Latest News

McGill, News

Protest held for Indigenous peoples traumatized by the child-welfare system

by Abeer Almahdi on

More in McGill:

The Canadian federal government has appealed a ruling by the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal, that ordered them to pay reparations to First Nations children and their families who were separated by the child-welfare system. In response, on Oct. 19, Students’ Society of McGill University (SSMU) Indigenous Affairs Commissioner Tomas Jirousek and the Indigenous Student Alliance (ISA) organized a protest in solidarity with the victims, calling on the government to improve on reconciliation. 

Jirousek, a member of the Kainai First Nation of the Blackfoot confederacy, began the protest with a land acknowledgment and spoke on the intense trauma that Indigenous survivors of the child-welfare system experience.

“These aren’t just numbers on a factsheet,” Jirousek said. “These are kids who aren’t getting their childhoods back. These are kids who are spending nights, years away from their parents [and] cultures, just because the federal government doesn’t think [that] they are worth the money.”

Jo Roy, a member of the Abenaki First Nation, student representative for the Social Work Students’ Association (SWSA) and a current member of the Indigenous Affairs Committee, began by telling the story of Dene siblings who were reunited after separation and foster care. Betty-Ann Adam Dene was separated from her siblings during the ‘Sixties Scoop’, only to reunite decades later. Birth of a Family was a documentary that was filmed about their reunion.

“Please don’t think that the pain of Indigenous peoples is far removed from your lives here in this city, because it is not,” Roy said. “It is experienced by [Indigenous people] around you. [This] is why we’re standing here together, because the pain must end [….] It is not right to challenge the collective right for First Nations children to have a future free of pain.” 

The Sixties Scoop refers to a period of provincial child welfare policies starting in the 1950s, where thousands of Indigenous children were forcibly removed from their families under false pretenses and placed in foster homes or adopted into white families across Canada and the United States. Children within this system often fell into vulnerable positions, leading to systemic abuse and harassment. As part of federal assimilation policies, children were forced to discount their languages and cultures. Residential schools, which were government-and church-run institutions, were created to forcefully assimilate Indigenous children. 

Noah Favel, member of the Poundmaker Cree Nation and former co-chair of the ISA, spoke about the continued systemic discrimination by the Canadian government. Favel situated the protest in the larger conversation of structural barriers faced by Indigenous people. 

“[The federal government’s] decision [to cease funding] perpetuates a system of poverty for people who are already so impoverished,” Favel said. “[…] Issues with housing, food security, and healthcare. [To] place this trauma on Indigenous children, who are already grappling with so many other issues […], people who are struggling to maintain our language, our heritage, [and] our customs. To put [this decision] on us when we have bigger things to focus on, it really hurts.”

The ruling specifies $40,000 for each child taken away from their family since Jan. 1, 2006 and for each of their parents or grandparents, amounting to an estimated $8 billion in compensation. Over 50 per cent of children in foster care are Indigenous, despite only representing seven per cent of children under 15. According to Indigenous Services Minister Seamus O’Regan, the federal government cannot come up with a plan to identify survivors and provide compensation by the Dec. 10 deadline. Nakuset, member of the Cree Nation and the Executive Director of the Native Women’s Shelter of Montreal, has worked at the shelter for 20 years. She began by talking about her own experiences with family separation, as she is the first person in her family to have children who were not taken by the system. 

“This is a really difficult subject because my mother went to a residential school,” Nakuset said. “Because of her experience at residential schools, I ended up being a part of the Sixties Scoop, and being taken far away from my community [in Saskatchewan] and brought here to Montreal, where I was forced to grow up in a culture that wasn’t mine and to be ashamed [of my origins]. I was able to find that strength and go find my roots, and get my Indian status back, and get my education.”

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) was a report funded by residential school survivors in 2008 to help them share their stories, and to investigate the full lasting impacts of this system. The document came with 94 calls to action for reconciliation. According to Nakuset, the reports and recommendations still did not elicit government action.  

“TRC came out a couple of years ago […] when Trudeau came into power he said he was going to implement all 94 of the [recommendations.] He’s done 10,” Nakuset said. “Then the inquiry into [Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls] finished, with 231 calls to justice announced […The] fact that all these recommendations have been put forward and no one is doing anything about it speaks volumes.”

