up buoy or the bobbing purple head of a lion jellyfish under the downtown fishing pier. These discoveries were to no end but my own excitement, and I never wished them to be anything more. 

But with growing up comes an awful social expectation that the world’s mystery should melt away and be replaced with a logical curiosity in only the things that hold productive value. Whether that be a degree, a career, or a salary—curiosity is no longer serendipitous, but mechanized. It is no longer appropriate to be curious with justification of its productivity––and this product is never just whimsical pleasure. 

I often wonder, being only on the edge of adulthood, when I might cease to find a frozen puddle worth stopping for. I am already saddened that I no longer jump inside an elevator to see if my head will hit the ceiling, or that I have stopped running outside in the morning to test whether last night’s snowfall is powder or packable—always hoping for the latter, because every sledding hill needs a jump. I am sure that my eight-year-old self, for whom there was nothing more important than such explorations, would be shocked at the indifference ten years have brought; and I am scared further still for what ten more years might take. 

Such unabashed curiosity requires a vulnerability that adults have sadly been trained to avoid, but which should be preserved at all costs; it honors the unpredictable, the odd, and the subtly beautiful. It makes me sad that an adult’s destination is such an imposition that they no longer stop to watch an ant carry a twig twice its size down the sidewalk. 

Allowing oneself to be freely curious, and, for even ten seconds, to commit one’s thoughts wholly and unapologetically to something as small as an ant, holds an importance that the grown-up world has forgotten.

Curiouser and curiouser: Dogs, dildos and discovery 

Jayda Smith, Staff Writer 

I need to do something more interesting than just studying before I die. A jarring thought that might lead some to hop on a plane to Europe and others to start training for a marathon, but one that led me to attend animal therapy in the Healthy Living Annex of the Brown Building––the beginning of a series of curiosity-led escapades. 

Animal therapy is where I met Bau. Bau is an adorable Bichon who skillfully performs his duties as a therapy dog. I laughed as Bau executed various athletic manoeuvres; he sat, laid down and danced bipedally. Animal therapy wasn’t the only engaging thing the Annex offered. Across from where I sat was a store called The Shag Shop.

It sells affordable and inclusive sexual health products, including, but not limited to, menstrual cups and adult toys. Shame had stifled my curiosity and prevented me from visiting before, but now that I was only a few feet away, I couldn’t pass on the opportunity. Somewhere between nervousness and indecision, I found her. The Double Dancer: A purple toy that boasts three speeds of increasing vibration and “dual flickering teasers” (whatever that means). I tried not to look too embarrassed as I cashed out and hurriedly stuffed the device into my backpack. It was my first time buying such a toy, but embarrassment was a small price to pay for a new experience. Needing one last adventure to end the day, I took a trip to the farmer’s market in the SSMU building. My most remarkable find was a book: “Anansi the Spider: A Tale from the Ashanti.” 

This tale featured a famous trickster spider from Ashanti folklore. Though the tale originates from West Africa, I know Anansi intimately. In Belize, my home country, we learn of Anansi’s hijinks around the same time we learn our multiplication tables. It touched me that culture was strong enough to have preserved Anansi across thousands of miles, depositing him safely from West Africa to Belize. 

From just one day of exploring my curiosities, I found therapy dogs, sex toys, and home, all on one campus. What else might I find if I ask more questions? Exploring my curiosities turned into self-care and self-discovery, and it all started with a dog. 

Changing majors and career paths

Sophia Micomonaco, Contributor

Last week, I attended a conference on campus for women students interested in finance. As someone who considers changing majors weekly, the thought of choosing a career is one of my biggest sources of anxiety. I signed up for the conference wondering if finance could be my new calling.

I would consider myself a “big-picture person,” partly because of this anxiety. I view every possibility as if it will affect me in fifty years’ time. I judge new ideas intensely and make a plan for outcomes A, B, and C (with subsections). In the past I have decided on plans and then strongly stuck to them, like when I thought that I was going to major in philosophy. I signed up for philosophy courses and realized that I didn’t really like them, but I stuck it out because I was fearful of losing the path I had temporarily chosen. When these courses didn’t go as well as I had hoped, I tried again with more subjects, repeating this cycle of confusion and dissatisfaction in the pursuit of the “perfect” subject area for me. 

The conference featured successful women in finance as its speakers, some who did not hold finance degrees––just like me. Participants asked a range of questions and many of the speakers unknowingly provided very similar answers. When asked what they were looking for in an internship candidate, the most common response was “curiosity.” A lot of the women said that it was okay to change careers, and that one’s past decisions wouldn’t be a waste. If you were curious about something, even if it ended up being the wrong fit for you, at least you tried. 

This provided me with a lot of reassurance, because my attempts to plan for one kind of career were dwindling. The week before the finance conference I was planning for my career in public relations… or mediation… or both. I don’t know if I’m going to work in finance, but now I at least know that I’m interested as I am with so many other things. This time, I’m going to accept that I don’t have a plan yet—because it’s better to be curious than resistant. 

Off the Board, Opinion

What to do if you can’t be an astronaut

by Chloé Kichenane on

More in Off the Board:

I’ve always wanted to be an astronaut. When I was seven, I begged my mom for a telescope, convinced that the €40 plastic lens would equip me well enough to pierce through the polluted Parisian sky and uncover the secrets of the universe. I never got the telescope, and so naturally, I never became an astronaut.

Carrying the weight of this professional failure at such a young age was incredibly distressing. Years passed, and as I slowly mourned the loss of a life spent in space, while the calls of the job market only became louder. I needed to find something else. At eleven years old, I finally decided: I was going to be a journalist. After all, I liked asking unnecessary questions and writing stories about everything and nothing, so why not?

Well, dear past-me, here’s a few “why nots.” My parents get credit for most of them, and sadly, part of me can’t even disagree. When I come home to visit, conversations at the dinner table go to the tune of how will you make money to start a family?, journalism is a dying industry and AI will take your job, or —my personal favourite—feminist girls like you should be in science. Yet here I am at twenty years old, having failed modern feminism and writing about it for my university’s newspaper. Nine years after abandoning space exploration, I still want to be a journalist.   

Journalism never came to me as a revelation. I found myself wavering among choices, swinging back and forth between a career in diplomacy, publishing or the music industry until eventually, journalism was the only thing that stuck—a blessing and a curse. As I see many around me facing an existential crisis, uncertain of the life their future job may bring them, I sometimes envy them. Truly, I often wish I didn’t know where I was heading. In French, we say journalism is a “métier-passion,” or a job you need to do with passion—but passion doesn’t pay the bills.

With every local paper shutting down or falling into the hands of another conservative billionaire, with every new team of reporters being laid off or every ad that pops up as I read my articles—my heart sinks a little. I think to myself, “Democracy does not die in darkness, it dies behind a paywall.”

My worries are not simply about the industry itself. Our collective attention spans are getting shorter, and we mostly consume news in concentrated shots of information. How can we produce compelling stories that hold the powerful accountable, if no one has the bandwidth to read them? Is there a future where people have the time to read past the headline? I don’t have the answers to any of these questions, and frankly, I’m not sure I want to know anyway. Despite this, my hope for journalism is undeterred and I still pine for a future in it. 

I’m well aware that student journalism is its own comfortable bubble, where being overworked and underpaid is not an immediate reality. Maybe that’s precisely the reason why I still have so much hope—it’s a tiny window into what professional journalism could be, in a better world. Every time I open a new issue, my doubts about the future seem to go away as my eyes glide over the freshly printed paper. There is a new generation out there that still understands the importance of writing people’s stories, of speaking truth to power. 

But I realize now that it doesn’t really matter whether I’m right or wrong because, truth is, I don’t have a choice. It’s probably too late for me to become an astronaut, and journalism is the only other option that checked all the boxes on my list of job requirements. Looking back, I’m almost glad my mom never bought me the telescope. I no longer want to see the pale blue dot we live on from a distance. I prefer to zoom in as close as possible on what’s going on around me––to ask questions, write stories and uncover new kinds of secrets.

Arts & Entertainment, Music

Where Do I Begin? Country music artists of colour and the industry

by Ella Buckingham on

More in Arts & Entertainment:

Tracy Chapman’s “Fast Car” recently hit the No. 2 spot on Billboard’s Hot 100, winning Song of the Year at the 2023 Country Music Awards. I know what you’re thinking; no, it’s not 1988 again. A cover of the hit, released by country music artist Luke Combs on his newest album “Gettin’ Old,” has been garnering these accolades. Additionally, it has won Combs “Single of the Year” (CMA Awards), hit No. 1 on the Billboard Country Airplay Chart, and was recently certified platinum. While Combs’ success is impressive and spotlights Tracy Chapman thirty-five years after the song’s release, critics are torn over what this means given the discriminatory nature of country music. Some are uneasy about Combs’ achievements as a white man gaining so much attention for covering a queer Black woman’s work. 

Tracy Chapman has been quoted saying she never expected to find herself on the country music charts, and Black country music artists have been striving to get there for decades. Radio stations playing the music of predominantly white male country singers have exacerbated this struggle. A study from the University of Ottawa found that within the country music genre, the ratio of spins for male to female artists was 9.7:1. Another study conducted by SongData showed that between 2014 and 2020, artists of colour only received 4.8 per cent of country music format’s airplay. Both of these findings emphasize the strong bias toward white and male artists within the genre. 

Despite the country music community’s whiteness, Black artists are integral to the fabric of the genre. Historically, both the African-American and white communities in the Southern United States played “country music”. Its origins were largely influenced by African-American and Native American communities; enslaved peoples began the first string bands, and the blues—one of country music’s hallmarks—was an invention of African-American communities. Some credit the banjo as originating from West Africa, and a Kanaka Maoli teenager, Joseph Kekuku, created the steel guitar. Even the lyrics of country music have their origins in enslaved people’s spirituals, hymns, and field songs—all predominantly Black sources. Important early Black country artists include Lesley Riddle, who shaped the genre of modern country music primarily through his collaborations with the Carter Family, and Arnold Shultz, who was integral to Travis Picking’s development.

Country music began to be marketed along racial lines in the Jim Crow era, as the industry divided it into two categories: “Hillbilly” and “race.” While both of these terms are problematic, the “different” categories have the same roots. White country music, labeled as “hillbilly,” was specifically targeted toward the expanding white middle class in order to bring respect as well as profits to the genre. Eventually, this turned that demographic into the stereotypical audience of country music known today. 

The marginalization of Black voices and influence has continued to the present. Mickey Gurton, who has fought to be recognized in the genre for over ten years, became the first Black female country music star to perform at the Grammys in 2021, singing her hit single, “Black Like Me.” Up until that point, radios excluding women artists and artists of colour afforded her little air time in order to present her music to the public. Since her Grammy performance, however, her songs have amassed millions of streams on both YouTube and Spotify. 

While “Fast Car” was not originally a country music song, its popularity in the genre as a cover by a white male artist is cause for scepticism, especially considering the genre’s history of marginalization. As consumers, advocating for marginalized voices to be given airspace and monetarily supporting these artists are small but effective ways to work toward larger social change. We must interrogate how we represent country music and whose voices we centre at both the individual and industry levels.