Science & Technology

Leaping into the sixth mass extinction

by Alex Arkilanian on

More in Science & Technology:

Environmental scientists believe that most animal groups today are facing global population declines. The magnitude of the declines is so great that many are referring to this as the beginning of the sixth mass extinction.

Amphibians are one of the most affected groups: Their estimated extinction rate since 2007 is 211 times greater than the background rate of extinction, the base rate of extinctions that would occur without human influence. Furthermore, the International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources (IUCN) estimates that 40 per cent of assessed amphibian species are threatened by extinction. In Quebec, blue-spotted and eastern red-backed salamanders, amphibians native to the province, are facing a decline even greater than the global average.

Dr. David Green, a professor in the Department of Biology, explained that scientists have long been aware of the world’s declining amphibian populations.

“The [phenomenon] of declining amphibians [was] first noticed by scientists who study amphibians 30 years ago at the end of the World’s First Congress of Herpetology,” Green said in an interview with The McGill Tribune.  “It was written in Science and picked up [by] The New York Times, and that really started it off.”

While population declines are occurring across multiple animal groups, amphibians are particularly important to ecosystem health, particularly water ecosystems.

“[Amphibian larvae] help to balance the nutrients in [the aquatic] system, […] and then they transform, and they take all that material out of the ponds and […] go out on the land,” Green said. 

In addition to playing a crucial role within ponds, amphibian larvae are part of land-based ecosystems. They provide an essential link between aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems and are an important food source for other animals on land.

Though scientists have been aware of amphibian population declines for decades, the causes are less clear and are still being investigated today. 

“One of the major threats here and everywhere is largely habitat loss,” Green said. “That’s the elephant in the room.”

While the reasons behind these declines is not straightforward, disease may play a large role. 

“The cause people are concerned with right now is diseases, particularly the chytrid fungal disease,” Green said. “Chytrid fungal infections have become nearly ubiquitous in the amphibians of the world, but this couldn’t have been possible without something causing the immune systems of the organisms to weaken.”

The amphibian immune system is unique in that its primary component is the skin. Glands under the skin of amphibians secrete compounds that attract a diverse collection of microorganisms, which serve as a strong line of defence against pathogens. 

“So we have a succession of things,” Green said. “Chytrid […] is lethal as a disease. It’s also ubiquitous. You get diseased when you’re immunosuppressed. If part of your immune system is environmentally-based, […] then habitat destruction and habitat change can affect the immune system.”

Today, conservationists tackling these declines are focused on raising larvae safely before returning them to their environment, but Green is skeptical about small-scale solutions to global problems. 

“It’s not a frog problem,” Green said. “It’s a people problem.”

For Green, the solution is in the way we manage global society. People should be concentrating resources in urban centres, and trying to build up instead of out. 

While experts have previously been optimistic about the state of amphibian populations, Green warns that dismissing their decline as simply a warning sign is a dangerous mentality. Since amphibians occupy such a central position in their respective food webs, their loss could be more than simply a cautionary notice.

“[Amphibians] are not the canary in the coal mines,” Green said. “They are the miners.”

Science & Technology

Searching for the first stars

by Amir Hotter-Yishay on

More in Science & Technology:

Astrophysicist Jeff Peterson of Carnegie Mellon University delivered a lecture on Oct. 9 about the quest to study ‘cosmic dawn,’ the ‘turning on’ of the very first stars in the universe. Estimated to have occurred 150–300 million years after the Big Bang, physicists have sought to study signals from this crucial epoch for years—and now, they may have finally done so.

“This is a scientific adventure,” Peterson said. “But it’s also a physical adventure.” 

From the origins of the universe to the atomic levels of hydrogen, Peterson’s freewheeling talk, hosted by AstroMcGill, gave a cosmological crash course on the long and winding road to cosmic dawn. 

In 1964, armed with a supersensitive antenna, radio astronomers Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson set out to detect incredibly faint radio waves from space. The experiment hit a roadblock when they found that their data showed a mysterious disturbance spread evenly throughout the sky. Initially convinced that it was simply a problem with their antenna, they had, in fact, detected the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) radiation. Given off by the Big Bang itself, the CMB is the oldest electromagnetic radiation in the known universe. A cosmic signature that fills all space, the CMB offers physicists a snapshot of the early universe as it was when a drop in temperature caused the formation of the first neutral hydrogen atoms.    