Art, Arts & Entertainment, Books

‘A Haunted Girl’ is a soul-stirring take on mental health and a hero’s journey

by Charlotte Hayes on

More in Art:

Mentions of suicidal ideation and mental illness

Four years ago, in a hospital cafeteria, Ethan Sacks (BA ‘94) sat waiting for visiting hours to start in the pediatric psychiatric ward. As his mind turned over, he wrote down, “The fate of all life on Earth depends on a girl who doesn’t know if she wants to live,” which would later become the tagline for A Haunted Girl. The new independent comic series, co-authored by Ethan and his daughter Naomi Sacks (U1 Arts), chronicles the journey of 16-year-old Cleo as she navigates the challenges of returning to school after being hospitalized with severe depression, anxiety, and suicidal thoughts. On top of the troubles of fitting back into her old life, she starts to see visions of ghosts, leading her to question what’s real and what’s a figment of her imagination. With the first issue published on Oct. 11, this four-part paranormal thriller expertly balances a page-turning supernatural adventure with the real experiences of teenagers facing major mental health crises. The Tribune spoke to Ethan and Naomi about the comic’s conception and creation, as well as their hopes for the role it can play in the lives of young people facing similar challenges.

A Haunted Girl has an intensely personal origin. In a letter included at the outset of the first issue, Ethan describes this scene in the hospital cafeteria, years ago, waiting for his daughter (and now co-author) Naomi, who was seeking treatment for depression, anxiety, and suicidal ideations. Although the initial idea came from Ethan, Naomi’s involvement with the project grew through her recovery, culminating in her official co-authorship of the comic. She told The Tribune that there wasn’t necessarily a moment in which she became involved; rather, it was a gradual process. 

Ethan wanted Naomi to see herself within the story—the characterization of Cleo needed to feel reflective of her own experiences. When describing the process of collaborative writing, the duo explained that Ethan tackled the supernatural and action-based scenes and Naomi handled everything to do with therapy, recovery, and navigating high school. 

“It’s almost like internal demons and external demons,” Naomi jokes, pointing at herself and then her dad.

When asked what books they read or movies they watched in preparation for writing the comic, Ethan said that horror movies became critical texts for uniting his portion of the work with Naomi’s. He specifically highlighted The Exorcist, both for its obvious themes of connecting the supernatural to a medical context and for its creative usage of the parent role.

“For me [The Exorcist] was a touchstone […] Sure, there’s a demon and there’s all that imagery, but it’s also [about] a parent who can’t help their child,” Ethan said. 

Ethan worked closely with the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention (AFSP) to ensure that the comic wasn’t perpetuating any harmful tropes or stereotypes. He wanted to avoid potentially stigmatizing mental health issues and presenting language that could be triggering to a vulnerable audience. To help with this, A Haunted Girl received a sensitivity reading from the organization. Additionally, AFSP resources are listed in the back of each issue, providing techniques for coping with stressful situations and those in immediate distress. Ethan and Naomi hope that the comic can incite readers, particularly teenagers, to seek the help that they may need.

A Haunted Girl is a thoughtfully written and beautifully illustrated comic that demystifies an issue that is so rarely authentically portrayed—especially in the comic medium. It is unafraid to use the language of therapy and destigmatizes asking for and getting help. At the same time, the language isn’t clinical. This messaging, immediately juxtaposed with the creepy supernatural elements, creates a heartwarming yet enthralling read. The mission statement is clear: To inspire those whose struggles mirror Cleo’s as they go on their own hero’s journey. 

‘A Haunted Girl’ is available in bookstores across the country. Issue #3 will be released on Dec. 13

Martlets, Men's Varsity, Sports, Varsity Round UP

Varsity Report Card: Fall 2023

by Anoushka Oke, Julie Ferreyra, Tillie Burlock on

More in Martlets:

Redbirds Baseball (6–5): B+

Coming off a Quebec baseball championship victory last season, Redbirds baseball was afforded an exciting opportunity to play in the newly formed RSEQ baseball league. Four out of the team’s five conference losses came at the hands of the UQTR Patriotes; the Redbirds were unable to solve UQTR all season long. After sweeping the best-of-three RSEQ semifinal against the Concordia Stingers, the ‘Birds lost the first game of the best-of-three final series against UQTR. The Redbirds dominated the second game 14-4 to tie the series, but McGill ultimately succumbed to the Patriotes, unable to defend the title against their newfound rival. Despite the dropoff from last season, the Redbirds will likely improve as they continue to recover from the two seasons lost to COVID-19. 

Cross Country: Redbirds B+/Martlets B-

Despite missing star runner Matthew Beaudet, Redbirds cross country had yet another strong season while the Martlets saw great improvement from the 2022-23 season due to their significantly smaller roster. Opening the season with the McGill Invitational, Sophie Courville finished third with a time of 22:39, spearheading the Martlets’ fourth-place finish overall. The Redbirds, on the other hand, secured first place in  the men’s division of the meet, with the trio of Thomas Windisch, Noah El Rimawi-Fine, and Jerome Jacques finishing first, second, and third, respectively. The Redbirds consistently placed in the top three at meets throughout the season, coming in first place once again at the Sherbrooke Invitational. At Sherbrooke, the Martlets captured second place, rookie Sienna Matheson leading the way with a sixth-place finish. The RSEQ Championships saw the Redbirds take home bronze while the Martlets finished right in the middle of the pack in fifth place. 

Martlets Field Hockey (0–10): D

With no win on the tally, the Martlets field hockey squad remained at the bottom of the Ontario University Athletic (OUA) standings. The 2023-24 season was once again devoid of home games. McGill has not hosted any field hockey games since the 2019-20 season, when the team made it to the post-season. With a significant proportion of the current roster graduating at the end of the 2023-24 academic year, the team must remain hopeful for the coming season. However, the disappointing showing on the field did not prevent members of the squad from standing out off the field. VP Inclusion for the Varsity Council, Ada Collins, received the OUA’s inaugural Champion of Equity, Diversity and Inclusion Award, the first award granted to a McGill field hockey player since 2017. 

Sports Editor and Martlets field hockey goalkeeper Anoushka Oke did not contribute to this section of the article.

Redbirds Football (1–7):  D

The Redbirds football team took home a singular win for the third straight season. After defeating Sherbrooke Vert et Or 26-14 in their home opener, the Redbirds lost each of their subsequent games by double digits––an unfortunate outcome for McGill’s highly-touted team. Individually, however, the Redbirds had a number of impressive performances. Offensive lineman Alexandre Marcoux signed a deal with the Calgary Stampeders at the conclusion of the Redbirds’ season. Slotback Darius Simmons earned U SPORTS All-Canadian honours for the third consecutive season, leading the RSEQ in reception yards (611), receptions (54) and yards per game (76.4). Simmons, running back Brandon Ciccarello, and offensive lineman Michael Vlahogiannis were also awarded RSEQ all-star honours. Despite the individual successes, the lack of improvement from last years’ equally disappointing season leaves the Redbirds with yet another D. 

Redbirds Lacrosse (10–4): A+

Despite only seven regular-season wins, Redbirds lacrosse stunned fans across Ontario and Quebec, swiftly qualifying for the Canadian University Field Lacrosse Association (CUFLA) playoffs after beating Queen’s University in a 9-5 sudden-death win. For the first time since 2015, the Redbirds squad made it to the final of the Baggataway Cup after putting an end to a decades-old losing streak against Guelph University in the quarter-finals. The Redbirds defeated the Carleton Ravens in the semi-final but fell to the Western University Mustangs in the finals. With thirteen hat-tricks coming from four players this season, and several players honoured as CUFLA all-stars, the 2023 season was a definite success for the Redbirds’ lacrosse squad. 

Rowing: Redbirds B+ / Martlets B

Several Redbirds and Martlets rowers got on the podium throughout the season. Their first regatta, Head of the Rideau, saw McGill take home first place in the women’s lightweight four, second place in the men’s four and in both the men’s and the women’s single, and third place in the men’s lightweight double. The men’s lightweight double then went on to win second place in the following Head of the Trent regatta. Following successful bids from their two regular season regattas, twenty McGill athletes qualified for the Canadian University Rowing Association (CURA) championship showcase meet. McGill rowers got their first medal at the CURA meet since 2014, with the duo of Jacob Lofaro and Federico Sanchez earning silver in the men’s double sculls. 

Martlets Rugby (1–5): C-

After back-to-back winless seasons, the Martlets (1–5) rugby team claimed a lone victory in their season opener, defeating the Bishop’s Gaiters 22-13. Unfortunately, the remaining five games of the season looked much like those of 2022-23 and 2021-22, with the Martlets taking four straight shutout losses and only getting back on the scoreboard in their final game. While disappointing, the Martlets made strides this season with Lauren Minns leading the way. Not only did Minns take home RSEQ athlete of the week on Sept. 6 and achieve RSEQ all-star status at the end of the season, the Martlets’ back-row was awarded All-Canadian second-team honours at the U SPORTS women’s rugby awards. Despite the low C- grade, The Tribune is hopeful for greater success for the Martlets in 2024. 

Redbirds Rugby (4–3): B+ 

After a spectacular 2022-23 season, it was always going to be difficult for the Redbirds rugby team to outdo themselves. Nonetheless, the team still made fans roar in the stands all season long. They ended on three narrow wins, claiming third place in the RSEQ standings. The team faced UOttawa’s Gee-Gees in the semi-finals, one of the only two teams against whom the Redbirds lost in the regular season. After pocketing their first-ever playoff win against McGill, the Gee-Gees ultimately prevailed in the finals for the first time since 2008.

Individuals who had an outstanding season included outside-centre Martin Laval, who established the new single-game record by converting all nine tries of the game opener. Max Bernhart, Dominic Russell, Nicolas Laine, Roberto Frascione, and Elliot Descarreaux were all selected by Rugby Quebec to participate in the New York Rugby Sevens tournament. 

Redbirds Soccer (4–5–5): B- 

The Redbirds failed to make it to the playoffs once again, finishing sixth in the seven-team RSEQ league. Opening their regular season with a 1-0 loss to the UQTR Patriotes, the Redbirds oscillated between losses and ties with a few wins sprinkled in between. However, they saw some improvement from last year, doubling their win tally from the 2022-23 season’s two and losing three fewer games. At the close of the season, defender Matisse Chrétien and midfielder Nassim Kemel earned RSEQ first-team and second-team all-star honours, respectively, while Chrétien, forward Mathis Cyr, and midfielder Nathan Yee earned all-rookie honours. Chrétien was also later named to the U SPORTS all-rookie team. Despite another tough season, the Redbirds have a young team and a strong rookie base that they can hopefully build upon next season to make a bid for the playoffs.