Physicists believe that 370,000 years after the Big Bang, these hydrogen atoms arose from the rapidly cooling, ionized plasma soup that comprised all matter. With time and gravitation, the atoms began to form clumps, growing in size and eventually collapsing into themselves to form the first stars. The light given off by these stars fundamentally altered the properties of the remaining hydrogen, allowing it to absorb some of the CMB at a radio wavelength of 21 centimetres. Theorists predict that this absorption of the CMB should manifest as a ‘dip’ in its thermal spectrum, so while it might not be possible to study these stars by their light, astronomers should be able to locate them indirectly by using this ‘dip.’

“So we have a quest,” Peterson said. “Can we measure this dip in the spectrum?”

Armed with radio telescopes and stationed in the most far-flung places on Earth, Peterson and his team set to work.

Radio telescopes pick up on the CMB, but in most places, the signal is disrupted by FM radio waves broadcasted by radio stations and the like around the world. To escape this disruption, scientists studying the CMB have travelled to such places as the Australian Outback and Marion Island, located 2,000 kilometres south of Cape Town in the middle of the Indian Ocean.

Singling out this infinitesimal dip from the pervasive radio disturbance of the universe is no small task. Yet, in February 2018, the Experiment to Detect the Global Epoch of Reionization Signature (EDGES) team, based at the Murchison Radio-astronomy Observatory in Western Australia, reported the first possible detection of the hypothesized dip.

“There are five or six teams around the world that are trying very hard to find out [if] this [is] correct,” Peterson said. 

This announcement has generated a frenzy of speculation and excitement. Some believe that these results might prompt a reappraisal of scientists’ understanding of dark matter, the mysterious form of matter that remains undetected despite being thought to account for 85 per cent of all matter. For now, Peterson advises caution: Until another team corroborates the EDGES findings, all of the excitement remains nothing more than conjecture.

“This will explode into a giant field,” Peterson said. “It may be 50 years before we map this, but human beings will do it […] because we won’t be able to resist.”

McGill, News

Foreign Policy Panel hosted by Max Bell School wraps up elections

by Chloe Merritt on

More in McGill:

The McGill Max Bell School of Public Policy partnered with the Canadian International Council to host a talk titled “Foreign Policy and Foreign Interference: The 2019 Canadian Elections” on Oct. 17.  Jennifer Welsh, Canada 150 Research Chair in Global Governance and Security at McGill, moderated a panel of Canadian policy experts to discuss foreign policy issues and the country’s ability to address them.

Panelists discussed how foreign interference in the Canadian election may not have been as bad as it was in the 2016 United States’ election. Despite the decreased severity, Taylor Owen, Beaverbrook Chair in Media, Ethics and Communications Studies at Max Bell, described how digital infrastructure has shaped the nature of this election’s discourse. 

“I think this might be the first real social media election that [we have seen],” Owen said. “[With] the parties, the media, [and] the public all participating on this plane of relatively superficial interaction. The election was small because our debate was small.”

Rohinton Medhora, President of the Centre for International Governance Innovation, also commented on the spread of misinformation and uninformed voters. 

“If we had a thin, shallow debate on foreign issues is at least as important a fact as if the bad guys are interfering,” Medhora said. “We are woefully uninformed, from a Canadian perspective, on how the rest of the world is doing.” 

Additionally, the panelists discussed the election’s failure to address major foreign policy issues that the next government will have to manage. Medhora acknowledged that there has been plenty of discussion on major policy issues, such as Canada’s relationship with the United States and the incarceration of Canadians in China, but Canada’s foreign policy had so far failed to address allies who do not hold the same liberal values as Canada.

“We haven’t really had a deep discussion on how Canada deals with countries like China [….] who do not share our heritage values,” Medhora said. 

When it comes to the trend of nations slipping towards non-democratic regimes, Marie-Joëlle Zahar Political Science Professor and Director of the Research Network on Peace Operations at the Université de Montréal, argued that Canada needs to reevaluate some of its alliances. 

“We assume that we are operating in a liberal world and that therefore liberal countries are going to stand together on issues and that is not the case,” Zahar said. “It becomes more difficult to have a conversation with other countries with which we [believe] share [our] values, when in fact [we] are drifting apart.”

In response to a question about Canada’s role in protecting democracy, the panel highlighted the importance of matching Canada’s digital infrastructure to the realities of foreign policy.

“There have always been foreign powers in campaigns and in elections,” Owen said. “We need to focus on the [digital] infrastructure itself and how we make it as democratic and transparent as possible. If we do that, [then] we will reveal the actors that are attempting to manipulate us.”