Martlets Soccer (6–3–5): B+

With a third-place finish, the Martlets advanced to the RSEQ semi-finals against the second-place Université de Montréal Carabins, ultimately falling 2-1. Individually, midfielder Mara Bouchard and defender Stephanie Hill were awarded U SPORTS All-Canadian honours. Bouchard, Hill, and midfielder Chloé Renaud were named RSEQ conference all-stars, while goalkeeper Sophie Guilmette was named to the second squad and midfielder Amélie Beaudet-Gaudette was voted onto the all-rookie all-star team. Jose-Luis Valdes took home the RSEQ coach-of-the-year-award in his eleventh season as head coach of the team. Marginally improving from last year with three fewer losses, The Tribune remains hopeful that the Martlets will be able to boost their offense next season and secure wins in tight matches. 

Science & Technology

Navigating the government’s guide to employing generative AI in the public sector

by Yejin Lee on

More in Science & Technology:

On Nov. 30th, OpenAI’s release of ChatGPT marked its one-year anniversary. Within a relatively short period, this generative AI (GAI) brought tremendous changes in everyone’s lives. Between huge layoffs in administrative professions, and widespread controversies, such as the debate around the use of AI in classrooms, it seems crucial to survey the implications of such a tool. 

In September 2023, the Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat (TBS) published a Guide on the Use of Generative AI, providing an overview of GAI, along with challenges and concerns for responsible use as well as policy considerations. Researchers from McGill and the University of Toronto were invited to submit their feedback on the guide. They discussed their comments in a recent paper encompassing sociopolitical aspects of GAI while analyzing the guide’s strengths and weaknesses. 

Despite assessing the guide as “fit for purpose,” the paper identifies three key pathways to strengthen it: Direction on drafting new federal legislation for more comprehensive and enforceable rules, ethical sourcing practices, and environmental impact mitigation. 

The researchers emphasize the need for a more enforceable policy framework that offers greater accountability and public trust in GAI in the public sector. Regulation of the foundational model is particularly crucial as various applications of GAI use it as a base. Pre-existing biases are almost impossible to detect, and the harvested data used for its training ranges across public and private data, raising concerns about copyright violations. 

Moreover, GAI requires extensive data input. The workers have to clean, annotate, and prepare the possibly harmful data to remove biases and graphic material for the production of ‘quality’ data. Worker protection, under the proposed ethical sourcing practices, is highly compromised. For instance, Meta, OpenAI, TikTok, and Big Tech ignored Kenyan labour laws for their data workers in Kenya. Even though those companies are valorized for kick-starting the GAI revolution, they are infamous for hiding the extent of the harm; severe mental distress and even suicides of content moderation workers are well-documented. 

“As long as the status-quo business model remains profit maximizing and shareholder-driven, the exploitation will continue,” Ana Brandusescu, PhD candidate, and Renee Sieber, associate professor, both researchers at McGill’s Department of Geography, wrote in an email to //The Tribune//. 

According to Brandusescu and Sieber, extending Canadian labour laws to international data workers may resolve such exploitative practices.

“We have to go beyond soft law such as guidelines and standards to more concrete and consequential measures that are respected and enforced,” Brandusescu and Sieber wrote. “[Possible measures could be] prohibiting federal agencies from using certain products and services, remove offending companies (e.g., those who violate human rights laws) from preferred vendors’ lists, and to name and shame companies who do not comply with rules and regulations.”

The paper compliments the guide on its attention to GAI’s environmental impact, but suggests that it should include a more comprehensive examination of the environmental impact caused in each phase of GAI’s software and hardware lifecycle. Despite the immense amount of greenhouse gas emissions and water consumption for AI data centres, AI’s environmental footprint often goes unacknowledged. 

A more thorough guide may also encourage companies to incorporate feasible solutions, such as energy-efficient architecture or carbon-awareness tools. Deep Green, a UK-based company that pairs a data center with a swimming pool to transfer the heat generated to warm up the pool, is a creative alternative to letting the heat energy go to waste. 

GAI is an issue creating radical changes in numerous social areas while posing substantive harm. This issue requires a tangible enforcement of regulatory policies since a naive, hypothetical discussion about it would not propel much change. 

“Is it worth it for one of us to have AI-enabled convenience if it means that three people will lose their jobs, [Internet Protocol (IP) addresses] will be stolen, and workers in low and middle-income countries will be exploited?” Brandusescu and Sieber wrote.

Now is the time to ponder what benefits GAI brings us, whether it is actually being economically and socially distributed, and pay consistent attention to relevant policies so that the suggestions as above can come into effect.

Commentary, Opinion

To Bixi or not to Bixi?

by Monique Kasonga, Liliana Mason on

More in Commentary:

Bixi is my religion – Monique

If taking out your first Bixi is an unforgettable experience in itself, riding one also comes with endless benefits. For starters, the convenience is unparalleled. With hundreds of stops all over the city, you can always find a bike and a place to drop it off. While having your own bike can admittedly have its advantages—like the freedom to customize it to your preferences—the consequence of having to find somewhere to lock it is cumbersome enough. 

Here’s a simple, everyday scenario: You need to get to a restaurant to meet friends in 10 minutes. Walking will take you 25, and biking will take you eight. But wait, you won’t be going back to your place afterward; you’ll be heading to a bar, which you need to take the metro to get to. Thinking of walking? Don’t even bother—the table has ordered their dinner already, and they are all wondering when you’re going to finally download the app. By temporarily renting a bike, you’ll be freed of the responsibility of carrying one around all night and you’ll be on time for your dinner. 

Significantly cheaper than a student metro pass, Bixi allows you to explore the city in unparalleled ways. Tucked away next to the Bixi stop you parked at is your new favourite Mile-End coffee shop (and let’s face it, you’d never make it to the Mile-End from Milton-Parc by foot.) 