The panelists also admitted that it is unclear why Canada has not seen the same democratic backsliding as is prominent in other Western countries.

“We have a firm sense of ourselves as internationalists,” Zahar said. “We are not a country that goes it alone. Not committing to unilateralism […] is a good check against authoritarianism.”

Regardless, Medhora emphasized the importance of Canada’s foreign policy despite its size on the world stage.

“Canada, even if it might be a small player, should not shy away from doing something,” Medhora said. “We were two per cent of the war effort in World War II, that didn’t stop us from joining the war. [….] Small countries [like Canada] can contribute [to global discourse], and they should.”

 

MLB World Series
Baseball, Sports

2019 World Series Preview

by Miya Keilin on

More in Baseball:

The 2019 World Series begins Oct. 22, when the Houston Astros host the Washington Nationals at Minute Maid Park. The Nationals, who had never won a playoff series before 2019, are undoubtedly the underdog: Their 93–69 regular season record was only second-best in the National League (NL) East and 14 wins worse than the Astros. Nevertheless, the team has captured the hearts of many baseball fans this postseason, from taking down the Los Angeles Dodgers in the NL Division Series (NLDS) to fun antics from 20-year-old Juan Soto, who has to drink grape juice instead of champagne with his teammates to celebrate because he’s still underage. On the other hand, the American League (AL) was always between the Astros and the New York Yankees, so Houston’s spot in the World Series comes as no surprise. 

Fangraphs gave the Nationals a 7.2 per cent chance of winning the World Series at the beginning of the season; by May 24, that number had fallen to just 1.5 per cent. However, the team went 73–38 for the rest of the season to clinch the first NL wild card spot. They defeated the Milwaukee Brewers 4–3 after eighth-inning heroics from Soto to advance to the NLDS against the 106-win Dodgers. It took them all five games, but the Nationals upset Los Angeles with a Howie Kendrick grand slam in the tenth inning of Game 5. Washington then dominated every moment of the NL Championship Series (NLCS) against the St. Louis Cardinals: They allowed just one run and four hits through the first two games in St. Louis before returning home to win 8–1 and 7–4 in Games 3 and 4, respectively. 

The Nationals have relied heavily on starting pitchers Stephen Strasburg, Max Scherzer, Patrick Corbin, and Anibal Sánchez and relievers Daniel Hudson and Sean Doolittle, so their extra four days of rest are a critical factor. Beyond Hudson and Doolittle, however, their bullpen is lacking, so they will need long outings from their starters for a chance at the title. Elsewhere, they have solid players in Soto, Trea Turner, Anthony Rendon, and Victor Robles, but their lineup is otherwise unremarkable. 

If the tale of a team that went from a .392 win percentage to NL champions in five months is not compelling enough for fans wondering who to root for in the 2019 World Series, perhaps their quasi anthem is. Since Gerardo Parra made the Billboard Hot 100 single “Baby Shark” his walkup song in mid-June, Washington has gone all-in. From the little shark keychain hanging in their dugout to adult fans wearing shark costumes to games, “Baby Shark” has an awesome presence at Nationals Park, which has got to be worth something.  

The Astros have a kid-friendly creature of their own: Their mascot Orbit is notorious for playing pranks on opposing teams’ players. However, they also have arguably one of the best teams of all time. Fangraphs gave them a 17.8 per cent chance to win it all before the season even began and a 35.2 per cent chance before the start of the playoffs. 

The Astros have few weaknesses. Starting pitchers Gerrit Cole and Justin Verlander have been lights-out from the mound, and though Zach Greinke has had two bad outings this postseason, he is still a good option to turn to. AL MVP candidate Alex Bregman owns the second-highest Wins Above Replacement by Baseball Reference (bWAR) in the league, and George Springer, Jose Altuve, Michael Brantley, and Yuli Gurriel all put up strong offensive numbers this season. Josh Reddick, Robinson Chirinos, and AL Rookie of the Year candidate Yordan Álvarez have been struggling in the postseason, however. 

According to Fangraphs, the Astros have a 72.1 per cent chance of winning, but Soto and the Nationals will not go down easily. This series will feature outstanding pitching performances, late-inning dramatics, and a lot of emotion. Ultimately, the Astros will claim their second World Series title.  