Bixi’s infrastructure is a powerful force in the city’s transportation dynamics, alleviating traffic congestion and enhancing urban mobility by reducing reliance on private cars. Bixi’s city-wide station system ensures accessibility for a diverse range of residents, bridging transportation gaps and fostering a more equitable urban environment. Bike-sharing services like Bixi not only revolutionize transportation but also contribute to Montreal’s identity as a sustainable, healthy, and accessible city. If you ask me, there’s no better way to get around than by Bixi-ing—and I will die on this hill––the same hill I biked up with ease, using an electric Bixi. 

Down with Bixis – Liliana
The Bixi bike is a staple of the Montreal landscape, much like the ever-present construction cones and pothole-filled one-way roads that permeate the downtown. Many Montrealers have come to associate Bixis as an integral part of their identity, making the ugly, clunky bikes a centrepiece of their personality…little do they know how much better life could be. Bixi bikes are antiquated, heavy, and an overall stain on Montreal’s otherwise thriving bike scene.

Montreal has long been a city known for its strong biking culture, with over 900 km of bike paths, much of which is regularly cleared of snow to facilitate biking all throughout the cold, dark winters. This culture has flourished since 1975 when activists Robert Silverman and Claire Morissette founded Le Monde à Bicyclette to fight for bicycle-friendly infrastructure; however, the modern Bixi system not only does this culture a disservice, but flat-out embarrasses it. 

Since it first entered Montreal in 2009, Bixi has faced complaints from small independent bike shops and rental agencies who have been forced to shut down as a result of their competition. In 2011 alone, three independent bike stores reported severe impacts on their business as a result of Bixis. After bike rentals fell from 250 to just 10 per year, Roberto Rosenbluth shut down a location of his store Bicycletteries JR. 

Bixi also receives a consistent stream of bad reviews from customers complaining of hidden fees, shameful customer service, and malfunctioning equipment. Complaints range from bikes being un-maintained and barely usable to overcharging as a result of loopholes that are unclear to outsiders. 

Personally, I have a vendetta against Bixis. I think they’re heavy and bulky, and the first time I rode one, the experience was marred by heavy winds that almost pushed me into Sherbrooke traffic, prompting an angry old lady to yell at me for riding on the street. Personal bias aside, the Bixi system is deeply flawed and is an affront to the beauty that is Montreal’s biking culture.

Arts & Entertainment, Film and TV

“Saltburn” is a cinematic scrutinization of opulence and obsession

by Sofia Stankovic on

More in Arts & Entertainment:

Spoilers for Saltburn

Opulence. Drugs. Midnight strolls. A hedge maze. Far too many shots of bathtubs. Welcome to Saltburn, Emerald Fennell’s latest cinematic endeavour. Known for her bold feature-length directorial debut, Promising Young Woman, Fennell’s newest film takes a more ironic journey, enlisting a stellar cast to portray an “eat the rich” satire filled with twists and turns at every corner.

The film takes place in 2006 at Oxford University where scholarship student Oliver Quick (Barry Keoghan) struggles to assimilate with his privileged peers, whose legacies, family names, and substantial donations guarantee their admission. Oliver befriends popular and charismatic Felix Catton (Jacob Elordi), who appears sympathetic to his plight. Their friendship takes on an imbalanced, obsessive quality, blurring the boundaries between love and companionship. Stirred by compassion for Oliver’s familial struggles, Felix extends an invitation for him to spend the summer at his family’s lavish estate—Saltburn. Saltburn’s opulence initially overwhelms Oliver, yet even as he slowly embraces it, unease permeates the locale. The audience must immediately confront the discomfort of witnessing Oliver’s excessive indulgence and the intricate ways by which he inserts himself into the fabric of the Catton family. Saltburn, with its grandeur and intricate nuances, transforms into a microcosm of the subtle interplay between class, friendship, and personal identity.

The brilliantly performed satire skillfully dissects the themes of wealth and extravagance. Through Oliver’s eyes, Fennell peels back the mystique behind each character, gradually revealing the true nature of the individuals populating this world of riches. The cast truly elevates the film to its full potential, allowing for hilariously dark moments to enhance the film’s humour. Felix’s mom, Elsbeth Catton (Rosamund Pike), is electrifying in her cheerful cruelty; Pike’s line deliveries and incisive descriptions are a genuine delight, showcasing the amused detachment often associated with affluence. Moreover, Elordi flawlessly embodies the character of Felix, expertly toeing the line between the seemingly unattainably affluent youth and the grounded, relatable best friend. The on-screen chemistry between Elordi and Keoghan is undeniably compelling, adding a gripping dimension to their characters’ dynamic. 

Fennell adeptly navigates the delicate task of presenting visually uncomfortable scenes while blending cinematography, colour palettes, and sound design to enhance the overall narrative impact. Several scenes leave the viewer grappling with conflicting emotions through an interplay of repulsion and self-reflection. Moreover, the cinematography and framing are expertly done. The film was shot in an unusual 1.33:1 aspect ratio, giving the viewer the impression that one is seeing more than they are meant to. This fosters a sense of intrigue, prompting the audience to engage more deeply with the visual nuances of the story—as if one is living in Saltburn with Oliver. Complementing this visual prowess, the soundtrack impeccably aligns with the narrative, serving as an auditory guide to the characters’ emotions and enhancing the overall cinematic experience.