Emerging Trends, Student Life, The Viewpoint

The problem with true crime

by Anna Mackay on

More in Emerging Trends:

As cooler weather approaches, many McGill students will replace evenings on a terrasse with evenings spent watching Netflix; they will store their bikes and begin spending bus rides listening to podcasts. These shifts raise an important issue: The increasing demand for true crime media, which promotes violence as a source of entertainment, often with little regard for victims. True crime media has become astoundingly popular in the last five years, and this is particularly true for college-age individuals like McGill students. Despite criticism, many people continue to tune into true crime media because of the thrill they provide.

In 2014, the true crime podcast Serial became the podcast to hit five million downloads on iTunes the fastest, a “flagship moment” for a genre that had previously been viewed as sensationalist and not-quite mainstream. In the five years since, true crime media has become incredibly popular, with Spotify listing over 100 different podcasts in its true crime category and Netflix churning out critically acclaimed docuseries and full-length films focusing on real life tragedies. Many of these are characterized as “highbrow” true crime, which satisfies consumers’ desire for drama while taking an investigative journalism approach, portraying true crime not as a guilty pleasure, but as a legitimate and intelligent genre.

Some of these shows are well-executed, exploring larger issues of justice and who is allowed access to it. On the other hand, the very nature of the genre makes it fundamentally flawed. True crime provides consumers with an adrenaline rush and feeling of suspense that keeps them hooked on the genre, and the drive to create addictive content can be directly opposed to the objectivity required for credible journalism. Making a Murderer, a hugely popular Netflix-produced true crime miniseries, has been criticized for its strategic omissions in attempts to prove the accused’s innocence, framing the show as a quest for justice while lacking neutrality. 

Even more worrying are the fans that are eager to try and impose justice themselves and take part in investigating as if it were a game, as is evidenced by multiple Facebook pages for these communities. It’s easy for these shows to compose a certain narrative because they aren’t supposed to be sources of news, but rather sources of entertainment. This gives them a certain license to stretch the truth, but the contortion of someone’s real and painful experiences into a compelling ‘whodunit’ is disrespectful to victims and their families.

Experts have found a variety of reasons for true crime obsessions. Humans have evolved to pay attention to things that can hurt us, and feel a sense of relief when we remain unscathed, even if there is no imminent danger. This makes true crime both compelling and somewhat rewarding. Trying to solve true crime mysteries satisfies our need for solutions, providing us with proxy closure for all the problems in our environment—like mass shootings, terrorism, and a flawed justice system—that we cannot solve. Additionally, the consumption of true crime can subconsciously act as a preventative measure for people, especially women. Being able to detect traits or patterns of killers seems like a way to avoid them, and avoid being murdered.

Despite the natural reasons for our attraction to true crime, we shouldn’t let psychology excuse a lack of empathy and respect. Highbrow true crime obscures its shock value with intellect, so it is crucial that consumers make a conscious effort to face their attraction to violence and reflect on its dehumanizing effects. Increased exposure to violence can decrease our sensitivity to it, and when stories and images of violence are so proliferous in the news, any immunity to it is an implicit acceptance of its place in society. There is no way to be an informed citizen without being occasionally exposed to images and stories of violence and evil, but they should not be something that’s actively sought out for enjoyment. 

Whether a consumer indulges in true crime to avoid harm, simplify a more complicated world, or just for a thrill, doing so requires a degree of self-awareness. There is no reason to view violence and injustice with anything but an empathetic eye, so make sure that the next time you sit down to unwind from midterms with a true crime show, you see it for what it is: A narrative of real-life suffering for your entertainment.

Out on the Town, Student Life

Exploring Les Quartiers du Canal

by Corrina Greenler on

More in Out on the Town:

Les Quartiers du Canal consists of three neighbourhoods: Griffintown, Little Burgundy, and Saint-Henri. Situated along the popular Lachine Canal in southwest Montreal, the historically industrial area is quickly becoming a collection of trendy neighbourhoods, each with their own unique character. The McGill Tribune compiled some of the exhibits, restaurants, cafés, and shops to explore throughout the neighbourhoods of Les Quartiers du Canal. 

Griffintown

In the heart of the neighbourhood’s evolving landscape of old and new buildings, the Montreal Art Centre showcases work from local artists. The “Emerging Artist Exhibition” is an upcoming show that will run Nov. 16–28, displaying the work of Montreal-based artists who are new to the scene. They also offer a variety of events, from concerts to comedy shows. 