The film carefully weaves its narrative tapestry to build anticipation and tension, but unfortunately, the conclusion falls short in terms of narrative coherence and a well-structured plot. Despite the film’s earlier success in building suspense, the concluding scenes diminish the overall impact of the storytelling. The resolution dissipates the heightened intrigue surrounding the main characters, culminating in an ultimately predictable ending. Nevertheless, Barry Keoghan’s performance remains effortlessly captivating until the closing credits. His methodical character exploration prompts the viewer to reflect on the broader implications of extravagance and privilege in contemporary society. In this way, the film succeeds in sparking contemplation that transcends its narrative shortcomings. Ultimately, Saltburn leaves a lasting impression by masterfully blending together visual and auditory elements, providing an immersive experience that transcends the boundaries of conventional storytelling.

‘Saltburn’ is now playing in theatres.

News, SSMU

Hundreds of ralliers flood SSMU BoD meeting, call for Society to uphold student democracy

by Shani Laskin on

More in News:

Roughly one hundred students disrupted the Students’ Society of McGill University’s (SSMU) Board of Directors (BoD) meeting on Nov. 30 to voice their support for the Policy Against Genocide in Palestine. Students questioned executives face-to-face on the Society’s decision to consent to an injunction against the policy—a decision that has paused the policy’s ratification until at least March 25, when the case will be heard in court.

The Policy Against Genocide in Palestine passed with 5,974 students—78.7 per cent of non-abstaining voters—casting a “Yes” vote in SSMU’s Fall Referendum. The injunction was filed on Nov. 21 by an anonymous McGill student with support from B’nai Brith Canada, a Jewish service and advocacy organization. On Nov. 23, the Quebec Superior Court issued a safeguard order, leading SSMU to pause the Policy’s ratification.

McGill’s administration has also resisted the Policy, telling SSMU that it would “sharpen divisions” and is thus a violation of SSMU’s constitution—making it a violation of the Memorandum of Agreement between SSMU and the university.

Solidarity for Palestinian Human Rights (SPHR) McGill held a Student Rally Against Genocide on Nov. 30 to reaffirm their support for the Policy. The rally began at 5 p.m. outside of the Arts Building and included speeches emphasizing the students’ commitment to Palestinian liberation and the Policy. An SPHR McGill representative who wished to remain anonymous asserted that they believe that the injunction stands in the way of the democratic process.

“Legal warfare is an attempt to diverge us from our path by using law and biased regulations and bureaucratic procedures designed to repress and undermine any Palestinian student activism,” the representative said. “McGill, SSMU, and Canada have clearly spoken: Democracy is conditional and not applicable when we are speaking for Palestine. This establishes a dangerous model for student democracy and activism in Montreal, a precedent that SPHR McGill rejects and vows to pursue.”

Before 6 p.m., the protesters moved from the Arts Building to the lobby of the University Centre, where the SSMU BoD meeting was taking place metres away in the SSMU offices. The meeting began with the BoD answering a pre-submitted question about what steps they would take to “make sure that […] student democratic action is upheld and respected.” The question also asked how SSMU would ensure communication of their stances regarding the Policy. In response, SSMU Vice President (VP) Student Life Nadia Dakdouki explained that SSMU communications are ultimately intended to  avoid causing confusion.

“We only really communicate final decisions [….] If there’s something being discussed that is not finalized for […] legal considerations, it is not useful in the sense that it will only cause more confusion,” Dakdouki said. “So I know there’s been concerns in the past week, but it’s really just because everything has been moving so fast, and we’re doing our best to be as transparent as we can within the bounds of legality and confidentiality.”

According to SPHR McGill, SSMU had notified the group the morning of the meeting that no student observers would be allowed to attend the public session of the meeting to ask questions—which SPHR McGill cited as a “break of [SSMU’s] normal procedure.” In lieu of attending the meeting in person, SPHR McGill says that they were allowed to ask one question over Zoom. When the group asked a second question, SPHR McGill claims that SSMU “forcibly muted” them, after which organizers led protesters into the BoD’s meeting room.

SSMU executives asserted that they did not intend to silence students’ voices in an email to The Tribune.

“The Speaker chose to move members attending the public session online in order to accommodate the large number of people wishing to attend and ask questions,” the SSMU executives wrote. “At the discretion of the Speaker (and in accordance with our standing rules), because of the large quantity of questions, the procedure for question period was that each person should ask one question, then get back in line should they have another question to allow others to ask their own questions.”

“The member started asking their second question, and the Speaker intervened to clarify that the member would have to raise their hand (on Zoom) and wait their turn in the queue to ask their next question. The member was muted so that the Speaker could clarify the rules of question period and to take the next member’s question. There was no intention to stifle the voices or questions of members.” 

The BoD meeting adjourned as protesters chanting “Free, free Palestine” crowded the meeting around 6:30 p.m. In the BoD meeting room, the protesters confronted the SSMU executives and board members about the injunction. According to a representative from SPHR McGill, none of the SSMU executives were present at the injunction hearing, a claim which no SSMU executive denied. SSMU President Alexandre Ashkir told ralliers that SSMU was not happy with its previous legal counsel, and has since hired new legal representation.

He also voiced his opinion that students should be upset at the legal process, not SSMU.“I respect the effort, I respect the rally […] but the reality is we’re stuck in legal fuckery and instead of protesting the courts and protesting the people suing us, you’re protesting us,” Ashkir said.

A student asked, “If the struggle was to find lawyers who would stand up for us, why not be in the room and hold them accountable?” The executives began to answer but were interrupted by the students’ many questions that followed. 

Next, a member of Law Students for Palestine at McGill (LS4PM) condemned SSMU’s agreement to the injunction, saying that by doing so, SSMU’s lawyers knowingly paused the ratification for months. They also asked why SSMU did not accept help from LS4PM, despite their offers. Ashkir replied saying that SSMU had indeed used LS4PM’s assistance to find new legal counsel and thanked the organization. 

LS4PM did not reply to The Tribune’s requests for clarification and comment by the publication deadline. 

In an email to The Tribune, SSMU stated that it had already begun interviewing law firms by the time LS4PM reached out. SSMU said that it nonetheless took advice from LS4PM on what firm they would recommend. By the time they heard back, SSMU had already chosen Sibel Ataogul from Melançon Marceau Grenier Cohen, which was also LS4PM’s recommendation. “While our decision was made independently of LS4PM, their offer of legal help was appreciated and considered,” the SSMU executives wrote.

In response to further questions, Ashkir explained that while SSMU had not yet met with their lawyers to discuss strategy, they intend to defend the Policy in court. After Ashkir reiterated SSMU’s support for the Policy, the protesters moved back to the lobby of the University Centre, with Ashkir joining the rally.

Back in the lobby, Ashkir requested to make a speech to the crowd. He started speaking but attendees quickly interrupted him by shouting questions about the injunction. One student asked again why Ashkir was not present for the injunction hearing. Ashkir responded that he “didn’t have the time,” prompting cries of “Shame” from the crowd.

Isaiah, a representative of Independent Jewish Voices (IJV) McGill who asked for only his first name to be used, shouted, “In less than two months, more than 15,500 people are dead. How do we have until March?” to which Ashkir responded, “We don’t. All we can do right now is […] work around a legal case that is […] pinning us down.”

Another student began chanting “The students, united, will never be defeated,” which eventually gained traction among the crowd. 

The rally ended with more speeches, including one from IJV McGill.

“I hope [SSMU] recognizes that the overwhelming support and the voice of the students isn’t just a vote or a number, it’s a real thing,” Isaiah said in an interview with The Tribune. “We brought hundreds of students here today to mobilize and make our voices heard in real life. They have a responsibility to step up to defend the […] mandate from the students right now. And we’re going to keep pushing them until we see that happen.”

Behind the Bench, Sports

AI writers cannot be the future of sports journalism

by Tillie Burlock on

More in Behind the Bench:

The future of sports journalism is incredibly bleak at the moment. The New York Times disbanded their sports section in July 2023, electing to rely solely on The Athletic after having bought the sports outlet for $550 million in 2022. In what was suspected to be preparation for the shift, The Athletic let go four per cent of its staff in June 2023. Amidst budget cuts, ESPN also laid off household names such as Jeff Van Gundy, Jalen Rose, and Suzy Kolber, along with 20 other on-air employees. The Ice Garden, a leader in women’s hockey coverage, had its funding pulled by Vox and SB Nation in Jan. 2023. Sports journalism needs to be revived; however, Sports Illustrated’s turn to artificial intelligence (AI) is not the solution. 

On Nov. 27, Futurism reported that it discovered Sports Illustrated (SI) published several articles written by fake, AI-generated writers. These authors’ bylines contained a series of product reviews, but no other online presence, and were accompanied by for sale stock-photo headshots. When confronted with the allegations, SI deleted the content in question; soon after, a spokesperson for The Arena Group, which operates SI, stated that a third-party marketing agency produced the material as part of a license agreement that was under review. The Arena Group further stated that AdVon Commerce, the third party in question, denied that AI generated the content and claimed the fake bylines had been used “to protect author privacy.” 

Sports Illustrated is no longer what it used to be. Gone are the days of iconic covers such as LeBron James’ ‘The Chosen One,’ March 1980’s ‘Miracle on Ice,’ and Dwight Clark’s ‘The Super Catch.’ The decline of the printing press has harmed sports just as it has the rest of journalism, so the desire to breathe life back into a dying industry has merit; however, AI writers in place of real people is not the way. 

Many sports outlets have tried to revamp content with technology. ESPN aired an interview with Damian Lillard following his first game with the Milwaukee Bucks; fans quickly pointed out that he was not wearing the same uniform he had in the game and there was no audience in the stands. It turns out the video had been doctored and repurposed from a 2020 interview in the NBA Bubble. On Nov. 28, the share price of the Arena Group fell almost 27 per cent on the New York Stock Exchange. When considered in light of the public response to other outlets’ AI-led missteps, maybe this is a sign that the world has no use for AI-generated journalism. 

Instead of turning to AI to fill the void left by the shifting environment of sports journalism, outlets must turn to people for real solutions. Perhaps returning to investigative journalism such as that of Rick Westhead, Grant Robertson, and Katie Strang, who diligently researched and uncovered the details of the 2018 Hockey Canada scandal. Or maybe investing in multimedia story-telling like The New York Times who used emotional, yet, heartwarming videos to vividly narrate the stories of teens with chronic traumatic encephalopathy who tragically passed away in their teens and twenties. Or maybe it is turning to journalists like Dave Zirin who ardently and unequivocally criticize the sports they love most. 

The industry is struggling—there is no doubt about that. However, we must resist the urge to turn to AI as the solution. In a world where misinformation runs rampant, media outlets must lean into the potential that real journalists provide. The ability to tell stories, connect with athletes, and speak truth to power––skills embodied by the industry’s best––must be embraced. We are witnessing a moment of crisis within Canadian sport. Day after day, journalists reveal new scandals of abuse and work tirelessly to protect athletes from similar fates. The revitalization of sports journalism must come from innovative storytelling, where passion seeps through the page and athletes’ voices are placed at the forefront––not AI writers who write of “close encounters of the athletic kind.”

1 … 163 164 165 166 167 … 1,363

Read the latest issue

Read the latest issue