For more contemporary art, head over to Arsenal. Inside a repurposed shipyard, the space houses many exhibitions from both Canadian and international artists. This fall, the “In Conversation” series of events provide an opportunity to learn more about current artists’ collections and creative processes. 

There is no shortage of good places to eat in Griffintown. One of two locations in Montreal, Griffintown’s La Bête à Pain is a large, colourful café. Their open kitchen allows the customers to get a peek into the baking that goes on behind the scenes. La Bête à Pain serves both breakfast and lunch, along with numerous tasty pastries and breads available throughout the day. 

For an evening out, the upscale Bird Bar is best known for its unique combination of fried chicken and champagne. However, its extensive menu includes vegan options, ensuring that there is something for everyone in this restaurant. Bird Bar’s warm atmosphere and live DJ makes it a great spot to celebrate a special occasion.

Little Burgundy

While the Atwater Market and Corona Theatre are popular staples of this neighbourhood, many visitors overlook the many antique shops along rue Notre-Dame. Wander into Milord Antiquites Inc. for a one of a kind collection of furniture spanning three centuries, or try Baronne de l’Insolite to find an eclectic mix of old and modern decor, including vintage items from the 19th century and the Art Deco era.

Central to the neighbourhood, Little Burgundy has a number of unique places to grab a drink or a bite to eat. Drinkerie Ste-Cunégonde, a retro bar, is a popular evening spot for people in this neighbourhood, offering a large assortment of drinks and a terrace in the summer season. Though food options are limited, it is surrounded by restaurants and within walking distance of the canal, making it a great place to relax with a drink after a day out. Just across the street from the neighbourhood’s famed Joe Beef restaurant is Burgundy Lion, an English pub with a Montreal twist. This lively spot hosts a variety of events throughout the week. They often have soccer matches playing on their TV screens, making it a perfect place to enjoy a drink and camaraderie while cheering on your favourite team. Swing by on Monday nights to catch the bar’s weekly trivia night or try their Sunday afternoon high tea service in their year-round solarium. 

Saint-Henri

A little further from downtown, Saint-Henri offers lots of green space to relax in. The Lachine Canal is a well-known spot to enjoy views of the water and city. However, tucked between two metro stops, Parc du Premier-Chemin-de-Fer runs through the neighbourhood parallel to rue Saint-Jacques and provides a nice area for an afternoon stroll or bike ride. On a side street off of rue Notre-Dame, Librairie Saint-Henri Books is an independent bookstore that offers a wide collection of English and French books for all ages. A corner with some armchairs gives the space a homey and welcoming feel. Numerous cafés scatter Saint-Henri, but for those looking for something sweet, check out Rustique. The small café offers a wide selection of delicious cakes, pies, and cookies. Drop in to sit and enjoy a cup of coffee with a sweet treat. Rustique is best known for its excellent selection of pies, including seasonal flavors such as blueberry camerise, pumpkin, or lemon meringue.

McGill, News

Discrimination and harassment complaints double from last academic year

by Deisha Paliwal on

More in McGill:

According to the Annual Report on Policy On Harassment and Discrimination Prohibited by Law, the number of inquiries and complaints increased from 78 cases last academic year to 161 in 2018-19. In the preceding five years, there has been an average of 33 inquiries and complaints. 12 per cent of the complaints were filed on the grounds of discrimination, 45 per cent on harassment, 12 per cent on sexual harassment, and the remaining 30 per cent were classified as mixed or other. 

Initially adopted in 2006, the purpose of McGill’s Policy on Harassment and Discrimination Prohibited by Law is to establish an inclusive environment through prevention and response to harassment and discrimination. 

The university has appointed Sinead Hunt, a Senior Equity & Inclusion Advisor (SEIA) to act as the primary contact for initial inquiries and complaints. Following contacting Hunt, the individual decides between attempting an informal or formal resolution through investigation, through Senate-appointed Harassment Assessors. 

Professor Angela Campbell, Associate Provost (Equity and Academic Policies), emphasized the importance of the SEIA.

“The role of the [SEIA] is growing in scope and importance,” Campbell said. “This is a very positive development for the McGill community.”  

Harassment and discrimination reports are investigated by Assesors: However, as of October 2018, reports of sexual violence are investigated by an external Special Investigator instead, in accordance with the Policy against Sexual Violence. 

Whether the increase in harassment claims is due to an increase in complaints or higher awareness of the report is speculative. 

“I have no evidence that more people are being subject to harassment at McGill, but [I] do see awareness of [the policy] increasing,” Campbell said. 

Chloe Kemeni, Student’s Society of McGill University (SSMU) Anti-Violence Coordinator, tied the increase in complaints, in part, to campus discussions rather than policy awareness. 

“The current dialogue that has arisen from [student-driven policies and groups] has given folks the tools to define their experiences and advocate for themselves,” Kemeni said. “For those doing equity work on campus or in student governance, this is part of [our] daily discussions, but I’m not too sure that McGill has done an adequate enough job in communicating the policy in a way that is accessible to all.” 

The report also proposes a working group to ensure that the policy is implemented in an appropriate way for the university’s needs and goals; however, the group’s members are not specified. The group will undertake policy revision in the present reference year (Sept. 1 2019 – Aug. 31 2020). 

“It would be baseless to have a committee that does not have representation from racialized students who are most impacted by discrimination and harassment,” Kemeni said. “I don’t know if there is a clear cut answer to the question [of what McGill can do to reduce incidents] since at its core is a settler-colonial institution with deep ties to slavery.” 

The report also recognizes the demand to formalize the process for investigating complaints. 

“Questions arise about whether our current model, which entrusts investigations to Assessors who have full-time positions disconnected to the Policy at the University, is sustainable, especially as the number and complexity of cases arising under the Policy grow,” the report reads. 

As a result, a coordinating assessor has been assigned to this role on a full-time basis. 

The report recognizes that measures of isolation cannot transform the culture that surrounds harassment. 

“It would help to create a culture in which students feel comfortable reporting, but which also sends a signal to those enacting harm that their actions have recourse,” Kemeni said. “As of now, we tend to protect those who are most harmful, while isolating and retraumatizing those harmed.” 

McGill, News

Tribune Explains: Academic appointments

by Ezra-Jean Taylor on

More in McGill:

The intricacies of professors’ career paths often goes unnoticed by busy students. Yet, students interact with professors daily, and a positive or negative relationship with one may change a student’s life. One of the most substantial milestones a professor can achieve is academic appointment, but the process that guide appointments is complicated. By digging through the Secretariat’s website, any questions about academic appointment are answered.

What does “academic appointment” mean? 

To be academically appointed is to receive tenure as a McGill professor. This is a contract between McGill and its professors that guarantees the tenured professor’s employment. McGill’s guidelines for tenured staff explains that professors can either be “tenure tracked” for a definite term, in which they are then considered for re-appointment, or tenured indefinitely. 

In 2017, there were 1,664 tenure-tracked and tenured professors at McGill according to the McGill University Staffing Report. While almost half of the academic staff employed by McGill are women, they are underrepresented in the university’s tenured population. In the same report, 45 per cent of academic staff reported that they were women; In contrast, women made up 32 per cent of tenure-track and tenured professors.

What are the benefits of tenure?

Achieving tenure allows professors the freedom to explore areas of scholarly interest without the stress of an immediate deadline or fear of exploring controversial research topics. At the same time, the tenured professor cannot be employed by a different university or employer and must maintain the same quality of work as when they were appointed. This allows McGill to attract high-achieving professors that can produce valuable research under the university’s name. 

What are the responsibilities of tenured staff?

Academically appointed professors are responsible for three major tasks at McGill. First, they are required to teach either lectures, seminars, or supervise individual students. Second, they must participate in research. Research can take many forms, but McGill professors are required to produce and publish academic work throughout their appointment at McGill. Third, professors must commit time to other communities at McGill, such as by participating in clubs, speaking at events, or sitting on academic committees. 

How does one become appointed? 

Achieving tenure starts with being nominated by their academic department head. If the nomination is approved by the dean of their faculty, the professor’s name is submitted to the Provost, who decides if the professor should be appointed or not. If they are successfully appointed, the first position that they hold is that of Associate Professor. Associate professors are on tenure-track for between three and four years. The professor is then considered for full tenure by the Departmental Tenure Committee, the University Tenure Committee, and the Principal. The group evaluates the dossier of material compiled by the professor and external evaluators to decide if the professor meets the standards for full tenure or should be given deferred tenure consideration.

1 … 460 461 462 463 464 … 1,367

Read the latest issue

Read the latest issue